Mathieu Bastareaud lied about Wellington attack

Last updated 16:11 26/06/2009

Mathieu Bastareaud admits lying

Related Links

Cheeky Bastareaud! Bastareaud bashing scene questioned Women to be interviewed in bashing case CCTV footage crucial to French beating case Thugs bash French player

Relevant offers

Wellington

Whare too small for waka Bus hits tourist from cruise ship Outstanding scholar keeps getting better Firefighters fly to Kapiti blaze Joust another day at the office Bunch of new dwarfs sing praises of The Hobbit Thai team to investigate Kiwi's death Milk bars served it up by the scoop Council fears loss of liquor ban areas Congratulations and be prosperous

French rugby player Mathieu Bastareaud is unlikely to face charges for wasting police time after he admitted lying about being assaulted in Wellington last weekend, the head of the police inquiry says.

Bastareaud had told police he was attacked from behind by five men outside his hotel early on Sunday morning, leaving him with a serious eye injury requiring stitches.

He admitted overnight he had lied after drinking too much following his team's Saturday night loss to the All Blacks and had fallen in his hotel room, hitting his head on a table.

Inspector Pete Cowan told NZPA Bastareaud's version of events began to unravel around Tuesday after inquiries turned up a lack of evidence to support his story.

CCTV footage from the Holiday Inn showed him entering the hotel early on Sunday morning without injuries.

Mr Cowan said Wellington police yesterday asked the New Zealand Rugby Union to contact their French counterparts to discuss the incident further.

''We outlined clearly our findings which showed Mr Bastareaud's allegations were a pure fabrication and suggested that Mr Bastareaud reconsider his position.''

It was because of this police action that Bastareaud admitted he had lied, Mr Cowan told Radio New Zealand.

''Mr Bastareaud hasn't come out overnight and apologised out of the goodness of his heart. This has been a strategy from us and the New Zealand Rugby Football Union have been strong supporters and assisted us in this.''

Mr Cowan told NZPA he was ''very doubtful'' Bastareaud would face charges for wasting police time.

Bastareaud had not laid an official complaint, but his fabricated story had wasted ''an enormous amount of resources'', Mr Cowan said.

Seven or eight detectives in Wellington had worked on the case for the past week, with assistance from their Auckland counterparts, he said.

Mr Cowan had seen Bastareaud's apology, posted on his team's website, and was ''waiting to see what Mr Bastareaud came back with'' before deciding whether Bastareaud would be asked to pay costs for the wasted police time and resources.

Auckland barrister Kit Toogood QC said it was not worthwhile police pursuing Bastareaud for wasting their time.

Although no complaint had been laid, the police had done the right thing by treating the matter seriously once alerted to it.

''At a stretch you could argue that by making the allegation to management he knew police would get involved,'' Mr Toogood said.

Ad Feedback

''But the reality is he's out of our jurisdiction and there's no point police wasting more time trying to teach him a lesson he's learned already.

''The guy's completely discredited anyhow.''

Mr Cowan said CCTV footage showed Bastareaud had arrived back at his hotel at 5.22am on Sunday but didn't enter his room until 25 minutes later, and ''what happened in that 25 minutes is obviously open to a lot of speculation''.

ALL BLACKS COACH PHILOSOPHICAL

All Blacks coach Graham Henry was philosophical about the whole unfortunate affair.

"It's just young guys making bad decisions isn't it," said Henry's at today's captain's press conference at AMI Stadium in Christchurch. "In this case they made a very bad decision. These things happen whether you're a Frenchman, an Australian or a New Zealander from time to time with young people. They make bad decisions, and they've copped it."

Henry also felt it was not up to the All Blacks to point any fingers, despite the fact that they too had been duped by Bastareaud's false accusations.

"We've been in similar situations in the past where our guys have made decisions. It's a difficult situation, and I feel for French rugby people. There is some relief that it wasn't New Zealanders involved. But let's be honest about this, we're not all squeaky clean all the time.

"We hope our young guys do make good decisions most of the time. But sometimes they don't."

Bastareaud's Stade Francais teammate, Italy captain Sergio Parisse, who is in New Zealand for the test against the All Blacks tomorrow in Christchurch, supported the young man.

"When you are young you make mistakes, but I think Mathieu is going to be a very good player for France," Parisse said.

"Now he is (in) Paris and I've talked with the other guys in Paris and the president (of the club). All the team are very, very close to him."

CLEAR COLLUSION

Wellington Mayor Kerry Prendergast earlier said she believed the French rugby team and its management had colluded over Bastareaud's story.

''There was clearly collusion, there were other players involved, the team doctor's involved, the coach because [Bastareaud] got sent back [to France] so quickly. This is wider than just one player ...

''Other people knew. You can't just say 'this is one person, he should take the blame on his own'.''

