Wellington [change] Weather home
 
10°C Max: 15°C
Min: 8°C
Full forecast

NZ among worst countries for crime

Last updated 07:16 20/03/2008

Relevant offers

New Zealand is perceived correctly as a place with high levels of violent crime, Sensible Sentencing Trust spokesman Garth McVicar said after New Zealand scored highly an international crime survey.

New Zealand scored highest for thefts from cars, second highest for burglary, fifth highest for assaults, 10th highest for robbery and 11th highest for theft of personal property and for sexual assaults against women in The International Crime Victims Survey. The survey compared 30 countries in 2004 and 2005.

New Zealand also scored highly for supporting victims and had the highest perception of police performance.

Mr McVicar said he had not examined the survey in detail but he was picking up that New Zealand was perceived as a place with high levels of violent crime when he travelled internationally.

The murder of Karen Aim in Taupo this year had highlighted the issue.

"New Zealand is gradually, sadly, becoming the attention of focus in a lot of these issue," he said.

He had done a lot of interviews with foreign media during the investigation of Ms Aim's murder.

"We are getting a lot more knife attacks, a lot more baseball bat attacks," he said.

National's Justice spokesman Simon Power said New Zealand compared poorly with other countries.

On average an estimated 16 percent of the population of 30 nations in the survey have been a victim of at least one of 10 common crimes in the survey.

The highest victimisation rates were in Ireland, England and Wales, New Zealand and Iceland.

The lowest overall victimisation rates were found in Spain, Japan, Hungary and Portugal.

Theft of cars was highest in countries with high car ownership levels and low alternative means of transport. New Zealand was among them.

On average, 1.8 percent of households in the 30 countries saw their houses burgled in the 12-month period.

This type of crime was most common in England, Wales, New Zealand, Mexico and Denmark.

Johannesburg had victimisation rates for assaults and threats of more than 10 percent.

New Zealand was at 4 percent but rates below 1 percent were found in Portugal, Italy and Japan.

The proportion of victims of serious crimes with support needs who were actually contacted by Victim Support was the highest in New Zealand, at 47 percent.

Public satisfaction with police in New Zealand was the highest in the survey.

"Being the third-worst for the prevalence of all the most common crime is bad enough, but being the fifth worst for assaults and threats and 11th for sexual assaults on women is very concerning," Mr Power said.

Ad Feedback

"Labour has failed to deal to crimes against people, with these figures showing that crime is now much nastier."

Mr Power said it was great to see New Zealand ranked among the highest for public satisfaction with the police, reporting rates of victims and satisfaction of victims with how police dealt with reported crime.

"But this is all after the crime has been committed. After nine years of Labour are Kiwis any safer? These figures show we are not."

- NZPA

58 comments
James Burnett   #58   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

The missing statistics are the number of crimes solved by the Police. Their overall average is 38%. That is very bad. The messages sent to crims is that they have a good chance of getting away with it.

Just imagine that if we as the public became extreemly intolerant of crime, and forced some action so that Police solved 80% of all crime. What would happen is that the number of crimes committed in all catagories would dramatically drop. NZ would become a safe country to live in.

So we must focus on the failure of Police to protect us. The best way is to put pressure on politicians of all parties. And especially in an election year.

maryann A.   #57   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

how does lima, peru rank with world crime?

Owen   #56   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Statistics like these are somewhat flawed, any introductory criminology course will show you this. Statistics are primarily recorded by police, who record criminal acts at their own discretion or do not record crimes at all (or perhaps in New Zealand's case, the opposite may be true). These high numbers could simply reflect pro-active policing, especially recently with a focus on violence against women and children... if the police focus on violent crimes then more of these crimes will show up in statistics, showing a perceived "increase" in crimes of a violent nature.

