Aussie councils win fight against S&P

Last updated 14:58 05/11/2012

Relevant offers

World

ANZ accused of racial bigotry towards billionaires Pankaj and Radhika Oswal It costs $221 to buy a dozen eggs in Venezuela right now Family feud: Sydney teenagers in legal battle over $96 million fortune Air NZ faces 'imponderable' decision of whether to stick with Virgin Australian worker sacked for having a cup of coffee on the job Virgin Australia wants to get more out of China, signs deal with HNA Aviation AMP looks to ban loans to foreign buyers in Australia HSBC introduces stricter rules for safety-deposit boxes in Hong Kong UK cancer researchers' retirement funds invested in tobacco industry Apple still trying to break into TV but faces plenty of roadblocks

Australian municipal councils that lost millions on structured finance products have successfully sued investment bank ABN Amro, credit rating agency Standard & Poor’s and the finance company they bought them from, Local Government Financial Services (LGFS).

The 12 councils lost A$16 million (NZ$20m) on the constant proportion debt obligations, marketed as Rembrandt notes, which were created by ABN Amro and assigned a AAA rating by Standard & Poor’s.

The councils lost 93 per cent of the capital they invested in the Rembrandt notes they bought from LGFS in 2006.

Apparently some A$200 billion of these masterpieces were sold worldwide, not Rembrandts but CPDOs that is, and there was a defect in S&P's modelling of the volatility in the products.

Today's finding is not only the first adverse judgment against S&P worldwide, but it may also open up S&P to a further $20b in claims.

Federal Court Justice Jayne Jagot said on Monday that the councils were entitled to succeed in their damages against LGFS, ABN Amro and Standard & Poor’s which included negligence and misleading or deceptive conduct.

‘‘The councils have each proved that they suffered loss and damage as required to sustain their claims against LGFS, S&P and ABN Amro, the damage being the amount each paid for the Rembrandt 2006-3 CPDO notes less the amount they received on the cash-out of those notes,’’ the judge said.

She also said the councils were entitled to compensation from LGFS for breach of fiduciary duty.

Apart from the claims against LGFS, a subsidiary of the NSW Local Government Superannuation Scheme, for breach of fiduciary duty Justice Jagot said the damages should be split evenly between ANN Amro, Standard & Poor’s and LGFS.

LGFS also succeeded in its claim against ABN Amro and Standard & Poor’s for the Rembrandt notes that it did not sell to councils but sold to its parent company after the credit rating agency downgraded them from AAA rating to BBB+.

Ad Feedback

- Sydney Morning Herald

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content