Calming classics send teens packing

BY PAUL EASTON
Last updated 05:00 30/07/2009
SOUNDS DIFFERENT: Brenden McCarthy, 18, left, Caity Randall, 17, and Matt Ashford, 18, check the mall music  police say is reducing  trouble.
ROBERT KITCHIN/The Dominion Post
SOUNDS DIFFERENT: Brenden McCarthy, 18, left, Caity Randall, 17, and Matt Ashford, 18, check the mall music police say is reducing trouble.

Relevant offers

Wellington

Whare too small for waka Bus hits tourist from cruise ship Outstanding scholar keeps getting better Firefighters fly to Kapiti blaze Joust another day at the office Bunch of new dwarfs sing praises of The Hobbit Thai team to investigate Kiwi's death Milk bars served it up by the scoop Council fears loss of liquor ban areas Congratulations and be prosperous

Police have enlisted the help of Beethoven, Tchaikovsky and Vivaldi to drive troublesome teens from outside a Lower Hutt shopping mall.

Classical music wafted from speakers installed in Bunny St outside Westfield Mall yesterday, to the horror of Dane Collins, 17.

"It's disturbing. They need to change the DJ, they should be blasting out Tupac and Bone Thugs," he said.

The idea, used to varying success in other areas, was adapted by community constable Paula Harris.

Youths hanging out outside the mall had become a problem for security staff and people waiting for the bus, she said.

A "core group" were trespassed from the mall but came back almost daily.

Speakers were installed outside the mall in November last year to play "classical and calming" music at the youth hangout.

The move was backed by Hutt City Council, police and Westfield Queensgate.

Repeat trespassers were arrested as a further deterrent.

"So far, there's been very positive feedback about the music and the decreased numbers of youths congregating in the area," Ms Harris said.

Similar schemes have worked in other centres. Beethoven calms waiting passengers at Australian train stations.

In Christchurch, the dulcet tones of Barry Manilow were played in Stewart Plaza to scatter youths involved in littering, tagging and fighting.

Lower Hutt teens were divided on the merits of the musical assault yesterday.

Meg Burt, 20, said the classical music had driven him across the street. "It's sleeping music."

Discontent with the music spanned the generations. June Waldron, 77, said it was "very dull". "You want something you can get up and dance to."

However teenager Caity Randall, 17, liked it. "It kind of reminds me of a carnival, it's nice and calming. It adds a touch of class to the area."

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

7 comments
Post a comment
Anna   #7   09:29 pm Aug 05 2009

I completely agree with the girl Caity on her opinion. I myself have been there, and think it does add some class.

Good to know some teens out there still have some appreciation for the arts.

G Williams   #6   04:08 pm Aug 02 2009

Fantastic idea, I think more of the main cities in NZ should take up this plan. Good on June Waldron for wanting something more lively!! if young people can enjoy sitting outside a mall listening to music, why cant people of other ages have a bit of enjoyment out of it too. :)

Evan L Wgtn   #5   01:04 am Jul 31 2009

Interesting that a lot of popular hip-hop and rap music, such as Nas "I Can", Ludacris – "Coming 2 America" and Young Buck "Say It to My Face" uses samples of classical music from artists such as Beethoven and Dvorak. Insidious!!

Inglebert Humperdink   #4   11:53 am Jul 30 2009

Why does June Waldron, 77, want something to 'get up and dance to' on the pavement outside a shopping centre?!

JC of Chch   #3   09:55 am Jul 30 2009

Funny really, I'd enjoy a couple of hours listening to Beethoven, Tchaikovsky or Vivaldi. I would have to draw the line at exposing people to Barry Manilow, however, as I think that Human Rights and mental cruelty issues may be involved.

I wonder if the Bone Thugs could possibly be as bad as their name suggests? They're probably quite nice chaps, just a little confused.

Bert Rox   #2   09:33 am Jul 30 2009

Go Bert!!!

Bert Meinders   #1   08:59 am Jul 30 2009

Since most contemporary New Zealanders cannot function without music of some sort being played in the background (If it were quiet, their minds might start working, and we can't allow that), it's entirely proper that some of it should be classical. If children don't like it, there are plenty of places, including their own cars, where they can hear their choice of music-for-the-deaf or the chanting of American slumdwellers or whatever.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content