The Capital Connection continues to make significant losses, despite concerted efforts to make it commercially viable, and halfway through a two-year trial its future looks shaky.
Labour has promised to save the passenger service between Palmerston North and Wellington by pumping in millions in subsidies if the party is elected in September.
But Transport Minister Gerry Brownlee has dismissed that idea, saying efforts to save the service are failing and if passengers want it to survive they need to use it.
Brownlee agreed to a 2013 proposal from councils, including Greater Wellington and Kapiti District, to maintain the service for an extra two years to see if it could be saved, after KiwiRail revealed it was making a loss.
But in spite of fare rises and efforts to boost patronage, the line will make a loss of more than $600,000 this year.
The number of passengers has also dropped, cannibalised by the extension of Tranz Metro's Waikanae line.
KiwiRail said in 2012 that to be financially viable, it needed an extra 61 passengers a day in each direction to break even by 2015 and average ticket prices needed to be 40 per cent higher.
Brownlee, who has faced criticism over a lack of funding for public transport initiatives, said that "if people want it they need to use it".
"The total daily patronage is about 250 people in each direction so the increase that was required was not huge and it's a little disappointing that we're in that position."
He would not say whether he thought the service would last past the middle of next year, saying the review was still taking place.
"Asking me midway through that process to ignore the falling patronage and the cost of running it this coming year and make a commitment to it I think does a huge disservice to the people who came to my office and asked for this arrangement."
Labour is promising to adopt a 2012 business case from Greater Wellington and Horizons regional councils which suggested local councils and the NZ Transport Agency subsidise the line to keep it open at a cost of $3.8 million over five years.
"Labour will invest in all transport modes, not just roads, to deliver an efficient and sustainable transport system," its transport spokesman, Phil Twyford, said.
"As the business case shows, the Capital Connection stacks up. We will work with local councils to keep it on the rails."
KiwiRail passenger general manager Deborah Hume acknowledged there was a "public preference for the weekday service to continue" but its future beyond the middle of next year depended on it becoming financially viable.
"While any subsidy or funding from local or central government may well assist the Capital Connection to continue, any future decisions regarding a change to funding policy would not be made by KiwiRail."
Horizons Regional Council chairman Bruce Gordon welcomed Labour's proposal, saying the Capital Connection should be subsidised like Tranz Metro services.
It was beginning to claw back some of its old patronage while efforts to align ticketing with Tranz Metro services would help.
The line was a vital link. "More and more people are out living in the regions and relying on public transport to get to where they need to go.
"What we don't want is everyone living in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch, we want our regions to be supported by good public transport services."
- The Dominion Post
Did the Key v Cunliffe debate change your vote?Related story: Support slips for National and John Key
View obituaries from around the region.
View marriage and birth notices from around the region.
• Reporters: News, Business, Sport, Features
• Newsroom 0800 366 7678
• Website ideas: Email or tweet us
• Place an ad: Email or call 04 474 0000
• Subscribe: Email or call 0800 50 50 90
• No paper: Call 0800 50 50 90
• Start or stop your paper
• View the Digital Edition
• Make dompost.co.nz your homepage