Janice   #55   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

For a small country, we have some seriously large issues that need to be dealt with, not merely discussed. Our young appear to be more bored with life and apallingly violent. I think boy/girl racers should be stopped with simple "unlawful assembly" legislation. Stop pussy-footing around with fines they never pay, arrest them and crush their cars in a mobile car-crusher... on the spot, instant consequence for them all to witness. More police should be on the beat to pick up taggers, more money should be provided to the RSPCA to prosecute those who are cruel to animals... ASPCA in the USA have police powers as they recognise that this kind of thing escalates to more violent crime. And for the drug takers out there, stop wasting resources on them, if they want to slowly kill themselves, let them, the resources would be better deployed in the really serious stuff that's ruining our lovely country.

Wayne Thomson   #54   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Why don't the people above read the The International Crime Victims Survey link in the story. All your questions would be answered.

Kiwi in London   #53   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Try living in South London for a perspective on violent crime ... not fun!

Tim   #52   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Numero Uno for police satisfaction? Surely that means a higher level of reporting is going on if we have such faith in our police force. If you didn't trust the police, would you report the crime? Perhaps this accounts for some of the higher crime stats for NZ.

dianne haist   #51   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

What a surprise! (said sarcastically) This report actually puts paid to our notion of NZ as a 'safe country', as often expressed by our international students, doesn't it? I have been a victim of crime (house and car burglary) and last year, my young tourist friend was assaulted in Taupo. The so-called satisfaction with the police must be questioned, as the actual report does not say that exactly. Also, very few people (about 2000 random globally) responded to the report. Personally, my philosophy has been that crime-wise, 9/10 people are good and maybe 1/10 are bad but when I read in the Manawatu Standard about all the arrests made every weekend (once there were 48 in Palmerston North), I wonder why some of our citizens who live in such a nice city as ours, can be so dismal in their behaviour. Have we become just too damn liberal about letting the level of such violence escalate and hurt our society? It seems that our justice system is far too lenient with crims, at the expense of their current and future victims. So do we shrug and say, oh well that is the way of the world now? Actually it is time to say enough is enough and demand that our society improve. Does your local member of parliament have any suggestion in this matter to take up at parliament level?

John Hudson   #50   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

I had my car stolen once and caught the culprit 3 months later driving in my car. I managed to get the police to accompany me and he was subsequently arrested after threatening me. When the officer rang me to come and collect my car back from the police. I was told that the motor in the car was not mine and that the thieves were willing to sell it to me for $400. My other option was to have the motor removed. I was told by the police that they could not commit a crime to solve a crime. I got my car back by paying the thieves $400. It seemed to me that the police helped the thieves. 'Police and thieves in the street... Oh yeah' The Clash.

Den   #49   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

You've seen the movie Battle Royale too many times... Where disobedient kids are put on a bus and sent for armed combat against each other, in some dystopian future. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0266308/


Show 1-48 of 58 comments
Special offers
Opinion poll

Is the Government managing the economy well?

Yes

No

Not sure

Vote Result

Related story: Support for economic direction wavering

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

The Little Things

The Little Things

Kept that to yourself

Dilbert

Dilbert

No way to be sure

Omnivore blog pointer small

The Omnivore: Jeremy Taylor on food

The Pan-Asian restaurant phenomenon

Car Club small pointer

The Car Club blog: Powered by Autocar NZ

Future shocks for EV makers

Roil travel blog pointer small

Roil Around the World: Amy's roving

My five literary stowaways

F5 blog pointer small

F5: Henry Cooke blogs about the internet

Why future politicians are screwed

Blog on the tracks

Blog on the Tracks: Simon Sweetman on music

Guest blog: The D-Bag: A career in (baffling) details

All you need to know about what's happening in Auckland now

Auckland news, sport, entertainment and more

All you need to know about what's happening in Auckland now

What do the stars have in store for you today?

Horoscopes

What do the stars have in store for you today?

Test your knowledge with our daily crossword

Crosswords

Test your knowledge with our daily crossword

sudoku

Sudoku

Rev up your mind with our numbers game