When asked how she knew there were other people involved, Ms Prendergast said she had gained that understanding from media reports.

The New Zealand Rugby Union said it was outraged that Bastareaud fabricated the story.

NZRU chief executive Steve Tew said like many New Zealanders, he was disappointed that the player chose to make a false statement and cast a negative light on rugby, Wellington and New Zealand through his deception.

''Like all New Zealanders, I am extremely disappointed with this series of events and will be expressing that concern to the French Rugby Federation.''

Bastareaud admitted he fabricated the story in a statement on the website of his French club team, Stade Francais.

He said he had had too much to drink on Saturday night and fallen in his hotel room.

''I was ashamed and panicked and I thought I would be sent packing by the team management,'' the statement said.

''I told the original story because I thought it would be believed, but given the coverage it has subsequently received I thought it would be better to tell the truth.''

He apologised to the New Zealand Rugby Union, Wellington, and his team and coaching staff.

Bastareaud now faces disciplinary sanctions from the French Rugby Federation (FFR).

In a statement, its president Pierre Camou apologised to the people of New Zealand and the New Zealand Rugby Union, and said he had asked the FFR disciplinary committee to open an inquiry into the incident.

The French Embassy in Wellington declined to comment.

- NZPA and RugbyHeaven

15 comments
Post a comment
Mr Quick   #15   08:44 am Jun 27 2009

Who are the other 2 French players who came back to the hotel with the 2 girls and Bastareaud???????

Good game   #14   02:20 am Jun 27 2009

Du calme. Ok the guy lied and deserves to be punished. I'm really sorry for the new zelanders cause he fooled everyone (including the french fans). But when I see that some of you are again talking about the rainbow warrior or are saying that french are used to stab in the back that's really unfair. The one saying that according to the British "the french are not to be trusted" must have an IQ of a rooster and seems to have no idea of the relations between great britain (FYI, GB is not just England) and France. It's not because Bastareaud made a huge mistake that we are all like him. I don't know if you are aware of that but for the rainbow warrior it's not the 60 millions french who have organised the bombing but the governement so please don't put us all in the same boat. When the Dunedin fans threw bottles at the french team, I was really shocked but I knew that it was an isolated incident from a minority of people and that the new zelanders were not all like these. Bref Bastareaud est un petit con (even if in France some are saying that he has not fallen on a table and that it was another french player who beat him up) but please don't misjudge the french. Vive la Nouvelle Zélande et Vive la France...

David   #13   06:26 pm Jun 26 2009

OK, so let's see the French pay up to cover the costs of our Kiwi cops [sounds familiar, shades of the French state terrorist attack and murder in Auckland with the Rainbow Warrior] and if they don't, issue a warrant for his arrest so when he turns up for the World Cup [as another French hero] he can be locked away on arrival.

tim   #12   04:50 pm Jun 26 2009

Sasquatch #11- He (Bastard)told Sydney reporters on 23/6/09 the aricle was by Nathan Beaumont, I'm with you Lafaele I'll meet you at Featherston Street :)

Sasquatch   #11   02:13 pm Jun 26 2009

Kram #8 - No kiwis died on French soil in either WWI or WWII when France was being liberated in WWII or holding the line in WWI on the western front.

Lafaele #9 where is it reported by the media he said that? Besides, if he did and they are citizens of NZ then they are Kiwis (aka New Zealanders) first and whatever else second.

Stu #10 AGREED! it is a crime to make a false statement to police. Hence why the French got him out of NZ record fast!

Stu   #10   01:47 pm Jun 26 2009

I was disgusted at the story when I first heard that. Thinking how bad New Zealand has got with all the bad crimes being committed in the last few years....This guy should pay for police time!!! Cant believe the management would try cover this up if they did...

Lafaele   #9   01:38 pm Jun 26 2009

When the story was first reported by media, he was attacked by a group of Polynesian/Pacific and Maoris. He along with his team and the French Rugby Union should apologise to the named communities. How would our Pacific and Maori players currently practising their trade in France and Europe feel and be treated as a result of this LIE! The media also needs to note this point as once the lie was discovered, it became NZ and not Pacific & Maoris as reported earlier.

Kram   #8   01:32 pm Jun 26 2009

That so many Kiwi service people laid down their lives for the liberation of France during the first and second world wars is a tragedy of enormous proportions considering the french have been stabbing us in the back ever since.

Sasquatch   #7   12:58 pm Jun 26 2009

The British have an old saying "The French are not to be trusted".

LOL@Matt #4 my thoughts exactly.

tim   #6   12:47 pm Jun 26 2009

And didn't he say he was attcked by Polynesians, I mean come on, some people seem to have forgotten about that eh!! Well next time he visits Wellington his wish might come true.


Show 1-5 of 15 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content