Culture of fear shoots down reform

Last updated 06:11 22/04/2013

Relevant offers

Editorials

Kids in cells reflect a 'surge' in youth crime Editorial: Disability Issues Minister Nicky Wagner's Tweet reveals her as tone-deaf Editorial: The police must tread carefully over liquor licences Editorial: Immigration cuts are not xenophobic, but economically necessary Editorial: Did authorities fail oyster farmers? Editorial: Tory PMs humiliated first in Brexit referendum, now in snap election Editorial: Kids in primary schools don't need to play with guns Editorial: Wellington's welcome move to tackle the housing crisis Editorial: In the battle between officials and politicians, neither side is always right. Editorial: Fluoridation means better dental health for all

Every culture has its dark side, its lunatic obsessions. America's is guns.

Political attempts at rational gun control founder on this madness. The Senate's disgraceful rejection last week of President Barack Obama's mild initiative on background checks for gun owners is just such a case. The world watches, and gapes. How can Americans behave like this?

The usual answer is to point at the power of the gun lobby. Of the 45 senators who voted down the measure, 42 had received money from firearms lobbyists. The aptly-named Senator Jeff Flake, who switched his vote at the last moment, had been given $5000 by a pro- gun outfit. Mr Obama was right when he accused the Senate of caving in to the National Rifle Association and its tawdry mates.

But in a sense this explanation just shifts the mystery back a step. The gun lobby buys some politicians and frightens others into submission. Some of the Democratic senators who killed Mr Obama's measure last week say president Bill Clinton's 1994 ban on assault weapons cost many of their party their seats. But how is it that the voters are so influenced by the lunatics of the gun lobby?

Surveys show, after all, that 90 per cent of voters support moderate gun control. Last week the senators did their dirty work while survivors of the latest mass shooting, in Tucson, looked on. One, Patricia Maisch, shouted "Shame on you" and left. If shame and the voters' presence could force a politician to behave decently, this would have been the time.

So the madness lies deeper than lobby power and the shadow of money. Many Americans think guns are a necessary part of their lives. Survivalists who think Washington is out to get them keep a pistol in the drawer. Guns symbolise freedom, a great American taonga.

Besides, the right to bear arms is enshrined in the second amendment. This is a genuinely outmoded bit of late 18th-century treaty-making. Guns were needed to arm a "well-regulated militia" - in other words, to fend off the Redcoats fighting to keep America British. But it's in the constitution, and for many Americans the constitution is Holy Writ.

What's more, in America's ghettos there is an at least plausible argument for having a gun. When so many around you are armed and dangerous, it might seem rational to be armed for self- defence.

But the deepest reason for America's gun psychosis lies in its culture of fear. This is Michael Moore's one genuine contribution to his country's gun debate. Americans are afraid because the Right preys on their fears about black people, immigrants, terrorists and home-grown lunatics. In a climate of fear and anxiety, the call to arms always carries weight.

Ad Feedback

And that means Mr Obama's campaign to bring a little sanity into the gun culture may be doomed. Background checks to filter out the criminals and madmen who want to buy a gun? The world would call it an obvious move. The US finds it wildly controversial. And that says a great deal about what life in America is really like.

- The Dominion Post

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content