Fans want Cruden but Cooper may pick Ripia
BY TOBY ROBSON
Relevant offers
Manawatu star Aaron Cruden may be eased in, rather than unleashed, on the Super 14 this season.
Hurricanes coach Colin Cooper appears to be leaning towards handing the more experienced Willie Ripia the No 10 jersey for Friday's season opener against the Blues in Albany.
It would be a decision at odds with the franchise's fan base, with a poll on the Hurricanes' website last night showing overwhelming support for Cruden to be thrown in the deep end.
As of last night, Cruden had 61.8 percent – or 1435 votes – in a poll that asked who should start the season at No 10, with Piri Weepu on 21.7 percent (503 votes). Ripia had just 385 votes, or 16.6 percent.
However, Ripia has been the more dominant figure during the pre-season, starting in all three of the Hurricanes' matches, and would be the sensible, if slightly conservative, bet to take the reins initially.
Last season, the Hurricanes coaches threw young age-grade prodigy Dan Kirkpatrick into a starting role at No 10 with mixed results, and Cooper admitted it had been a learning experience.
"We know it's a big step up and it's about managing players. There are some lessons learned from last year, so we just have to make sure we manage Aaron and work out whether it is best for him to start or come off the bench," he said.
"That will come down to how he's gone in the pre-season, how he is physically and the opposition we are playing.
"Willie is going really well and the young fella is coming on too. We are still working through which is the best starter and which is the best off the bench."
Kirkpatrick struggled in the starting role during the opening two games of last year's Super 14 and was replaced by Ripia for the rest of the season.
Ripia played strongly before a disappointing effort in the semifinal loss to the Chiefs.
"Willie is a very good attacker and he's got better and better. He has a lot of experience and that has to come into account," Cooper said.
"He played very well last year, but because we didn't win the semi that has probably affected him and affected the whole team.
"The No 10 has so much pressure on him. When things don't go well, you are usually looking at the 10 or the nine, and I think last year a lot of that pressure from outside the group went on him. There's a lot of learning there from us as coaches.
"The 10 is a major, major decision for coaches in any team, I think. He's certainly a better player and been showing that."
Cruden undoubtedly carries a weight of expectation from Hurricanes fans after starring at national age-grade level and for Manawatu during the Air New Zealand Cup.
He admits the step up to Super 14 level is taking some adjustment but is clearly keen to test himself further during the season proper if given the chance.
"Probably the pace of the game and the physicality. Those are the things I thought would be a major difference from the Air New Zealand Cup and they seem to be the main things at the moment," Cruden said.
"It's a challenge and that's what you want. The pace of the game steps up, but you get that every level you step up in footy. It's good, I'm enjoying the challenge."
Ironically, Blues coach Pat Lam has the choice of starting Kirkpatrick against the Hurricanes, though most expect Canterbury recruit Stephen Brett to get first crack at first-five.
The TAB are clearly expecting the Hurricanes to have a strong season, installing them yesterday as $1.60 favourites to start the season with a win against the Blues ($2.25).
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
Canes will go nowhere with Ripia at pivot. Do the Canes want to play boring, ineffective rugby like Taranaki? Cruden will spark the potent Canes backline.
The blues half back and first 5 (kpatrick) are both hurricane 2nd choice players, man 4 man the blues have nothing on any of the canes backs. its guna be a good opening away win on friday nite!
#2 & #10 you say its silly to compare kirpatrick and cruden but do you actually know much about them besides what you just read??? they both were captain of the new yealand under 21 team and they both won the IRB age grade player of the year but it is a great idea not to rush him in, super 14 is a massive massive step up and he stil needs to put some size on and build into it otherwise he's going to get knocked around and not given the chance to develop into the great play he can be.... Go the canes and good luck willy you can lead them to a great season.
dan #4, No one ever remembers wellington to be consistently in the finals. People only remember teams that won the trophies... BTW, Wellington has been stealing so many Aucks players for years and still is... Dream on chokers...
Cruden will be great - key point is will be though. He is not quite there yet and I if I was the coach i'd be tempted to bring him on from the bench with 20 or more minutes to go. That should give him enough game time to settle in and show how good he is and also realise the rise in class before he proves he can start the game
Well, I haven't seen much of Cruden to be honest. I live overseas and have seen only glimpses of him playing for Manawatu on my scratchy monitor. By all accounts he has the goods apart from his goalkicking which appears as a real weakness.
I hope he doesn't turn into another Isaia Toeava in that the coaches and media talk him up as the next best thing with seriously outrageous talent, only to see the poor kid crack under the weight of expectation and promise. It got to the stage where whenever Toeava played well, the AB coaches made special mention of him to seemingly boost his confidence. I hope this doesn't happen to Cruden.
...there will never be any good first fives that don't come out of Canterbury. Cruden is just a show pony to massage the egos of the Canes masses and he will be found out in the S14!
The Blues are the second most successful team in Super rugby, they have a better head to head against all teams except the Sharks (and are tied with the Cursaders at 8-8), they won't have 16 new faces as they did last year and Pat Lam has had 1 year behind him. They may not win on Fri but they will have a better year than the Canes.
"(Cruden) is happy playing flat, where as Ripia sits in the pocket as he did against the Chiefs in last years semi and kicks the ball down the oppositions throat."
True that.
I still think Aaron is gonna have a steep learning curve in the S14 tho, it's a big step up from NPC. Definitely not wise to just chuck him in there, he'll be better served watching and learning and getting some confidence through select game time in his first season.
Crowe's workout sales pitch lures Gurley to Saints
'Shape up or ship out' the newest Firebirds way
Hurricanes steal Sonny Bill's thunder
Key players missing for Phoenix game
Nick Willis dons shoes for Silverstream track
'Disgust' over Wellington club player's fine
Cricket-mad TV host on top of her game
Hurricanes fight back to beat Chiefs
Super teams prepare for mid-season interruption
Capital take chances at softball champs
Parents don't want son's killer in town
Clock ticking for Transmission Gully process
Bid to scrap race relations office
Man injured after vehicle rolls in Lower Hutt
Weavers shape Ohariu Valley paradise
Fay aims shot at OIO over Crafar
Quake felt across lower North Island
Exide plant closure plan within week
'Disgust' over Wellington club player's fine
Key players missing for Phoenix game
Lloyd Morrison gets Town Hall funeral
Hurricanes steal Sonny Bill's thunder
Quake felt across lower North Island
Parents don't want son's killer in town
Trap for burglars catches policeman
Man injured after vehicle rolls in Lower Hutt
Avatar sequels to be made in Wellington
Study reveals the happiest Kiwis
High cost of living mars return to NZ
Fear of dangerous rift from wealth gap
Hurricanes steal Sonny Bill's thunder
Mallard case raises questions of behaviour
Bid to scrap race relations office
Are you worried about a big earthquake in Wellington?
Newest First
Oldest First
Realistic Guy you may want to check your facts before you question others. Dan Kirkpatrick was not captain of the NZU20s. That team was captained by Chris Smith of North Harbour. Also Dan was not IRB Age grade player of the year. He was player of the final. Player of the year was Luke Braid, BOP flanker. Oh and by the way I know both players personally and they are chalk and cheese on and off the field. You may want to dig a bit deeper than your local rag when you start quoting "facts".