Man dead in Wellington flat for up to a year

CLIO FRANCIS
Last updated 10:51 01/09/2011
RICHARD HENARE
PHIL REID/The Dominion Post

RICHARD HENARE: "It's a bit of a shock. To know we've just been walking around not knowing he needed help.''

OLIVENE TAYLOR
PHIL REID/The Dominion Post
OLIVENE TAYLOR: "They used to check. The only time the council comes now is when someone's dead.''
Council flats
PHIL REID/The Dominion Post
ALONE TO THE END: Curtains are drawn in the unit, left, where Mr Clarke lay dead for months. Many of the flats around it are empty and the block is due to be demolished.

Relevant offers

News

Rubbish bins are better than bags Protester costs council $350,000 'Quick fix' proposed for Ngaio School Porirua closer to getting artificial sports field Ecologist warns of Gully risk to fish Near-miss sees passenger ferry sailings cancelled Resignation another blow for cycle race Illness caused by chilly water Drowning victim British fishing adventurer

LATEST: Wellington City Council has launched an investigation into how pensioner Michael Clarke lay dead in his Wellington council flat for over a year without his neighbours or the council knowing.

Did you know Michael Clarke? Contact the newsroom at news@dompost.co.nz or call 0800 366 7678

The 88-year-old's body was found only by chance – the block where he lived in Newtown Park Flats in Mansfield St, Newtown, is due to be demolished and council workers have been going door to door to make arrangements to shift tenants.

Wellington City Mayor Celia Wade-Brown said she was "very sad'' Mr Clarke's body lay undiscovered for such a long time.

"It serves as a reminder that we should all think about our neighbours welfare. Getting to know your neighbours - even if it just means knowing their name and saying hello - is an important way of keeping our community connected and strong.''

The council has now established a tenant support role within the Housing Unit especially to liaise with and look after elderly tenants.

After knocking at Mr Clarke's door several times over a number of weeks and leaving calling cards that were not collected, council staff alerted police.

On Wednesday last week, police arrived at his small bedsit at No16 and found his body.

Initial investigations by council staff indicated he could have died as long ago as last year. "Having done a check of some of the things in the flat ... unfortunately it could have been late last year," council spokesman Richard MacLean said yesterday.

Mr Clarke had lived for 30 years on the third floor of a dilapidated concrete building near Wellington Zoo known as "zoo block". He was known to like his privacy, and his rent and power bills continued to be paid by automatic payments. His death is not considered suspicious and has now been reported to the coroner.

Yesterday the lace curtains at the bedsit were drawn and a cluster of flies buzzed outside the blue door. Resident Richard Henare, who has lived in the block for the past five years, said: "It's a bit of a shock.

"To know we've just been walking around not knowing he needed help. It gives you an uncomfortable feeling knowing that someone's passed away like that."

The elderly residents tended to keep to themselves, he said. "The whisper going around was that he might have been dead for months.

"There was no giveaway, though – no smell, nothing.

"The only time the council check up on you around here is if you're late on the rent."

Another resident, who wanted to be known only as Bob, remembered Mr Clarke as sticking to himself. "We're boxed away in here and the only way you get out is in a box," he said.

Ad Feedback

"We're put away here, we're just forgotten about. We live as hermits and we die as hermits."

Olivene Taylor has lived in the block for 33 years. "They used to check on older people and there used to be security," she said.

"The only time the council comes now is when someone's dead. They are supposed to check on people but they don't."

She gestured around the block: "One person was dead for seven days, another person over there for two weeks. It's pitiful really."

City council social portfolio leader Stephanie Cook said the council had various procedures that required staff to knock on doors and visit tenants at least once a year.

"We're checking to see what has happened – or possibly not happened – that has allowed this sad situation to occur.

"It obviously appears that the tenant's rent payments and power bill continued to be automatically paid for a number of months – so there was little to suggest something had gone wrong.

"The council's housing staff do try to keep tabs on all tenants to make sure they're OK – but many of our tenants like their privacy and do not like unnecessary intrusion into their lives."

