Succession success for farming family at Porangahau

A Porangahau farming family is less than 18 months away from owning their family farm, despite a huge slip taking a chunk out of their budget. They spoke to Kate Taylor.

Helen and Wade Stoddart on Arataura Station at Porangahau
Kate Taylor

Helen and Wade Stoddart on Arataura Station at Porangahau

The wind is starting to pick up as lunch is served on a hot summer's day at Arataura Station.

That's not a good sign for Wade and Helen Stoddart as the farm has so far kept a tinge of green unlike a large swathe of Hawke's Bay.

Arataura's downfall is the wind.

Romney cryptorchid sheep on a pasja crop on Arataura Station at Porangahau.
Kate Taylor

Romney cryptorchid sheep on a pasja crop on Arataura Station at Porangahau.

"We get the equinox winds in October and March," Wade says.

"But usually not October through to March," Helen adds.


Cattle graze on Arataura Station in Central Hawke's Bay.
Kate Taylor

Cattle graze on Arataura Station in Central Hawke's Bay.

When a deal was done on a handshake

This farming mum's in charge
Hawke's Bay coastal hills a test for organics
Hill country station offers a clean canvas

Arataura is as far south as Hawke's Bay goes – half the farm is in the Hawke's Bay Regional Council catchment and the other half in the Horizons region. The main access for the neighbouring property, Tautane, is from Herbertville.

Wade Stoddart spends every free moment on the dozer fixing the aftermath of a huge earthflow on Arataura Station.
Kate Taylor

Wade Stoddart spends every free moment on the dozer fixing the aftermath of a huge earthflow on Arataura Station.

The Stoddarts live 20 minutes from Porangahau, which is where Sophie, 8, and Charlie, 6, go to school. Three-year-old Max is still at home with Helen.

Ad Feedback

Wade's been back working on the 830ha family farm (715ha effective) for 17 years and has been managing it for his parents Mark and Chris Stoddart for the past 12. Official succession has been marked in the dairies for June 2018, which includes plans for his two brothers, Guy and Sam, and their families.

"They're both on similar-sized farms as well – one next door and one at Mangaorapa. We operate under one cheque book at the moment but we farm separately. Mum and Dad have moved to Porangahau Beach although Dad still works full time on Arataura. He's still a valued part of the day-to-day operations here. After the businesses split he'll work between the three blocks as needed."

Mark and Chris bought Arataura 1977 when a third of it was covered with scrub with no woolshed, no house and only seven paddocks.

"It's all developed now with Dad and my grandfather spending winters fencing and summers cutting and pushing out scrub and turning over paddocks. It was a big development programme to start with.

"Mum and Dad went on to buy another three farms over the years – a total of 2230ha. They scrimped and saved to get three boys into farms. We are lucky they thought about the next generation like that. I only hope we can do it for our kids."

Arataura Station has a large amount of mature native bush and two QEII National Trust covenants – a 5ha block near the house that was covenanted 10 years ago and a 25ha block covenanted three years ago that is one of the longest sections of fenced and QEII-protected coastline in New Zealand.

"That block is mainly flax and contains the cliffs separating the farm from the sea. There's also another 30ha area of mature bush that has been fenced and retired for about 30 years, including a huge matai that's about 500 years old and towers about two-thirds above the canopy of the other trees."

The couple have been planting 200-400 trees a year, although the survival rates are low because of the wind and summer dry. This has dropped to 150-200 while they spend money on new novaflow drainage.

The stock ratio on the 715ha (effective) property is 80:20 sheep to cattle running 9.5 stock units to the hectare.

Romneys are bought from Hildreth Romneys in Hawke's Bay and angus genetics are bought from a mixture of Central Hawke's Bay breeders. They calve 160 angus cows with the top 55 steers sold to Anzco's Five Star Beef feedlot as soon as they're weaned.

"In the past three years they've averaged 284kg off mum and the weaner steers last year netted $1020," he says, with a glance at his notebook.

For the past three years, 3300 romney ewes have docked 151 per cent (ewes to the ram) with a scanning percentage of 169 per cent without counting triplets. All sheep are killed at Alliance in Dannevirke with 700-800 of the lambs sent off mum before Christmas along with 600 cull ewes that have been put to suftex rams and lambed three weeks earlier than the main mob.

"Our springs don't really hit until early November so our lambs battle to get underway when a lot of our mates at Wanstead or wherever have got rid of twice as many. But now we make it up. They're brown as anything and we're still green."

"Touch wood it stays like that," Helen adds quickly.

