Ohariu - and Dunne - on a knife edge

Last updated 05:00 12/11/2011
cand xs
MAARTEN HOLL/Fairfax NZ

JOSTLING FOR POSITION: Candidates line up at the Ohariu meet-the-candidates event.

Relevant offers

Election 2011

Cunliffe: cleanout needed now Winston gives up the good life to 'fix NZ' Maori Party tries to seal deal Key-like qualities give Shearer the edge Coalition deals may be in place by weekend Peters won't rule out release of tea tape Shearer emerges as favourite for leader The Davids: Why I should be leader ACT coalition nearly ready Labour contenders chase Jones' vote

Peter Dunne is facing the fight of his political life with a new poll showing he is holding on to the Ohariu electorate by the skin of his teeth.

The Fairfax Media-Research International mini poll shows the UnitedFuture leader, who has held the north Wellington seat for the past 27 years, could be ousted by Labour's Charles Chauvel.

It put Mr Dunne on 37.4 per cent, less than two points ahead of Labour's Charles Chauvel on 35.6.

National's Katrina Shanks is a distant third on 19 per cent and the Greens candidate Gareth Hughes registered just 1.4 per cent.

A massive 34.6 per cent of voters were undecided.

The poll, conducted on Wednesday night, surveyed 163 voters and has a margin of error of 7 per cent.

Research International spokesman Paul Epplett said that means the race for Ohariu is too close to call.

''There are a lot of people who are going to stand in the ballot box and make up their mind at that point in time.''

Prime Minister leader John Key has urged National voters in Ohariu to back Dunne; he even attended UnitedFuture's annual conference in August to extol the virtues the Government's stable support partner.

However, Mrs Shanks has been campaigning hard, hitting the malls and building her support.

The poll shows voters like her and many are refusing to accept the deal National struck with UnitedFuture in a bid to guarantee it coalition partner after the election.

Of those who are going to give their party vote to National, 40 per cent said they would vote for Mrs Shanks.

''What that is saying is that her strength in the electorate is undermining Peter Dunne's likelihood of retaining the seat,'' Mr Epplett said.

That means every vote for Mrs Shanks is now a vote for Mr Chauvel.

Mr Dunne had a noteworthy resurgence during the 2002 election campaign when he charmed the television debate audience participation ''worm'' with his commonsense approach.

United Future swept back into Parliament with eight MPs.

But since then, Mr Dunne has struggled to find a winning formula and his popularity has fallen every election; from a giddy 12,500-vote majority in 2002, to 7700 in 2005 and plummeting to 1000 after the 2008 election.

The fact that Mr Dunne remains popular in the electorate can be partly attributed to the lifeline National has thrown him.

Mr Key has continually said he wants to have support partners after the election, even if National was in a position to govern alone after November 26.

UnitedFuture represents a solid partner which hasn't faced the dramas that have befallen ACT and the Maori Party over the past term and led to MPs quitting their parties.

However, it appears voters are becoming irritated with deals done over electorates.

At a heated candidates' debate in Wellington suburb Ngaio this week, Mr Dunne was accused of being a ''fence sitter'' who changes his allegiances when voters change the government.

Even the ever popular Mr Key seems unable to convince Ohariu voters to back Mr Dunne.

Related stories:

Candidates face off, Dunne has everything to lose

Ad Feedback

Live chat replay: Claws are out in Ohariu

- © Fairfax NZ News

14 comments
Post a comment
Mark   #14   05:00 pm Nov 16 2011

I love it how most of the people commenting on this clearly don't live in Ohariu and have underlying agendas.

My favourite is the pro-cannabis lobby who seem to think one man can hold parliament to ransom. (if there was really a mandate for law reform it would be done and Dunne couldn't stop it - the buds are affecting your brains)

Matt   #13   07:20 am Nov 14 2011

You're not publishing comments on how small the sample size was, and how huge the error was, and how low the standard of journalism to rely on such flawed polling was? Why not? Scaredy cats. Do your job right, instead of pushing this level of incompetence on to us.

Alex   #12   02:49 pm Nov 13 2011

I hope he is not elected. He's far out of touch with the Ohariu voters. Charles Chauvel however is. United Future will join the same club which NZ First joined 3 years ago .. the ex-parliamentary parties club.

Vic   #11   via mobile 01:45 pm Nov 13 2011

I think that Peter Dunne has been a spectacular MP for Ohariu for the last twenty-odd years and I'll certainly be giving him my vote on the 26th.

keepitat$13anhourformorejobs   #10   05:10 pm Nov 12 2011

Time for tea with Key ?!

SPC   #9   04:26 pm Nov 12 2011

Is Key deliberately trying to discredit MMP by making these electorate deals - is he really trying to influence the electoral referendum to bring in his preferred SM?

Eddie   #8   03:35 pm Nov 12 2011

Dunne and dusted I hope a one man band does not work these days time for change I say

Phyllis   #7   03:15 pm Nov 12 2011

Having been an Ohariu voter for 20-odd years...in my humble opinion, Mrs Katrina Shanks would make a more worthy representative for Ohariu in Parliament than either Mr Peter Dunne or Mr Charles Chauvel. I'm urging my Ohariu friends to give 2 votes to Mrs Shanks - 1 for as our MP and 1 as per the Party vote....Go, show 'em, Mrs Shanks that their percentages count for nothing BEFORE the election!!!

M   #6   01:47 pm Nov 12 2011

As soon as the 20,000 vote man is out the better. It is because of him many disabled people are unable to have medical cannabis as a better alternative to the highly addictive and corrosive pharma medications on offer. What it boils down to is this guy is unable to show compassion for disabled people. Is that the sort of person you want in charge as Associate Minister of Health?

Andrew   #5   11:35 am Nov 12 2011

All the publicity around how close the fight is for Ohariu will hopefully drive voters to think hard about who they want running their electorate. I really can't think of anything useful that this guy has done in Ohariu and I'm no fan of political tarts. For the first time there is a real opportunity to get rid of this fence-sitter and also to show the major political parties that we don't like being told who to vote for.


Show 1-4 of 14 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you use self-service at the supermarket checkout?

Yes, I find it so much more efficient.

No, it is way too complicated and I'd rather have a human do it.

No, but I would if it was an option at my supermarket.

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content