Such a Payne that it had to end this way

BY FRED WOODCOCK IN SYDNEY
Last updated 05:00 15/03/2010
1 of 9 Phoenix goalkeeper Liam Reddy (right) protests for hand ball as Sydney FC players celebrate Chris Payne's second goal of the A-League playoff match in Sydney.
ANTHONY JOHNSON/Sun-Herald Zoom
NO WAY: Phoenix goalkeeper Liam Reddy (right) protests for hand ball as Sydney FC players celebrate Chris Payne's second goal of the A-League playoff match in Sydney.
Phoenix goalkeeper Liam Reddy
ANTHONY JOHNSON/Sun-Herald
UNANSWERED PLEAS: Phoenix goalkeeper Liam Reddy pleas with officials to over-rule Sydney FC striker Chris Payne's second goal, which went in off his left forearm.

Phoenix handed controversial loss

Opinion poll

Did Chris Payne's handball goal change the outcome of the Wellington Phoenix vs Sydney FC preliminary final game?

Yes, the Phoenix could have won if not for that goal

No, Sydney would still have won

Hard to say - it might have changed the game's momentum

It doesn't matter - let's not be poor sports

Vote Result

Relevant offers

Local sport

Matthew Bell ends lengthy innings Ellis back on the pitch despite agonising condition Joseph Parker a heavy-duty hero in waiting Weepu hopes to back up this week All Whites have chance to go one better Orcas capitulate and miss out on a place in final Best yet to come for shot put golden girl MSP victory would have special significance Union feels the pinch after posting another deficit Captain optimistic despite daunting semifinal challenge

Wellington Phoenix coach Ricki Herbert is refusing to let Sydney's controversial "Hand of Payne" goal sour a breakthrough season for the A-League club.

An emotionally charged Herbert let rip post-match, questioning Sydney's ethics and the poor refereeing standards in the A-League after Chris Payne's blatant handball goal played a pivotal part in the Phoenix's 4-2 preliminary final loss at the Sydney Football Stadium.

He was more philosophical yesterday, rightly acknowledging the goal had not been the sole reason for the Phoenix's demise. But he was still contemplating what might have been.

"It's always going to sit in your mind," he said at the team's hotel in Sydney. "I think in 20 years, I'll look back on it and still be disappointed.

"Let's not take it away from Sydney, they were extremely good, but it's just disappointing an incident like that had a big effect on the game.

"This league is all about small advantages here and there and I think if we had of gone in at 1-1, our tails would have been up. I'm not sure what their reaction would have been, and who knows?

"We're going to have to live with it. The only thing I've said is `who is accountable for it?' I haven't seen anybody accept responsibility yet."

Payne's antics overshadowed a brilliant attacking display by Sydney, in particular Alex Brosque, and a disappointing Phoenix performance that fell well short of the benchmark they set in previous weeks.

They were simply out-thought and outclassed across the park.

Herbert acknowledged Sydney's superiority but yesterday preferred to accentuate the positives from the season.

"I couldn't be more proud of this group, 95 per cent [of the media] didn't pick us to even make the playoffs.

"We've proven with 33,000 people through the gate [in Wellington] as opposed to 13,000 [in Sydney] that we're a force to be reckoned with, and quite rightly so. We've made a difference to the competition.

"I couldn't ask for anything more. We were one step from a grand final, it's a massive change for New Zealand football, and our goal next season will be to get there."

Herbert agreed next season would be a much tougher proposition with increased expectations on his side, and said it was important the club "took stock" to ensure improvements were made across the board so they could take that extra step.

Ad Feedback

Phoenix captain Andrew Durante said they would learn from Saturday and he was confident they could challenge for the title next season, given the core of the squad remains.

"It's disappointing we didn't get through, but we've had a great season. We'll have a similar team and we'll add some new players to give us an even better chance of going one step further.

"It's going to be a hard season to top, but it's only going to get better for Wellington Phoenix."

English striker Chris Greenacre also reflected on a top season, tinged with disappointment at coming so far without reaching the big show.

"We know what it takes now to get to a grand final, so hopefully that will stand us in good stead for next season. We know we're good enough to compete at this level."

Durante wants the A-League to look at adopting fulltime referees in the wake of the Payne furore.

"I don't know what they're doing during the week, they're doing normal jobs and then they have to come here to a big occasion and referee. They need to look at it."

- © Fairfax NZ News

0 comments
Post a comment

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content