Mayoral chains come at high cost

Last updated 05:00 18/12/2013
John Morrison
John Morrison: "I ran [for council] to give people an alternative and it was pretty close. "

Relevant offers

Celia Wade-Brown won the Wellington mayoralty, but it was runner-up John Morrison who pulled in the lion's share of donations for the October campaign.

Wade-Brown spent $56,990 to keep hold of the Wellington City mayoral chains, and recouped only $4200 in donations - a net investment of $52,790 to land the $158,000-a-year job.

Morrison spent slightly less, at $55,000, but recouped nearly half of that in donations, leaving him to stump up $34,640 of his own money.

He received $7860 in anonymous donations, ranging from $10 to $1499, $10,000 from investment group Caniwi Capital, and $2500 from the Museum Hotel.

Wade-Brown said her campaign had accepted donations but had not actively solicited them and, although she was pro-business, many of her supporters were not on high incomes.

"I've had three years being paid a mayor's salary. In my view, it's up to me to fund my campaign."

She was slightly surprised to see the amount of donations some candidates received, and she had taken a view that all contributors, no matter how small the donation, should be identified.

Morrison did not return calls yesterday.

Other mayoral candidates also spent up large - Nicola Young, who got a seat on the council, spent $32,400 and got all bar $960 of it back in donations. These included $3000 from Tirohanga Holdings and just over $20,000 in non-itemised "other" donations.

Jack Yan spent $17,810, under his estimate of $20,000, and was supported with $10,200 in donations. Karunanidhi Muthu spent $13,990, all of it his own.

Former councillor Rob Goulden spent the least; his mayoral campaign cost just under $2000.

Among council candidates, first-time councillor Mark Peck led the pack with a $17,580 bill while Ray Ahipene-Mercer, a veteran with six elections under his belt, spent just $1670.

Of those who did not win seats, Northern candidate Peter Gilberd spent the most, at $27,170. He received $12,500 in donated advertising on Newlands Coach Services - gifted by Wade-Brown's husband and campaign manager, Alastair Nicholson.

Nicholson said he won the advertising in a charity auction for $3000, but as he would have had to declare it as spending of $12,500, it would have blown his wife's limit.

"I looked at the other candidates we supported and at who could use it . . . it was either a candidate in the Northern ward or another mayoral candidate, which obviously I wasn't going to do."

Ad Feedback


Some of the Wellington City Council candidates' spends and donations. All candidates' returns are on the city council website.


Celia Wade-Brown (won mayoralty): spent $56,990, got $4200 in donations

John Morrison: spent $55,000; $20,360 donations

Nicola Young (won Lambton seat): spent $32,400; $31,440 donations

Jack Yan: spent $17,810; $10,200 donations

Karunanidhi Muthu: spent $13,990; no donations over $1500

Rob Goulden: spent $1980, $180 donations


Mark Peck (Lambton): spent $17,580; $1500 in-kind donations

David Lee (Southern): spent $17,250

Paul Eagle (Southern): spent $13,470

Helen Ritchie (Northern): spent $12,520

Simon Woolf (Onslow-Western): spent $10,500; $10,500 donations

Sarah Free (Eastern): spent $9780; $4880 donations

Malcolm Sparrow (Northern): spent $9540

Iona Pannett (Lambton): spent $8020

Simon Marsh (Eastern): spent $6190

Justin Lester (Northern): spent $2980

Andy Foster (Onslow-Western): spent $2770

Jo Coughlan (Onslow-Western): spent $2160

Ray Ahipene-Mercer (Eastern): spent $1670


Peter Gilberd (Northern): spent $27,170; $12,500 donations

John Dow (Lambton): spent $16,960

John Coleman (Eastern): spent $15,740; $10,770 donations

Martin Wilson (Onslow-Western): spent $8280; $2000 donations

Malcolm Aitken (Onslow-Western): spent $8120

Donald McDonald (Southern): spent $7420

Rex Nicholls (Lambton): spent $6550

Ginette McDonald (Southern): spent $4330

Leonie Gill (Eastern): spent $2560

Bryan Pepperell (Southern): spent $1750

- The Dominion Post


Special offers
Opinion poll

Should Wellington have a new convention centre?

Yes, the Hilton is a missed opportunity

Yes, but there's no need for another hotel and the price was too high

Yes, and it would be much better on Interisland wharf

No, Wellington has enough such facilities for its size

Vote Result

Related story: $100m Hilton project back to drawing board

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content