Megaupload accused's multi-million dollar discrepancy

MICHELLE ROBINSON
Last updated 05:00 27/01/2012
dotcom accused
MICHAEL BRADLEY/Fairfax NZ

IN COURT: Bram van der Kolk, Finn Batato, Mathias Ortmann and Kim Dotcom.

Relevant offers

Just two of the men facing extradition to the US over the Megaupload piracy case have been granted bail, with the third asked to account for a multi-million dollar income discrepancy.

The estimated US $2.5 million discrepancy in the accounts of Mathias Ortmann, 40, from Germany, could cost him his electronic bail.

The Crown was concerned he may have access to other funds which the FBI didn't know about.

Figures from the FBI, read in court, showed Ortmann made around US $14.5mfrom the internet company between 2005 and 2010.

He made an estimated US $3m in 2011.

But his accounts showed a total income of $20.15m, Judge David McNaughton said.

"That's a massive discrepancy," he said in the North Shore District Court yesterday.

Ortmann was remanded in custody overnight as his lawyer Guyon Foley prepares an affidavit on where the estimated $2.5m came from.

Foley indicated it was from trading profits.

Meanwhile, Bram van der Kolk and Finn Batato were granted electronic bail yesterday.

But they could spend a further three weeks in custody as their homes are assessed for suitability for electronic monitoring, Judge McNaughton said.

The pair were remanded in custody until at least next Thursday while the assessments are carried out.

Van der Kolk, 29, a Dutch national, blew kisses and mouthed "I love you" and "don't worry baby" to his wife Asia who was in court to support him.

She was in tears when his bail application was approved.

"I'm just glad my husband is going to be able to play with our baby again,'' she said.

She was supported in court by a friend, Amber Moltzer, who said the situation had been a "nightmare".

"We didn't know what to expect."

Batato, 38, from Germany, also has a fiancé back home and there were initially concerns that he would flee there and be immune from extradition as there is no agreement between the US and Germany.

Batato, Van der Kolk and Ortmann were arrested, along with Kim Dotcom, in a raid on the Megaupload founder's mansion in Auckland a week ago today.

Dotcom was this week denied bail as there were fears he would flee the country.

The men, and three others, face five charges laid in an indictment by a US grand jury in Virginia.

Ortmann's electronic bail application hinges on his ability to explain where the unaccounted sum came from.

"This is the tipping point for bail, if it's not sorted I'll decline it," Judge McNaughton said.

"If everything's not adequate with the accountant, and there's substantial amounts available to him, and given his crucial position with the business.

"Whichever way I consider it, I'm forced to the conclusion to decline bail."

Ortmann's lawyer Guyon Foley said Ortmann told him the additional income was from trading profits.

"You'd get a bit of interest on $12 million over the years."

Judge McNaughton asked for Foley to file an affidavit and a hearing will be held tomorrow afternoon.

Yesterday afternoon a picture was posted on Dotcom's Facebook page with the message ''Thx for the support plz share and think about it''.

Beneath the message were two pictures showing Dotcom and another man in the dock. Above the Dotcom picture it said: Sharing music on the internet. Below it said: 50 years.

Ad Feedback

The other picture said: Killed, raped and burned women to death. Below it said: 20 years.

- Auckland Now

Special offers
Opinion poll

Are you happy with the council rates revaluation on your home?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

News tip POINTER

Do you have an idea for a story? Email us or give us a call on 09 925 9700.