A chronic case of idolatry
BY NICK CHURCHOUSEWell I never. Kiwi celebrity culture a tad misguided? Whatever is the fellow on about?
I'm talking about Lord Robert Winston, that exalted Brit who is in our neighbourhood to talk at a conference in Auckland today.
He is a professor of this and that, a little bit emeritus, and belongs to the House of Lords. Yes yes, righto wot wot.
He is also the host of that fascinating series the Child of Our Time, which my mother watched obsessively, most likely to try and understand me and my sister. Let it go Mum, we'll grow up sooner or later.
Anyhow, Lord Winston (ohoh with a name like that is he going to get a challenge from our own Lord Winnie?) is being a tad brutally honest. Some might say refreshingly honest. Some might say we know all this.
Which ever you believe, his message that New Zealand is a bit wrapped up in "famous" locals that don't really deserve the mana they garner.
Too many sporting folk, not enough intellectual folk, earn the respect and praise of Kiwi society, he says. And half of them are complete shockers when they walk off the field.
Can't say I disagree, even though there will be the usual qualifiers in there.
Being driven by "sailing, The All Blacks and the Bledisloe Cup" shows the "genuine lessening of the values of society".
Well, let's just give that old hornets nest a couple more whacks.
What about Dancing with the Stars? Our unnatural idolisation of "The Weather Guy"? And if there's a serious social ill to debate, discuss and rectify, let's go ask Colin Meads! Ahem, the guy is nicknamed after a tree that is not even a native, and since when did putting your shoulder to the ass cheeks of other men and pushing make you a bastion of intellectual and moral fortitude?
Lord Winston is bang on the money, but hey, it's not just little old Aotearoa. Everywhere does it. The Brits are the worst, the Yanks aren't much better. I cannot really comment on Asia, I'll hazard a guess they'd be a smidgen better, but not by much.
Human nature does not allow us to value things we don't understand. Basically, that's because:
- television and news coverage does not lend itself to things we don't understand (we'll switch off, turn over and the ads won't work);
- school curriculum does not venture to cover things we should understand (somebody might be deemed a failure if it's too hard);
- and on large the commercial world does not deem it necessary to pay remarkably well for the people who understand the things we can't understand (just those people you can slap an ad on).
Hence quantum physics, deep sea ecology, the intricate complexities of human thermoregulation and the science of exponential extravagance, aka working out the value in a Wall St paycheck, does not come to the fore.
Lord Winston goes on to say we turn a blind eye to the digressions of such mighty men as our Boys in Black, which All Black manager Darren Shand does not deny, but instead excuses with "people will make mistakes" and promises to "emphasise personal responsibility".
I'd back Shand on this one.
Unfortunately All Blacks will always be idols in this country, but what we ask of them is too much.
These guys are sportsmen. They are warriors, fighters, brawlers, and rugby, as with most sports is the survival (victory) of the fittest, smartest, fastest and strongest. And they are impressive at what they do.
On the field we (and the NZRFU) want these guys to be animals, running down opponents like berserk rhinos, tackling like demolition balls and winning at all costs, with a modicum of allowance for sportsmanship.
Off the field we want these guys to be like Simon Barnett, soft, sensitive, nurturing types, with a mind for a pithy phrase and a penchant for Shakespeare and Chaucer.
The twain just ain't gonna meet on this one.
We should be caging these chaps up after the game, feeding them lettuce and protein pills until the next test match, putting raw meat on the goal line and telling them they can eat whatever they tackle. [Graham Henry please credit me if you want to borrow that for the World Cup].
Okay. A little off on a tangent there, but it relates. Our idols are often not people we should want to be like.
Societal worship should be levelled at the fathers, the mothers, the healthy eaters, the inventors, the hard working strongmen, the artful, the honest and the industrious.
Instead we exalt (perceived) beauty, brute strength, misguided attempts at humour (Paul Henry/Rhys Darby/Game of Two Halves), hairdos and fashion. Oh, and Shortland Street.
I'd say to Lord Winston there are idols in New Zealand who are worthy of our bestowed glory, but we've got a few too many dickheads that will probably get on the New Years Honours list for just being there. Bugger.
Who do you think is honestly worthy or your respect and adulation? Other than me, of course.
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
Good one Nick! I agree with you, and also with Lord Winston even though I have a feeling Child Of Our Time may have been a steaming pile of pop-psychology. I may of course have got it mixed up with something else.
I'll second xLeahx #1 on Ernest Rutherford, Kate Sheppard and John Britten, and I'll add Rita Angus, Phil Clairmont and Murray Ball, to show that NZ can produce genuinely funny comics if it tries. But mostly, the people who inspire me aren't famous. They're regular people like my postgrad supervisor, my dad, my friends.
