Air NZ wins case against pilots

JOSH MARTIN
Last updated 15:22 22/01/2014

Relevant offers

Better Business

Why a lack of sleep makes you a bad boss Two men fined over illegal rubbish dump in Hawera What does having a messy desk say about you? New Zealand Post reports $141m profit and parcel growth as letters decline Job security and flexibility - a key to addressing the gender gap Trade week aims to help plug New Zealand skill shortage Managing the chief executive: CEOs need performance agreements too Loathe your job in your 20s or 30s? That may hurt your health by your 40s Five ways to tell you're on the right career path Staff member stood down as police investigate $700k missing from Taranaki energy infrastructure company

Air New Zealand has won an Employment Relations Authority (ERA) case against its main pilots union over the transfer of better pay conditions offered to members of a rival union.

The New Zealand Air Line Pilots Association (NZALPA) accused Air New Zealand of breaching its collective employment agreement with them by not transferring "more favourable" conditions when the airline bargained with the Federation of Air New Zealand Pilots (FANZP), a smaller union.

The ruling effectively bans the NZALPA from cherry-picking higher pay and better conditions if they are offered to FANZP-aligned pilots.

The employment spat came down to the use of the word "agreement" which Air New Zealand's lawyers said meant an entire collective employment agreement, but NZALPA said meant any particular clause of a rival collective agreement.

The ERA said in its ruling that the airline could not budget or negotiate properly without knowing if pilots from the larger NZALPA would pick out certain parts of the alternative FANZP collective agreement.

NZALPA told the ERA that the underpinning issue was that there was not a level playing field in negotiations between the airline and the two unions.

Captain Garth McGearty, a former industrial director of NZALPA, told the ERA the FANZP negotiations used the "leverage" offered by the earlier collective bargaining efforts of the NZALPA.

McGearty said the two unions were "philosophically different" in that FANZP focused on getting higher salaries whereas NZALPA focused on a more collective approach, seeking a better work-life balance for pilots.

McGearty said the larger union was shedding members who defected to the better-paid FANZP.

Air New Zealand spokeswoman Brigitte Ransom said the airline " welcomes the ERAs determination".

The ERA ruled costs would be mediated between the two parties.

Ad Feedback

- Fairfax Media

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content