NZTA fails in bid for court costs

KAY BLUNDELL
Last updated 05:00 18/12/2013

Relevant offers

Kapiti

Grey backlash to proposed Westpac closure in Waikanae where median age is 62 Work on $1m park and ride to begin in Waikanae, a year after land purchase Election silly season kicks off: Kapiti mayor shocked after sign gets flambe treatment Walkers found in Hemi Matenga Memorial Park, near Waikanae Otaki Gorge Rd open again after closing due to small slip Arise Church slammed by parents for 'stealth' preaching at secular Kapiti College Horowhenua gardens on display for Koputaroa School, Waiopehu College fundraisers Young horticulturalist's career blooming No vote needed for some seats across Kapiti as nomination deadline passes Kapiti Coast proposes to create no-scattering zones for the ashes of loved ones

The High Court has refused the New Zealand Transport Agency's application for more than $11,000 in costs after two community groups lost appeals against consent for construction of the Kapiti Expressway.

Save Kapiti and the Alliance for a Sustainable Kapiti lost their appeals in August, and Justice David Gendall reserved costs. He indicated that, if lawyers could not agree between themselves on the issue of costs, the matter could come before the court.

No agreement was reached, and NZTA sought $11,542 as the successful party.

Save Kapiti said a pragmatic outcome would be one in which each appellant met one half of any costs award. But the alliance said it was a small group that did not have the money.

Justice Gendall refused to award costs, saying they were to lie where they fell.

"This is a situation where both Save Kapiti and the alliance, although unsuccessful, were genuine in bringing their appeals and had a legitimate public law challenge on issues of general importance for the community and the region.

"There seems to be no suggestion that the appeals were brought for personal gain of any type . . . the appellants were two community groups, with the alliance in particular suggesting it has entirely limited financial means," he said in his ruling.

Ad Feedback

- The Dominion Post

Special offers
Opinion poll

How many coffees do you have a day?

5 or even more

3-4

2

1

Anything from 1-5.

Don't touch the stuff.

Vote Result

Related story: Coffee as we know it at risk of dying

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content