Blinkered Aussie approach sours NZ test win

22:32, Dec 12 2011
Australia's Peter Siddle appeals for a wicket during day one of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's Peter Siddle appeals for a wicket during day one of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
New Zealand captain Ross Taylor looks back after being dismissed.
New Zealand captain Ross Taylor looks back after being dismissed early on the first day of the Second Test against Australia at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's James Pattinson appeals for a lbw decision on the first day of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's James Pattinson appeals for a lbw decision on the first day of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's Peter Siddle is congratulated by team-mates after getting the wicket of Martin Guptill on the first day of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's Peter Siddle is congratulated by team-mates after getting the wicket of Martin Guptill on the first day of the Second Test against New Zealand at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's Ricky Ponting (left) celebrates with captain Michael Clarke (second from right) after New Zealand's Martin Guptill was caught on the first day of the Second Test  at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Australia's Ricky Ponting (left) celebrates with captain Michael Clarke (second from right) after New Zealand's Martin Guptill was caught on the first day of the Second Test at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
New Zealand captain Ross Taylor reacts after his dismissal on the first day of the Second Test against Australia at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
New Zealand captain Ross Taylor reacts after his dismissal on the first day of the Second Test against Australia at Bellerive Oval, Hobart.
Trent Boult
Debutant New Zealand quick Trent Boult took three wickets in the Australian first innings.
Mike Hussey
Mike Hussey takes the walk back to the pavillion after Trent Boult claimed his wicket.
David Warner
Australian batsman David Warner survives an LBW shout from Ross Taylor and Martin Guptill.
Peter Siddle and Doug Bracewell
Peter Siddle watches as Doug Bracewell fields a shot.
Ross Taylor
Ross Taylor, not out on 42 at stumps on day two, plays a delivery off his pads.
Jesse Ryder
Jesse Ryder plays and misses at a ball down the leg side.
James Pattinson
Australian rookie pace bowler James Pattinson signs autographs for some young fans.
Ross Taylor and James Pattinson
Australia's James Pattinson is exuberant after removing New Zealand captain Ross Taylor.
Chris Martin appeal
Ricky Ponting and wicketkeeper Brad Haddin appeal for Chris Martin's dismissal.
David Warner
Australian opening batsman David Warner misplays a ball off his pads.
Nathan Lyon
Australian spin bowler Nathan Lyon is high-fived by team-mates.
Peter Siddle
A fired-up Peter Siddle reacts after taking a wicket.
Tim Southee
New Zealand's Tim Southee appeals for an LBW decision against David Warner.
Doug Bracewell
Lower-order batsman Doug Bracewell ducks under a bouncer.
Tim Southee
Michael Clarke of Australia leaves the field after being dismissed by Doug Bracewell of New Zealand during day four of the second test.
Tim Southee
Phil Hughes of Australia leaves the field after being dismissed by Chris Martin of New Zealand during day four of the second test.
Tim Southee
Doug Bracewell of New Zealand celebrates taking the wicket of Ricky Ponting of Australia during day four of the second test.
Tim Southee
Australia's Ricky Ponting leaves the field as New Zealand's Doug Bracewell celebrates taking his wicket during their second test cricket match.
Black Caps v Australia
Doug Bracewell of New Zealand is congratulated by team-mates after getting the wicket of James Pattinson of Australia during day four.
Black Caps v Australia
Tim Southee of New Zealand celebrates taking the wicket of Brad Haddin of Australia during day four of the second test.
Black Caps v Australia
Doug Bracewell of New Zealand appeals during day four of the second test.
Black Caps v Australia
David Warner of Australia celebrates making his maiden test century during day four of the second test.
Black Caps v Australia
Tim Southee of New Zealand celebrates but his appeal for lbw is unsuccessful during day four of the second test.
Black Caps v Australia
New Zealand players celebrate after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
Black Caps v Australia
Doug Bracewell of New Zealand celebrates taking the wicket of Nathan Lyon of Australia during day four of the second test.
New Zealand players celebrate after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand players celebrate after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand players celebrate after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand players celebrate after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand captian Ross Taylor celebrates after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand captian Ross Taylor celebrates after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand bowler Doug Bracewell celebrates after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.
New Zealand bowler Doug Bracewell celebrates after beating Australia in the second cricket test match at Bellerive Oval in Hobart.

It's hard to know what was the biggest slap in the face - the blinkered Australian cricket public voting David Warner as man of the match over Kiwi hero Doug Bracewell or Michael 'Pup' Clarke's distasteful post-match television interview?

If we were in Australia, we'd roll out another of those dreadful mobile phone polls to answer the question, but let's not.

First things first, pandering to sponsors has gone too far. Over the ditch, gone are the days where the man of the match award is judged by an impartial panel of experts who look objectively at the merits of the contenders and, as a rule, pick the deserved winner.

Michael Clarke
IN THE SPOTLIGHT: Michael Clarke failed to acknowledge New Zealand's performance in his post-test speech at Hobart.

No, now we have a situation where the Australian public jump on their mobile phones to decide the man of the match, with the player who gets the most votes receiving the official award. It's nothing more than a popularity vote.

Doug Bracewell was hands down the man of the match in Hobart. He took nine for 60 in the match, turning the result New Zealand's way on the fourth day with the defining second innings figures of six for 40.

Warner's 123 not out was a remarkable innings in the context of the match, but by definition he was not the 'man of the match'. Even Ian Healy would have to agree with that.

Advertisement

Warner got 58 per cent of the vote and Bracewell just 27, but Bracewell could have taken all 10 wickets in the second innings and still not been given the accolade.

Yes, it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things and you won't hear Bracewell, or any of the other Black Caps, complaining. They won, Australia lost, end of.

But the man of the match will be entered into the history books and those people reading those books in decades to come will not get an accurate reading of what transpired yesterday when they look at the man of the match column.

The test was decided by Bracewell's outstanding feats with the ball.

At the end of it all, Warner's knock was just another test hundred in a losing effort and will be quickly forgotten. Bracewell's spell won't be.

Veteran Australian radio commentator Jim Maxwell was highly critical of the public's decision, while Mark 'Tubby' Taylor, who provides a welcome modicum of objectivity in the otherwise cringeworthy Channel Nine comm box, was also hugely surprised.

But they were in the overwhelming minority of fair dinkum Aussies, and given the way Clarke talked in his immediate post-match interview, he may well have been one of the 58 per cent in the Warner camp.

Yes, he was right to acknowledge Warner's innings, but he gushed with praise of No 11 Nathan Lyon's batting exploits in a 34-run partnership, without one single word of congratulation to New Zealand, who, let's remember, actually won the test.

There is a lot to like about Michael Clarke, the batsman, but Michael Clarke, the captain, lacks class if yesterday is anything to go by.

Even the man all New Zealand cricket fans love to hate, former captain Ricky Ponting, would have been the first to acknowledge New Zealand's performance in Hobart.

Sure, it's a lot easier to be gracious in victory, but Ross Taylor was all over Clarke in the captaincy stakes.

Without prompting, he heaped praise on Warner's contribution to the test, almost before mentioning his own team.

It's just a shame Clarke could not return the sportsmanship.

The Australian public should expect better of their test captain, but yesterday's mobile phone poll result also suggests they should also expect better of themselves.

Stuff