Homes for Kiwis plan may be a winner

Last updated 06:18 29/07/2013

Related Links

Labour plan to bar foreigners from buying homes

Relevant offers


Infant milk formula 1080 scare: MPs welcome arrest news Defunct health cost-cutting scheme lacked organisation, DHB buy-in - report David Seymour's voluntary euthanasia bill to be lodged in Parliament Stoush erupts over benefit figures - good news, or bad news? Government asks for Labour's support on TPPA Judge orders Trade Minister to review his refusal to release TPPA documents Andrew Little: $2000 a day bill for Paula Rebstock CYF work 'a disgrace' Labour would stick to ban on foreign house buyers despite TPPA - Andrew Little Shutting down multinational tax rorts could mean 'more work for tax advisers' Cropping-related deaths low compared to other farming activities

OPINION: It has to be said from the outset, Labour's newly minted "foreigner ban" on buying existing residential houses has a lot more going for it than the late and unlamented "man ban".

For a start there is not a big constituency of voters to turn off among property investors who are not even in the country. It reminds you of that old joke that the best people to tax are foreigners living abroad.

And it is a fair bet the idea will win public favour, given the overwhelming opposition to any sell-off of Kiwi assets that shows up in most polls. Prime Minister John Key tapped into it in 2010, when land sales rules were being revised, by voicing concerns Kiwis may become "tenants in their own land".

As such the policy announced by Labour leader David Shearer yesterday - which overlaps existing Green and NZ First policy - is about politics as much as it is about housing. It will also give Mr Shearer the welcome chance to front-foot an issue other than his leadership.

The bar would apply only to non- resident, non-Australian buyers of existing houses - new builds will be permitted because it increases the overall housing stock.

According to BNZ, 9 per cent of houses are sold to people who do not live here, and of those about one in five is an Australian buyer. So Labour would bar about 7 per cent of the satisfied demand - enough to make a difference. But it is just one of a series of measures, along with a capital gains tax and a more benign regime for first-home buyers than the one the Reserve Bank is poised to fire at the property market, in a key battleground for the 2014 election.

The ball is now in the Government's court to explain how it will shield first- home buyers from the effects of central bank rationing of loans. The supply of houses remains a more critical issue, though.

Labour's plan to build and on-sell 10,000 affordable homes a year - alongside a promise of more state houses - remains its most potent weapon.

Ad Feedback

- The Dominion Post


Special offers
Opinion poll

Where do you stand on political coat-tail riding?

If it gets marginalised voices into Parliament, I'm for it.

I'm against it - if you don't get the votes, you shouldn't be there.

It's just part of the political game.

Vote Result

Related story: Voters reject riding on the coat-tails

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content