Wade says they have tried hogget and heifer mating with no real success.

"Our paddocks are too big and we can't fence more because of that ground movement. We found our romneys weren't mature enough early enough. Plus it gives us another class of stock in a year like this. The ewe lambs are out the back and they're getting pinched at the moment."

They've also been breeding for the weaner market for so long the average birthweight is too high even when using low-birthweight bulls.

With the help of Wade's father Mark on the tractor, 15-20 hectares are turned over every year.

"We put in a winter crop such as kestrel kale and swedes to finish the cull ewe lambs, then a summer crop such as pasja for finishing the male lambs then grass. It takes the pressure off the rest of the farm."

Annual fertiliser costs are $12-$16 a stock unit.

"Between 250-500kg of sulphur super is applied a year depending on what we can afford, but we never cut back, so it's at least 250kg every year no matter what."

The economic farm surplus (EFS) for the past three years, excluding interest, was $450 a hectare.

Wade and Helen have also been sharefarming another 400ha next door to Arataura for six years with Richard and Jean Kibblewhite. It carries 500-700 dairy cows in winter from three farms in Kumeroa, Norsewood and Dannevirke.

"We set stock at two to the hectare with plenty of cover and we clean up with steers once they're gone. They put on at least a condition score while they're here."

"We usually have 400-500 steers on there, sometimes grazing for my brothers or for Arataura, but charging normal grazing charges. We dabble in buying cattle when they're cheap, which has panned out well. One year 100 steers bought for $400 were killed for $2300."

"When it works, it works," Helen says.

"It's not like that every year unfortunately but it has been a lifesaver some years and could well still be this year."


Winter 2014 was an exceptionally wet season and the hillside giving access to Arataura Station couldn't hold the water any longer.

"There was so much weight behind the slip the pine trees at the bottom were moving standing up," Wade Stoddart says.

"We were watching it happen, almost in slow motion I guess, but it was so waterlogged there wasn't much we could do to stop it moving."

Wade and Helen Stoddart take over the family farm in June next year but Mother Nature has been determined not to make it an easy ride with repairs to a 1.5km earthflow costing them more than $50,000.

The money spent fixing the massive slip has paused many of Wade and Helen's development plans.

"We have a certain amount of debt to pay off every year so we've only been doing a certain amount of fencing and everything anyway, but we never scrimp on fertiliser and make sure the principal and interest on the mortgage is paid off. Anything left over is spent on fencing… or in this case, slip repairs."

Two summers later, the pools of water have disappeared and most of the weight behind the slip has gone.

"The slip is about 1.5km long, maybe even 2km, and about 400 metres wide. We brought a contractor in to put a cutting through the hill and filled hollows with culverts. The whole job cost about $50,000 as well as the work we did ourselves, such as carting our own metal."

As soon as it was dry enough to be worked, the contractor's digger worked solidly for eight weeks. "We'd also had our own digger and dozer for four years and they were ideal while the earthflow was in its earlier stages because we were clearing the road almost every day as we went in and out."

Even now, every time Wade has a few spare hours he's on his dozer flattening out the paddock to have novoflow installed through it for drainage before being resown.

"We're using the novoflow in other places as well to stop the natural springs from making the hillsides too heavy."

The soils are mostly bentonite. The negative side of that is the movement of the ground that lead to the slip but on the positive side, it also holds moisture well for the summer.

The five year average rainfall on the farm is 1400mm but last year only 1185mm of rain fell.

"That's my first year that I've gone through winter without the dams filling up. The biggest worry this year was not having that stock water before the summer."

The hillside that has disappeared with the earthflow had started buckling after a low-pressure system had hung over Central Hawke's Bay for over a month.

"It was constant wet with no wind. There had been a bit of movement on the hill, which has our driveway right across, so we took some of the stuff out of the house and got into the habit of leaving a car at the top of the hill in case the slip let go."

Helen says they clearly remember the weekend the slip let go because they were in Napier for an All Black/Argentina rugby match.

"It was so bad when we left on the Friday, we knew we would have to be out of the house for a few months. But Wade's dad phoned on the Sunday and said there was a 40-foot drop on the driveway."

They stayed in an old shearers' quarters through the summer but that became tougher with three young children as the nights closed in. They spent close to two years in borrowed holiday accommodation at the nearby Whangaehu Beach settlement at the bottom of the farm.

"We feel for the guys in Christchurch and Kaikoura," Wade says.

"We know what it feels like not being able to get into your own house."



Ad Feedback
special offers
Ad Feedback