SCF case lifts fraud to record high

Last updated 08:13 04/12/2012
Getty Images
RECORD: Over $1.7 billion of fraud cases hit the courts in the six months, up from $80 million for the same period last year.

Relevant offers


Weight Watchers campaign joins list of PR blunders Opportunist builders, dodgy steel and shonky standards create new building crisis 'worse than leaky homes' Skills shortage results in firms looking internally to fill roles, recruitment firm says Pumpkin Patch in trading halt - too much debt, not enough capital British American Tobacco offers to buy Reynolds in US$47 billion deal Backlog of defective buildings and shoddy workmanship sparks calls for building warranties Ikea NZ Facebook page set up: Is it finally coming to NZ? Auckland Council and contractors ordered to pay $120,000 to the family of killed rubbish truck worker 71yo asked to stand on hot water cylinder to plug in phone after bizarre UFB install Tuanz welcomes Vodafone offer to keep internet users connected

Fraud hit a record high earlier this year and the pending trial of directors and accountants of South Canterbury Finance is New Zealand's largest-ever fraud prosecution.

According to KPMG's six-monthly fraud barometer, $1.73 billion of fraud cases hit the courts in the six months to June, up from $80 million for the same period last year.

But the figures were skewed by the SCF case, which alleges bad and related-party loans were hidden from investors and the Government.

The SCF collapse triggered a $1.7b taxpayer bailout of investors, but the Serious Fraud Office alleged the company would never have qualified for the guarantee scheme if its true financial position had been declared.

KPMG's forensic services manager, Blair Bulloch, said the scale of the alleged fraud at SCF, nearly 1 per cent of GDP, makes it the largest fraud prosecution the country has seen.

The size of the case swamped the $30.8m of fraud from other sources recorded by the barometer.

"When SCF went into the Crown Retail Deposits Guarantee Scheme, ultimately it is the taxpayer that foots the bill. For everyone in the country, it's very significant," Bulloch said.

Taking SCF out of the equation, the underlying level of fraud in New Zealand appeared to have reached a plateau, he said.

"We have a relatively standard number of frauds in each period, and every once and a while we get one off the charts."

Past supersize frauds included Christchurch businessman Gavin Bennett's $106m loan fraud, and banker Stephen Versalko's theft of $18.6m from his employer.

If the SCF case were excluded from the latest figures, it would have been the lowest reading on the barometer since June 2009. The incidence of fraud, and related prosecutions, rose sharply as the hangover to the global financial crisis took hold.

Most of the cases were management frauds perpetuated against government and financial institutions.

Finance company prosecutions appeared to have wound right down, with the only major one remaining being a Serious Fraud Office decision on whether to prosecute figures involved in Hanover Finance.

However, this return to "normal" levels of fraud did not mean people should let down their guard, Bulloch said.

Ad Feedback



Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content