Plans to cut military band numbers

HANK SCHOUTEN
Last updated 16:53 27/01/2012

Relevant offers

News

Protester costs council $350,000 'Quick fix' proposed for Ngaio School Porirua closer to getting artificial sports field Ecologist warns of Gully risk to fish Near-miss sees passenger ferry sailings cancelled Resignation another blow for cycle race Illness caused by chilly water Drowning victim British fishing adventurer 840 homes lose power in Upper Hutt

Seven of the country's 10 Defence Force bands could soon be axed as a cost cutting measure.

Those for the chop under a proposal now under discussion are the various  part-time territorial bands.

Defence spokesman John Gordon said the plan would retain the regular force army band, based at Burnham, the air force band based in Wellington and the navy band based at Devonport, Auckland.

These are all manned by full-time bandsmen and women.

The aim is to cut $900,000 from the $5.9 million spend each year on  military bands.

A decision on the cuts was expected to be made at the end of March.

Vice Chief of Defence Force Rear Admiral Jack Steer said the reforms came out of the Defence White Paper and a value for money review.

"It is envisaged that the proposed changes will delivery long term efficiency gains, optimise the use of NZDF musicians across New Zealand and the reduced expenditure will increase funding available for front-line activities.

Ad Feedback
13 comments
Post a comment
GB   #13   08:28 pm Jan 30 2012

Dominion Post please do some research so you get your facts right. The RNZAF Central Band based in Wellington is not a band manned by full-time bandsmen and women. As is the case with the RNZAF Base bands the RNZAF Central Band is comprised of territorial airmen and women (a good number of which are music students from university). The central band only has two full time regular force members, the RNZAF Director of music and his assistant.

Stu   #12   10:56 am Jan 30 2012

I for one will be sad to see the end of Wellington, West Coast & Taranaki Regiment's band - The only Pipe Band in the NZ Army.

They may be 'only' part timers; but they were good enough to do the Edinburgh Military Tattoo in 2000.

Joy!   #11   06:29 am Jan 30 2012

I'm getting this picture in my mind of a military parade where the soldiers all carry boom boxes on their shoulders.....

KC   #10   12:26 am Jan 30 2012

No more muisc to the ears? Eh?

Steve   #9   10:10 pm Jan 29 2012

2.7 million was spent last year sanitising the defence media reports. The mere $900,000 savings destroy part of our defence force history. The NZ Artillery band has been in continuous existence since 1864. Much of these savings are at the cost of pomp and ceremony that colour our culture and heritage. It is equivalent to decolorising your TV and watching in b&w. Look forward to bland military occasions from now on as 3 bands struggle to fly around the country: highly efficient use of defence force money. Contrast this with the no holds barred $45M spent on government house renovations which only the big wigs experience. Millions spent on rugby world cup dignitaries and visits by royalty. The defence force seems to have no choice. Only the public can fight to retain this part of our heritage. 3 bands instead of 10 on Anzac day and other special occasions all for a mere $900,000 saving $130,000/band this is cultural sacrilege. Our culture is being destroyed around us single handedly by a right wing government with myopic tunnel vision.

jason   #8   10:45 pm Jan 28 2012

Paul @ #1

Your comment is why Defence policy is best left to people who know a little bit about the topic.

For a start, the planes 'we can't afford' is a government policy choice rather than an NZDF operational spending one, and fulltime bands are central to military ceremony and ethos.

The compromise is good. Given the Defence cut backs, non core bands need to go but it is necessary to retain the full time ones from each service.

ygb   #7   09:45 pm Jan 28 2012

Paul @ 1. I guess the government is running the shambles and that's why it is so. I would be surprised if there is an ex airman, squady or sailor amongst them. I hear $21M was given against the Treaty today. I keep on reminding myself that NZ is short on cash ..... that is for certain important things like defence. Yuk

Hardie   #6   06:46 am Jan 28 2012

The Territorial [Reserve] Bands are all a bunch of Prima Donna's playing dress up as soldiers when it suits them. Refuse to travel unless it's by bus and won't stay out overnight. Good riddance.

Phil O'sophical   #5   02:25 am Jan 28 2012

Talk about facing the music.

Chris M   #4   11:48 pm Jan 27 2012

Paul #1: Absolutely. Military bands are fine, but they won't do any good against an attack. Look at the Falklands war and the punishment meted out to the British naval task force by the Argentine air force. NZ needs a fighter wing in order to have a credible defense force.


Show 1-3 of 13 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

What do you think of the planned price increase for rubbish bags?

Boo. It's too expensive

Good idea, it will encourage recycling

I don't care

Vote Result

Related story: Wellington council could quit rubbish trade

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content