I agree with xLeahx. I enjoy rugby, soccer, cricket etc, but these guys are sportsman. Some of them seem like nice blokes, some not so much, but to hold them up as role models simply because they play well is ridiculous. The miedia have to share some of the blame, as do the public. The media are the ones who spent lots of airtime, and newsprint, telling us about Jesse Ryder being drunk, Tiger Woods affairs etc etc. These things are none of our business, and Jesse and Tiger (as just two examples) signed up to play sport, not to be role models. And the public play their part by buying these papers, watching the news etc, and demanding to know more. I am sure years ago sportsmen did silly things too, but it was deemed to be no one elses business. I agree with xLeahx about Ernest Rutherford too. I cant believe i went to school metres from where Rutherford had his laboratory in Christchurch, and made many of his more well known discoveries, and not once were we ever made of aware of that fact, even in science classes! And yet we all knew of the famous All Blacks who had been through the school. Colin Meads and Ed Hillary are two sportsman who do deserve their role model status....but not by their sporting abilities. By the fact they seem to be modest, sensible blokes, who demand respect naturally.
Of course we idolize the weather guy - we are OBSESSED with the weather in this country! LOL
Good blog :)
I do admire sportspeople, for the simple fact that they ARE industrious - they put huge hours and effort into training and competing. And they are talented. But the All Blacks impress me less than, say, a living legend like Danyon Loader. Mostly because the ABs get heaps of money for doing what they do (their jobs), whereas a lot of other sportspeople get little, if any, money, must have day jobs to make a living, and yet still dedicate heaps of time and energy to their passion and talent. That impresses me as I can imagine it would be hugely taxing personally.
I tend to admire and idolise great NZ artists, jewellers, designers and musicians, also. These people have talent and skill and artistry and again, I don't have the ability to create as they do, so I am a fan.
Helen Clark is an amazing woman who I admire for her achievements and astonishing mental capacity. And I think Tariana Turia is remarkable, intelligent and warm.
Can't think of anyone else at the moment, aside from obviously my lovely family and friends who I admire and respect for a myriad of different reasons!
What about Ernest Rutherford, Nancy Wake, Archi McIndoe, Jean Batten, Tim Finn, Charles Goldie and of course Sir Edmund Hillary to name a few. We are certainly not a nation who are only devoted to our sports people, we have some of the most talented and amazing people and they do deserve the respect and mana that is given to them. Sir Winnie should take a second look at the people and history of New Zealand and maybe do a little more research before making what can only can be called a very stupid and pointless statement.
Anyone who gets grease on their hands:
Ernest Rutherford, John Britten, the Fastest Indian, Sir Edmund, Jean Batten, yeah... and Michael Laws (whenever he touches himself).
I believe there are *some* sportspeople who are worthy of idol status, however, the current rugby and cricket players are not among them. They are the best in NZ at present, but certainly only average on the world stage and their off field behaviour is below average.
People like Possum Bourne who work with total dedication, succeeded against the odds and was an ambassador for himself, his sport and the country are worthy.
As far as the "scandals" that feature in the media, sure those sports people signed up for the sport, but like it or not, successful people in any endeavour become role models for others. Of course, it's not helped by the media making mountains out of molehills and focusing on such behaviour.
@xLeahx: "I can't think of anyone alive that I am particularly impressed with at the moment."
Well, that's the whole point, isn't it? New Zealand has plenty of scientists and engineers, some working here, some based overseas. Some of them are very clever, getting results or developing new technology. But, by and large, the media deems it all not newsworthy, and so you haven't heard of them.
We seem to obsess about anything or anyone that the idiot media put in front of us. No offence Nick, just a little touchy cause my GF has seen you several times in the last week and seems be doing some minor celebrity worship of her own. Grumble grumble...
On the other hand, she thinks that Lane looks like a gangling giraffe with spaghetti arms that flail around like a Thunderbirds puppet.
Jamie Oliver to open restaurant in Wellington
Leaky building requires massive mop-up
Man injured after vehicle rolls in Lower Hutt
Quake felt across lower North Island
Parents don't want son's killer in town
Clock ticking for Transmission Gully process
Clock ticking for Transmission Gully process
Fear of dangerous rift from wealth gap
Bid to scrap race relations office
Restorative justice goes to school
Mallard case raises questions of behaviour
Fay aims shot at OIO over Crafar
Anger at Holmes' Waitangi remarks
'Shape up or ship out' the newest Firebirds way
Newest First
Oldest First
The people who are worthy of my respect are certainly NOT sportspeople. How exactly is sports going to contribute to the advancement of our country? Answer = it's not. It's entertainment, basically, and obviously some people are better at it than others, but it's still nothing special.
The people in our country I admire/respect most are unfortunately dead, but they include Ernest Rutherford, John Britten (although it could be classed as a sports-type thing, at least he was an inventor as well), Kate Sheppard, Colin McCahon and so on.
I can't think of anyone alive that I am particularly impressed with at the moment.