NZ Cricket rejects misconduct cover-up claim

BY GEOFF LONGLEY
Last updated 05:01 23/11/2009

Relevant offers

New Zealand Cricket's chief executive Justin Vaughan has rejected any suggestion that his organisation is covering up two serious incidents of misconduct involving Black Caps cricketers.

Vaughan said yesterday the issues regarding Jesse Ryder abusing team manager Dave Currie at the Champions Trophy tournament in South Africa in September, and Otago team-mates Neil Broom and Aaron Redmond breaking curfew in India on the New Zealand A tour in August, were handled appropriately.

Vaughan said that while incidents on the field come under an international code of conduct which required publicity to be given to the disciplinary process, that was not the case for off-field issues.

Vaughan said misconduct was dealt with in-house under the agreement between New Zealand Cricket and the New Zealand Cricket Players' Association.

"They are private between the employer and employee and they are not made public. We are under no obligation to do that," he said.

In Dunedin yesterday, Currie downplayed the verbal altercation with Ryder that culminated in the injured batting star being fined for another discipline breach.

Ryder first took out his frustrations on a chair as he crossed the boundary rope in Johannesburg after smashing 74 from 58 balls against Sri Lanka despite batting in pain with a groin injury.

Currie initially sought to congratulate Ryder as he left the arena but after witnessing the chair being hit he tried to caution the 25-year-old.

Once inside the dressing room, Ryder – whose injury had ruled him out of the remainder of the tournament and cost him a lucrative payday in the inaugural Indian Premier League's Champions League – lashed out, swearing at Currie and telling him to go away.

Ryder's reaction to his dismissal mirrored a similar episode at Napier in March when he clunked his bat on the apron of the pavilion exiting after scoring a double ton against India.

Currie defended Ryder after that outburst, and was in a conciliatory mood yesterday, saying the fine was appropriate and their working relationship was fine.

"You wouldn't hope to have that behaviour but you accept cricket's emotional," Currie said.

Ryder had acknowledged his actions were unacceptable, Currie said.

"We went through a process, we're fine. This stuff happens in teams all the time, emotions can get ahead of yourself. I like him, he's a character and teams need characters."

Ryder, undoubtedly one of the side's finest strokemakers, has had a chequered history since his one-day international debut against England in the summer of 2007-08. At the end of that series he punched a window in a Christchurch bar, requiring surgery, before abusing hospital staff. Last summer he was stood down from the final ODI against the West Indies after missing a team meeting while concerns persisted over fitness and weight issues. However, his value is without question. The left-hander averages 49.88 from 11 tests.

Ad Feedback

Meanwhile, Broom and Redmond owned up to breaking team curfew and inadvertently starting what was described as a "riot" in Chennai.

Their confession came after the pair had gone out drinking and then questioned by police.

Once police realised they were New Zealand cricketers they were put in a taxi and sent to their hotel.

Redmond said they had not told team management that they would be leaving the hotel.

"Unfortunately when we decided to leave the nightspot we were picked up by police following another poor decision to hand out money to people living on the street, whereupon a crowd developed," he said.

"The police initially took us back to the station and then arranged for a taxi to take us back to the hotel."

-with NZPA

- © Fairfax NZ News

9 comments
Post a comment
Stef   #9   03:24 pm Nov 23 2009

Bloody hell Ian, that's quite a statement. To me, it's just a case of a hot-headed young guy who was a bit pissed off at getting out. He made a mistake, but that's all. I remember our greatest batsman, MD Crowe, being similarly annoyed after getting out for 299. I should think if anyone had tried a similar tactic to Dave Currie they would have received a similar tirade back in their direction.

wolfman   #8   12:50 pm Nov 23 2009

Vaughan is a disaster. Ever since he has been CEO, here have been nothing but cock ups. What is it about Sports CEO's in this Nanny Country, not one of them have a clue. Look at League, went bust, Rugby, a complete farce run by an arrogant air head, Cricket, sack the coach as the players didn't like him. Vaughan is too weak for the job. Look at the Warriors, sack good players and keep rubbish. Says it all really.

bm   #7   12:41 pm Nov 23 2009

Ryder's attitude should be celebrated not looked down upon. The reason NZ is becoming a lesser and lesser force is simply because our batsman accept getting out. Firing up after getting out at least shows that Ryder cares about his wicket. The last NZ batsman that used to get this angry when getting out was Martin Crowe. Is it little wonder these two have proven (while only over a short period for Ryder) to be very successful.

Neil   #6   12:41 pm Nov 23 2009

Although it is hard to condone bad behaviour in any sport it is not hard to understand why a guy like Jesse Ryder reacts the way he does. It is interesting - his temper outbursts seem to happen after he has batted very well - e.g. after the 200 last year and the Champions Trophy this year - the greater the achievement the greater the let down when it is over maybe?

rossp   #5   12:26 pm Nov 23 2009

Can someone tell me why the media thinks they deserve to be told everything?

No one the media a dam thing, get over it

As usual this is just another media beat up in a slow news week.

RainMan   #4   10:27 am Nov 23 2009

Um so whats wrong with being a tad upset when getting out? He's a competitive and emotional guy, of course he's going to show some frustration. If any these clowns in the media actually played competitive cricket you'll know what happens behind the scenes. Cricket's a one chance game when it comes to batting. There are times where you can put all the hard hours and come out with a golden duck at the end of it. Leave him alone because I can guarantee he isn't the only one to show emotion when getting out.

If anything we should be praising the lad. Isn't that a good sign that a New Zealand batsman isn't content with getting 40's, 50's.

/rant

Shane   #3   10:07 am Nov 23 2009

Well done Justin Vaughan. Neither of these incidents really warranted any attention.

We seem to have a perception problem when it comes to employee/employer relationships in sport. Not to get at the author of this piece but would he be okay if we reported on a disciplinary matter he might have with his boss?

I don't think any of us would. Maybe we should just leave this sort of stuff to the employers and the staff.

Richard   #2   09:09 am Nov 23 2009

At Ian #1

Or perhaps he was a tad upset about missing out on all his IPL money...

Ian McKinnon   #1   07:08 am Nov 23 2009

Leave Jesse Ryder alone. Obviously his competitive, uncompromising desire to win contravenes the left-wing ideals the majority of sports journalists in the Fairfax stable harbour. A pity more of New Zealand's sportspeople did not share his enthusiasm, driven out by nine years of sick liberalism, preached by socialist schoolteachers and Labour/Green adherents.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Are you worried about a big earthquake in Wellington?

Yes, I feel unsafe

A bit, but I think we'll be ok

No, it's all hype

I don't care

Vote Result

Related story: Quake fear: No way in or out

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content