Mayor Celia Wade-Brown said it seemed Mr Clarke was an extremely private man who appeared to have no close family. "Physical isolation may be something that's more prevalent across all of society in this day and age – but it doesn't lessen the sadness of the situation.

"While we're still trying to ascertain all the facts about this incident, I think it's an appropriate time for us all to think about how we keep in touch with family and friends."

Ms Wade-Brown said she had asked for an update on the council's processes for contacting tenants. The Social Development Ministry confirmed Mr Clarke had been receiving his pension for the past year.

In 1999, Wellington police called for the council to check regularly on tenants after several cases in which the bodies of elderly people were not discovered for some time.

In one, police found the decomposed body of a woman who had lain dead in a Kilbirnie flat for eight weeks and in another a 75-year-old man lay undiscovered for a fortnight in the Newtown Park Flats.

- © Fairfax NZ News

22 comments
Post a comment
NotSurprised   #22   04:42 pm Sep 02 2011

The only thing the council cares about is the bottom line! City Housing has an EXTREMELY high staff turnover (esp by those whom try to put people before $$). Maybe they should put more effort in retaining staff to save $$ then there would be less $$ spent on retraining staff, staff would have better relationships with tenants and we would all benefit. P.S - the CH current leadership is obviously not working, time to see a change.

Nicky   #21   01:12 pm Sep 02 2011

Instead of all the finger pointing and accusations about who was most at fault why cant we put some sort of trigger system in our banking system where after a given period of time, that an alarm is raised when there is inactivity with a bank account. This man had money going in and out, but obviously he was not purchasing food etc, a red flag popping up somewhere in the banking system to be passed on to police/council for investigation may be the way to go.

Adrian   #20   09:18 am Sep 02 2011

Sweet. Maybe the ratepayer will happily fund the rise in rates for the extra staff required to make regular visits. The public are notorious crybabies that want to give nothing and get everything.

Ian   #19   09:46 pm Sep 01 2011

Whatever happened to 'management by walking around'. No servant of the council had cause to visit the flats in a whole year? I thought the council was offering cheap apartments for compassionate reasons. Not much compassion coming through over this tragic event. Perhaps the council should leave accommodation up to accommodation professionals: they could hardly do worse.

Laura   #18   06:58 pm Sep 01 2011

The Mayor has her concerns on matters like "shadowing of a flyover over the Basin", not the likes of the Councils tenants in her backyard. With the $17 mill ratepayers surplus, it makes you wonder why an 88 year old had to live so pitiful for so many years in these Council flats.

Miles Lacey   #17   05:54 pm Sep 01 2011

Because I'm too poor to go anywhere and virtually everyone I know is living outside the area where I live I often go through weeks at a time when I don't see people so if I dropped dead at my computer right now nobody would notice for at least two weeks. That's part of the problem of living in a polarized society where we only talk to people who are like-minded or "popular". Social misfits or the lonely just don't get noticed unless we go postal or are found dead in our homes after a year.

Chris Heffernan   #16   05:08 pm Sep 01 2011

Such a death is tragic and it reminds us that This day in age, people are too self-centered and misanthorpic to know there neighbors and any communication is generally an exchange of abuse (or punches) over what x neighbor is doing to annoy y neighbor, Celia Wade brown is living in the past - people are just too arrogant these days.

Trish   #15   05:00 pm Sep 01 2011

Such a sad, sad story. RIP Mr Clarke. You may have kept to yourself but now much of NZ knows your name.

disgruntled of wellington   #14   01:58 pm Sep 01 2011

@adrian

Olivene doesn't sound like a muppet at all. You need to check your nastiness.

Adrian   #13   01:32 pm Sep 01 2011

disgruntled of wellington #7 - what a stupid comment. I was responding to a comment made by someone trying to place blame on someone in the midst of, as you call it, "a really sad situation". Dig your ignorant claws into the muppet who commented in the article, not me. You get the service that you pay for. State housing is no different. Use your brains.


Show 1-12 of 22 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

What do you think of the planned price increase for rubbish bags?

Boo. It's too expensive

Good idea, it will encourage recycling

I don't care

Vote Result

Related story: Wellington council could quit rubbish trade

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content