The Maranui Cafe in Lyall Bay has been hit by another fire, three years after it was destroyed by a blaze.
A fire was lit in the cafe's cardboard recycling bin at about 2am on Sunday, and spread to the side of the building.
The arson attack set off a security alarm at the cafe, and fire engines were called to the scene.
Co-owner Bronwyn Kelly said the fire caused some damage to the building's exterior, with weatherboards needing to be replaced and repainted.
The gas supply was also out until about 11.30am - affecting peak trading at the cafe.
"We made an emergency menu, which was a lot shorter," said Ms Kelly.
"It wasn't that great, but people were pretty understanding."
The cafe was painstakingly restored after a fire in August 2009.
"It's a little bit freaky, seeing [the damage], and smelling the fire as well," said Ms Kelly. "It brings back a few memories.
"And they say lightning doesn't strike twice."
Model Miranda Kerr name-checked Maranui as a favourite in an interview for the New York Times' fashion magazine earlier this month.
Related story: Cafe review: Maranui Cafe
- The Dominion Post
Do you intentionally buy organic food?Related story: Wellingtonians driving organic food mainstream