Editorial: Faulty lines? More like Fawlty Towers

Last updated 05:00 18/02/2010

Relevant offers

Editorials

Editorial: Half-baked ideas not what public needs NZ, mate, you might have a drinking problem Editorial: Adding value to our national days Editorial: Wellington's waterfront is a gem Editorial: Family reunions - who should pay? Editorial: Veto protects Syria's blood-stained leader Editorial: Section 9 row adds to asset sale unease Editorial: A lesson primary teachers could learn Editorial: Some advice really is worth following Editorial: Clock ticking on Christchurch mayor

Kiwirail is to the transport industry what Basil Fawlty is to the hospitality trade.

It treats its customers as impediments to the smooth running of its business.

Current management can be excused responsibility for the creaking trains and dilapidated tracks in the Wellington region.

They are the consequence of 40 years of neglect by public and private owners of the rail system. But KiwiRail bosses cannot escape responsibility for the way customers are treated.

If they are not left waiting on the platform for services that have been cancelled, they are shut in trains that have mysteriously stopped part way into their journeys. Either way, they are kept in the dark.

On Tuesday 369 people were stuck on a train to Upper Hutt for two hours after a power failure halted all trains in and out of the capital. "No one told us anything," complained a passenger. "We were locked up and were going nowhere. We were not allowed outside."

The previous day 2000 commuters were delayed for up to two hours when another power fault brought services to a standstill. Some passengers waited more than an hour for replacement buses to show up. Others walked to work along the lines.

This week's breakdowns are just the latest in a string of problems that have infuriated passengers over the past 12 months as historic under-investment in the commuter network and a $600 million upgrade have coincided to create what KiwiRail project manager David Gordon calls a "perfect storm".

Passengers have been delayed by power faults, equipment failures, slips and contractor errors and, last winter, were left to shiver in carriages without working heaters.

Faced with such a difficult operating environment, KiwiRail might have been expected to do its utmost to retain customer loyalty by informing passengers of the cause and likely length of delays and having alternative forms of transport on hand to minimise inconvenience.

Instead it has operated as if its customers have no choice but to put up with its erratic services.

KiwiRail and the Greater Wellington regional council, which subsidises rail services in the region, are now paying the price for that miscalculation. Between July and November last year, patronage on trains in the Wellington region fell by more than 7 per cent, or 373,000 trips.

At a time of increasing concern about global warming, commuters are switching from trains to cars because it is the only way they can be sure of getting where they're going on time.

KiwiRail is optimistic that services will progressively improve over the next 18 months as lines are upgraded and new passenger carriages become available.

Ad Feedback

That will be welcome, but it is not just the company's infrastructure that needs overhauling. So does its way of operating.

Passengers want to be treated like the customers they are, not like sheep who have no choice but to accept substandard levels of service. Surely that is not too much to ask for in the 21st century?

- © Fairfax NZ News

7 comments
Post a comment
Matt   #7   02:57 pm Feb 18 2010

The SH2 is choked because of accidents and too many cars. The Hutt Valley Line isn't running because of faults. The Great Harbour Way which would make it safe and attractive to cycle from Petone isn't likely to get built any time soon. It seems John Key can't fix any of them. New Zealand is broke, and Wellington is broken. Perhaps its time to seriously discuss moving the capital to Palmerston North.

Snow   #6   12:26 pm Feb 18 2010

I agree, rail commuters are well aware of the rail upgrade/maintenance work needed to get it all ready for the new trains. We accept that. What I am disgusted with is the old school Government employee attitude that as long as they have a job who cares about the customer. I was walking to the J'ville line to catch a train home from the city, the trains were running late (surprise,surprise) and there was a train ready to leave 5mins before my scheduled one. I was tired and didn't feel like running to catch this one, I was happy to wait until my scheduled one albeit late. Needless to say I was shocked to hear abuse shouted out to me by the train guard that I better f****n hurry up and get on it!!!!!! I indicated that I wasn't concerned about missing this one but he insisted that I was holding up the train and that they were already running late, in a very aggressive tone. It's not the first time that I have been subjected to poor attitude from train staff and it's this that I'm keen to see improved rather than the train lines. It is no wonder that passenger numbers are decreasing and KiwiRail's answer to this is increasing fares smacks of bad judgement and lack of understanding of what the 'real' issues are.

Ray   #5   10:46 am Feb 18 2010

Re Editorial comment "commuters are switching from trains to cars because it is the only way they can be sure of getting where they're going on time." Guess Plan no. 2 didn't work this morning !! Just proves that the roads are also subject to unforseen delays also.

Paul Whitham   #4   10:05 am Feb 18 2010

Even when Kiwirail run communications they get it wrong. Yesterday morning I was woken by a text at 5.55am telling me that the trains would be running to schedule. That was no comfort when at 7.40 we waited at Wallaceville station for a train that never arrived. At 8.10 the next train (which at that stage was 10 minutes late) arrived. We were told by the Guard that the train was no longer express but would be stopping at all stations. Then at Taita the guard said that we were back to being an express. Obviuously no one told the driver as he stopped at all stations. For the third time in a row the Guards decided not to face customer comments and did not collect tickets. No problems to Kiwirail as the ticket box goes to the Regional Council, but for us Monthly passes it means that we have to pay for a lousy service twice.

Ard Righ   #3   09:55 am Feb 18 2010

I think you're being a bit rough on poor Basil.

I think Basil Fawlty could spill a bottle of wine and a plate full of food over a customer, and *still* have better customer service than KiwiRail.

Greg   #2   09:54 am Feb 18 2010

So... are we ready for the Rugby World Cup? Do we even know what it means to be ready?

Beth   #1   08:50 am Feb 18 2010

I was impressed by KiwiRail's lack of communication in January. I caught the train 3 days in a row, all were delayed. On the third day the train was over half an hour late when another person at the station rang the customer help line, who weren't aware there was a delay. They had to go find out what was wrong and call the gentleman back.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content