Beautiful, baby

BY DONNELLE BELANGER-TAYLOR
Last updated 09:05 03/09/2010

I have to admit that I was horrified to read this story about a 14-year-old with (semi-permanent) makeup tattoos.  The concept of makeup tattoos in general creeps me out, but on a 14-year-old?  Ick. The worst part, to me, is that it was done with her mother's blessing.

PollI guess I'm probably not typical, in that I'm a woman in her 30s who doesn't own a single item of makeup (that makes me sound more hippy-crunchy-hairy-legged than it should; I never learned to use it, and I came to terms with the fact that my looks aren't my strong point long ago, so what's the point?) but ugh!  It viscerally disturbed me that someone could support the whole superficiality industry to the point of letting someone stick needles next to their child's eyes in the name of beauty.  Still, I was pleased to see that 78 per cent of the people answering the poll agreed 14 is too young.  I wonder what the results would have been if the question was simply "Are makeup tattoos utterly creepy?"

The 14-year-old in question got it done because she competes in beauty pageants.  At 14 is one thing, but I find it even worse when it's four-, six-, eight-year-olds.  This is the integral attitude they're being set up with for life - that appearance is all that matters, that it should be all-consuming.  It's the fakeness of it all; kids in thick makeup, looking like they're wearing carlashes.

And if that wasn't bad enough, pageants seem to unleash a storm of truly abhorrent photo "retouching".  Don't go there if you suffer from either pedophobia or pediophobia (fear of children or dolls... it's hard to tell the difference sometimes).

So what are your thoughts?  If your child wanted makeup tattoos, at what age would you let them?  Would you let them compete in a beauty pageant?

» Follow PG on Facebook

47 comments
Post a comment
alison   #1   09:10 am Sep 03 2010

very very disturbing! and the wee kiddies look 100% more gorgeous in the before shots.

Lil Miss Trouble   #2   09:15 am Sep 03 2010

I would never let my child get make-up tattoos, when she is old enough to not need my consent to get a tattoo then it will be up to her and thats fine but never as a child. Ears and belly button piercing is ok cause they can be removed, tattoos are permanant.

Beauty pagents are not really my thing but if my daughter wanted to do it for fun then sure why not.

Pix   #3   09:36 am Sep 03 2010

you should check out youtube and see that 14 year old girl - she's also in photoshoots that show her just wearing a g-string and bra! it's disgusting that her mother allows this

tasha   #4   09:37 am Sep 03 2010

scars from piercings are permanent. and i take it semi permanent means they come off in time- what's the problem? better that than real ones that they may regret later- and yes teens can get them without consent. better to know i say

Andrea   #5   09:39 am Sep 03 2010

totally 2nded from another women in her 30's with not a single item of make-up!

I think it's the saddest thing when I see young girls (especially babies - why would you hurt them on purpose???) with pierced ears?

What kind of message does it send to say to such young children that they would look better, or be improved by changing themselves?

Kids these days apparently have the lowest self esteem in recorded history (toxic childhood, Sue Palmer), I really think the pressure of appearances constantly bombarded by media etc is a significant part of that.

Society as a whole would be better off if we were all more accepting of our looks & the media could portray a range of "beauty" as seen by different cultures, not just the tall, skinny, blonde, straight haired women that are so ubiquitous.

The very fact that you even say, Donelle, that your looks are not your strong point is a sad indictment of the expectation that women should be good at everything and hot as well.

In any case, from the few photos I've seen of you, I think you look great! Very natural and happy, which I also think is a huge thing for your childrens self esteem, as a confident mother is the best indicator for her childrens future esteem.

Another awesome blog post! Thanks!

Fern   #6   09:40 am Sep 03 2010

Like you Donnelle, I was alot creeped out by this story!! If my child came to me and asked for that, my stipulations would be similar to my mothers view on Tattoos - you can as long as you are not living under my roof and are over 18.. Except I would say over 25, only because I look back at 18 and think that some of the decisions I made then weren't .. mature... But beauty pageants... Depends. We aren't as extreme as overseas countries, and it would be nice when they are in their teens.. But I'd say that any kids I have with my current partner would be too busy in the outdoors & sports to even have time to contemplate that!!

Alice2   #7   09:58 am Sep 03 2010

18. I'll consent to piercings at pretty much any age, but tattoos are something you take on yourself once you've reached majority.

@Lil Miss Trouble, from my understanding, most makeup tattoos these days are done with semi-permanent inks, that are meant to last only a few years. There were quite a few people who got stuck with awful fashion makeup tattoos in the early days. Still, not something I'd enter into lightly, especially the idea of tattoo needles doing eyeliner, eep!

JCC   #8   10:27 am Sep 03 2010

I find the thought of makeup tattoos really disturbing! As i understand it, she got 'eyeliner' and 'lip liner' done -doesn't this now set her up for a lifetime of having to wear makeup, cos it looks like she's got some on already? I'm like you Donnelle, and oh so rarely wear the stuff (weddings and Very Important occasions) and that's my choice. Now she can never have the choice to go au natural, which (i'm presuming) would be an outrageously unthinkable thing for her mother to do -so women can't even go to the letterbox without a full 'face' on!

n   #9   10:31 am Sep 03 2010

I don't think girls should be getting bellybutton piercings under 16. It's not a 'pretty decoration' in the sense that earrings are and they nearly always develop nasty infections (ewww soo remember this). I loved mine but I won't deny it was cause it was 'sexy pretty' not just 'oooh sparkly'. Don't have it anymore cause my body rejected it after about 4 years..

Sal   #10   10:34 am Sep 03 2010

I am regularly so disturbed by how sexualised girls become at such young ages that I genuinely hope I never have daughters. Young children should not be entering contests based on physical beauty or wearing makeup AT ALL let alone having ink injected into their bodies. Yes, in a perfect world good parenting would mean your girls don't feel the need for such things, but the fact is the media and their peers will be bombarding them with the message that their worth is entirely based on their looks and this is impossible to avoid short of moving into an Amish community.


Show 11-47 of 47 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content