Ad Feedback

From hongi to 'the finger'

Cullen says Tuhoe members show they're ready to look to the future

The Dominion Post
Last updated 23:05 31/07/2008
ROBERT KITCHIN/The Dominion Post
RUDE GESTURE: Te Weeti shows his disapproval as he follows Tame Iti after signing papers in Parliament's Banquet Hall yesterday.

Relevant offers

Politics

Sharples' stepson to be ordained in marae first Harawira may not be forced out of party Community boards watching Auckland Dispute leads to investigation of chief executive National rules out review as Labour ends bank consensus National makes progress on ETS bill Submitters push for third-party insurance Arise and awaken, Sir Ngatata Goff to end accord on monetary policy Key denies bowing to China on Dalai Lama

The behaviour of Tame Iti was "impeccable" but a one-fingered gesture by his Ruatoki neighbour Te Weeti risked souring a historic step toward Tuhoe repairing its troubled relationship with the Crown.

The two men were among more than 400 iwi members at Parliament yesterday for a signing of the terms of negotiation for Tuhoe's Treaty claims.

Though Tuhoe did not sign the Treaty of Waitangi it has entered formal negotiations - though iwi chief negotiator Tamati Kruger has said a desire to be self-governing and the return of Urewera National Park could become sticking points.

Treaty Negotiations Minister Michael Cullen said in his speech that Tuhoe members had shown they were prepared to look to the future.

"There is a long history here of land confiscation, executions, various other breaches by the Crown ... and this I think is a day when we can begin to move forward."

Te Weeti, who led the Tuhoe hikoi to Parliament last year to protest against armed police raids in Ruatoki, made the one-fingered gesture toward Crown officials after signing the documents.

When asked why, he said he disagreed with Dr Cullen's speech about looking to the future.

"He was saying things will heal. No, they won't, mate. His house was not booted in."

Iti, who is on bail and facing Arms Act charges in relation to the October police raids, issued a challenge with a taiaha and performed a hongi with Dr Cullen.

Iti's behaviour yesterday was later described by Dr Cullen as "impeccable".

Labour had criticised National leader John Key for a hongi with Iti during Waitangi Day celebrations, with Trevor Mallard telling Parliament: "I cannot believe any responsible politician in New Zealand will endorse Tame Iti in the way John Key did at Waitangi."

Mr Kruger said the police raids in October were the latest example of a bad relationship with the Crown. The start of Treaty negotiations was historic and positive.

Claims included the loss of land and lives, the execution of unarmed prisoners during the New Zealand wars and the Crown's 1916 raid on Maungapohatu and arrest of Tuhoe prophet Rua Kenana.

Mr Kruger predicted Government "unease" at sensitive aspects of the claims.

"I think the tricky issues are around Tuhoe's desire and wish to have Te Urewera National Park regarded as part of our territory.

"The second one that would be difficult for the Crown would be discussions over self-government."

Dr Cullen said the negotiations, which he hoped would be completed within a year, were a first step toward resolving grievances.

Ad Feedback

Tuhoe will also be a main beneficiary in the $420 million Central North Island collective "Treelords" deal, which was settled in June.

 

16 comments
Richard   #16   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

you have to go to a higher level if you require answers try the UN and look under scorched earth policies! everythings there!

Richard   #15   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

two words leagal binding who wants to get into a discussion about whats right and whats wrong i did a little research you have to go to the UN to find some of the mandate in regards too lodging the claim everything prepared on somewhat higher level.

DS   #14   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Cullen seem to be throwing money around: half a billion to Toll for 30-year-old rail stock; half a billion to iwis in Treelords settlement, and there seem to be no public debate to justify that this money/assets is deservedly spent, while an anti-smacking bill had been debated for months and Pharmac can't afford to fund the full course of an anti-cancer drug. NZ is supposed to be a florishing democracy, except when it comes to forking out large chunks of taxpayers cash, which seems to be decided in backroom deals with the interested parties. I can't find any info what specific grievances are getting addressed in that Treelords deal and even why it is called Treelords in the first place.

TeWeeti admira   #13   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

That gesture was made to the reporters.

Patrick Beatson   #12   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

I consider all the comments I read below to be racist and illinformed.

I wish all New Zealand and New Zealand media would make more of an effort to examine history and realise how badly European immigrants and colonial governments ripped off the Maori.

These settlements that are made are a tiny percentage of the current value of the assets stolen. The thefts have been proven in a kiwi court of law. Many of the crimes took place in the last couple of generations also, not way back in some vague smokey past. They are only the claims that can be proven by written proof and deeds and signed cotracts that have clearly been broken. They are a token recogntion and appology for appauling, arrogant and criminal deeds.

Last year under some joke "Terrorist" claim, the Tuhoe had their homes and land invaded again. If the government and pakeha public can't handle a finger as a response to having armed soldiers crash through the doors of your homes without any proven justification then they should just grow up.

Lets look at out history, accept the wrongs of the past, try to applogise and compensate, (even if it is a token amount) and get on with living as two people, with two ethnic identities under the umbrella of one national identity.

john brian   #11   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

I was taught that History was the chance to learn from our mistakes to make a better future - not try to fix the past. The Treaty is done, for better or worse it is over, lets move on together not fractured as individuals.

Gavin G   #10   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Nice to see that Te Weeti has such respect for the treaty negotiation process. Just imagine the headlines if somone from the crown behaved in such a manner.

It has reached the stage with the amount of people leaving New Zealand each week it will just leave the Maori behind to fight amongst themselves for the spoils. Oh how the pendulum swings.

The treaty gravy train steams on even though the engine driver appears intoxicated. When is enough enough.

Taxpayer   #9   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

The saddest thing Tamati is that one can no longer comment that the actions of people like Te Weeti are offensive without being confronted with shrieks of racism.

I have worked for over 45 years and fought a war for my country. I find it sad that people like Te Weeti and Tame Iti who have done virtually nothing for our land but foment dissension, can put their hands out and demand money.

People like these are a problem for Maori people because the time is not far away when the silent majority is going to say enough!

Tamati Olsen   #8   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

It's so sad to see comments such as those by Graham Keech and the 'taxpayer'. Goes to show there's a long way to go on both sides of the book.

David W   #7   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Te Weeti - how extremely disrespectful, given the opportunity to enter negotiations with the government considering they never signed the treaty in the first place.


Show 1-6 of 16 comments
Ad Feedback
Special offers
Opinion poll

Should Manners Mall make way for buses?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: Mall campaign pays for 'protesters'

Featured Promotions