Foster to drop appeal in deal with mayor
DAVE BURGESS
Relevant offers
Wellington
Rebel councillor Andy Foster is set to withdraw his appeal against a $46 million indoor sports centre after striking a backroom deal with Wellington Mayor Kerry Prendergast.
Mr Foster has accepted an offer from the mayor to do a new review of the preferred site for the 12-court centre, currently earmarked for Kilbirnie's Cobham Park.
The offer is conditional on Mr Foster agreeing to withdraw his Environment Court appeal.
It may not end the controversy, however, as the review does not deal with an appeal by Wellington resident Mike Mellor, which could still result in the issue heading to court.
Ms Prendergast and Mr Foster have been at war since he appealed against the decision by independent commissioners to approve the 12-court Kilbirnie centre.
The appeal could have delayed the project for up to 18 months. The council has spent about $3 million so far on the Cobham Park proposal.
Mr Foster lodged the appeal because he believed the complex could be sited on the Westpac Stadium concourse at the same cost to that proposed for Cobham Park.
Ms Prendergast has said the concourse option would cost at least $66 million and was too expensive.
The new review will look at the costs of the concourse proposal, which, when presented to councillors, was still at the conceptual design stage. The respective costs of both options could then be compared.
Both parties had agreed to abide by the review's findings but Ms Prendergast believed Cobham Park would still come out on top. "I'm confident the information presented to councillors is correct. But there is enough uncertainty in the community that it needs to be looked at by independent experts to confirm the council's advice."
She said the panel would be led by Sir John Anderson and she was hopeful it could report its findings in a few weeks.
Mr Foster had verbally agreed to the review yesterday after a meeting on Friday and was expected to put it in writing last night.
He said he would make suggestions for the review's terms of reference and processes, which are conditional to his acceptance. "It must be an open and transparent process. The report back must be a public one so everybody can look at the information which is presented.
"This will give the public the opportunity to look at the information, which is important for such a big investment for the city."
The review is the second forced by Mr Foster. Last June he voiced similar concerns over the centre, which led to what he labelled "a very quick and dirty peer review that only included council information".
That review found the concourse option was too expensive and recommended Cobham Park as the preferred site.
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
CYF kids can't imagine a good childhood
Payments could harm families, court told
Transmission Gully route wins Ngati Toa backing
Schools feel pressure as rolls swell
Some shops dip out on RWC windfall
Head quits after abuse response criticised
Man convicted of sex crime passes real estate test
Woman died after stolen car crossed centre-line
Wasp sting leaves tramper unable to see
Activists hacked McCully emails
Urewera accused had guns and explosives, Crown alleges
Gully cultural effects less than coastal route
Activists hacked McCully emails
Head quits after abuse response criticised
Woman died after stolen car crossed centre-line
Man convicted of sex crime passes real estate test
Wasp sting leaves tramper unable to see
Quake strengthening will 'anchor' tunnel
Fonterra says two recalls unrelated
Ricki Herbert extends All Whites contract
Billboards show declarations of love
Wellington still growing, despite slowdown
Porirua Employment Hub likely to close
Dressing room insight an A-League winner
'Sock bandit' turns himself in
Wellington competes with Super City beast
Man accelerated into girlfriend - crown
Deaf MP 'inexperienced' - Speaker
Police find woman's body near tower
Sediment from Gully would last 90 years
Rimutaka Incline train dream on hold
Quake strengthening will 'anchor' tunnel