Suicides expose failings in mental health service

Last updated 05:00 15/02/2013

Relevant offers


Hamilton machete victim recalls horror attack Hottest jobs in the public service Global focus on child abuse shifting from response to prevention Positive reception from Aus trip fuels fight against 'injustice' - Andrew Little Turakina Maori Girls' College closed due to multiple failures, minister says Taylor Swift's crew apologise after filming at Bethells Beach causes bad blood Bomb threat closes city's popular tourist spot Waikato DHB to take stand against gambling Hot, windy as firefighters battle Marlborough forest fire Revealed: The highest paid public servants

A young woman killed herself after being refused help by mental health workers who said their shift was nearly over.

Coroner Ian Smith criticised the failings of mental health services - such as delays in assessing patients, communication breakdowns, and poor documenting and sharing of information - in his reports released yesterday on three suicides in the Wellington region between November 2008 and August 2010.

Leigh McGuinness, 27, committed suicide at a respite-care centre in Brooklyn in November 2008, the morning after her mother sought help for her from police.

The officer who answered the phone asked two members of Capital & Coast District Health Board's crisis assessment and treatment team if they could help, but was told they could not because they were due to finish work in 15 minutes.

Mrs McGuinness took her daughter to Wellington Hospital's emergency department, and she was transferred to the respite-care centre. She was found dead there the next morning.

Mr Smith agreed with most of the 13 recommendations her family made in their submission to her inquest, including that mental health professionals should be prepared to work overtime or call in backup.

Capital & Coast clinical director Alison Masters said that, since Ms McGuinness' death, team processes had been reviewed and a procedure manual introduced.

In all of his reports, Mr Smith identified failings and recommended procedural changes to the DHB's mental health services.

He said the death of Graham Webber, 59, in April 2009, showed a breakdown of communication between the mental health service, patients and patients' families.

In his findings on the suicide of Porirua resident Gwenyth Kingsbury, 48, in August 2010, he said possible delays with patient care needed to be eliminated.

Mr Smith accepted the team had already made significant changes but would keep a close eye on the lack of communication.


Lifeline: 0800 543 354

Depression helpline: 0800 111 757

Youthline: 0800 376 633

Samaritans: 0800 726 666

In an emergency, dial 111

Ad Feedback

- The Dominion Post

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content