Susan Boyle in shock loss

Last updated 10:32 31/05/2009
Reuters
RUNNER UP: Susan Boyle has come second in the final of reality show Britain's Got Talent.

Related Links

Susan Boyle stuns audience again Susan Boyle 'threatens to quit' Pressure mounts on Susan Boyle

Relevant offers

Street dancers Diversity were the surprise winners of television contest Britain's Got Talent, beating favourite Susan Boyle who became an internet phenomenon and global celebrity after appearing on the show.

The troupe, which includes three sets of brothers and comes from southeast England, won £100,000 and the right to take the stage at the Royal Variety Performance in front of the Queen.

Of the 10 finalists, Diversity were the bookmakers' sixth favourite to win going into the show, but their acrobatic performance choreographed by 20-year-old Ashley Banjo was described by judge Simon Cowell as "utter perfection".

"If I had to give marks on that, that is the only performance tonight I would want to give a 10 to," Cowell said after their performance.

Boyle was runner-up, but so overwhelming were the betting odds in her favour that the result was seen as a major surprise.

The 48-year-old unemployed church volunteer from Scotland, who once joked she had never been kissed and has been described by newspapers as "frumpy" and a "hairy angel", was the antithesis of what many considered a celebrity to be.

Yet her rendition of I Dreamed a Dream from Les Miserables in April was downloaded on the internet more than 150 million times and made her a household name.

Film crews camped outside her home in the small town in Scotland where she lives alone with her cat, tabloid reporters followed her every move and she appeared on US chat shows hosted by Oprah Winfrey and Larry King.

PRESSURE

The pressure appeared to tell this week, when she threatened to pull out of the show and had an altercation with journalists.

In his blog, judge Piers Morgan wrote: "Let me tell you now, there is a downside to fame. People start criticising you, sniping at you, trying to trip you up, belittle you, harass you.

He said Boyle had learning difficulties after being deprived of oxygen at birth, and was nicknamed "Simple Susan" at school.

"I am calling today for everyone to just give her a break."

Ad Feedback

Boyle sang I Dreamed a Dream again in the final, and while her rousing performance was warmly received, it was not enough.

"You've had a weird seven weeks and you had every right to walk away from this and you could have walked away," Cowell said after she sang. "You can walk away from this, win or lose, with your head held high, Susan. I absolutely adore you."

Boyle, who praised Diversity after the public telephone vote was announced, said earlier in the show that the whole experience had been "well worth it".

"The pressure put on me has been overwhelming. I've got to put that aside now. When I step on that stage tonight it's the accumulation of 40 years of dreaming."

Despite not winning Britain's Got Talent, Boyle is widely expected to land a lucrative recording contract as a result of her global fame and impressive voice.

* Did the right person win? Watch Susan Boyle's performance here and Diversity here,and post your comments below.


- Reuters

123 comments
Post a comment
STK   #123   06:32 am Jun 05 2009

Susan Boyle should have won. Her first performance stunned the world. It was sheer perfection.

Mauldavia   #122   11:03 pm Jun 03 2009

I would have thought it was VERY obvious Susan Boyle would NOT cope with the rigor of performance and fame. Whilst she gave a very nice 'first' performance could they (the people in charge of the programe she appeared in), not see by her mannerism, and appearance, she could be somewhat challenged by the whole 'package'? There is so much more to singing than just opening your mouth to produce 'sounds'(nice, or not), and I would have hoped they could have helped her to cope with all that THEY know comes with it....

Dan   #121   01:51 pm Jun 02 2009

I never watched this but i remember watching on Youtube the video of Susan Boyle and another of that little kid singing Valerie and then that Michael Jackson song. He was WAY better than she was. She is completely mediocre. An old fat lady singing opera is not a rarity not is it one bit exciting. That little kid was one in a million. You see a couple of others that can sing, but this guy man could he sing! Susan Boyle doesnt even come close. Im sure someone will be able to remember his name but i only ever saw it on Youtube.

Age   #120   12:52 pm Jun 02 2009

Paul, you are in desperate need of a hearing aid. Susan's voice was anything but average. Although there was a massive media frenzy, she deserves accolades for dealing with the stress she was dealt from thoughtless people and her amazing voice. Both Diversity and Susan Boyle were incredible contestants which made for a fabulous final.

Re. Alex   #119   12:23 pm Jun 02 2009

It wasn't about sympathy. Susan Boyle represented the ordinary person that the masses can identify with; not some beautiful, god-like individual that the media would have us aspire to. Susan deserves something, whether that be a place at the RVP and/or a contract. Susan lost to Diversity because of her demeanour on the night, for which the media was chiefly responsible.

lynnek   #118   09:37 pm Jun 01 2009

I was amazed that Susan didn't win BGT. After all the things that have happened in her life, and the talent she has, she deserved to win. However, despite her loss, I'm sure with her beautiful voice she will go on to make a well deserved successful musical career. Can't wait for her debut album to come out. Good luck for a great future Susan.

haitoman   #117   06:44 pm Jun 01 2009

Latest from London - Susan Boyle carted off to a hospital clinic

Pat   #116   01:15 pm Jun 01 2009

Hey Paul, Susan is not old, 70 is old, not 48. Susan's voice is not average, and she's certainly not silly. learning disabled, yes, but not silly.

NZ Bev   #115   12:41 pm Jun 01 2009

Well done Susan, in our eyes you are the winner. As said earlier "Who will remember that group". It looks like "Tall Poppy Syndrome" encouraged by negative media by a few jealous people. We will be looking forward to your debut album.

Oz   #114   11:42 am Jun 01 2009

In a situation like this, where the public vote decides the winner, unfortunately being 'the best' doesn't mean that you'll definitely win.

Susan Boyle on BGT - Adam Lambert on AI and Anthony Callea on Australian Idol are prime examples.


Show 64-113 of 123 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Will Paul Henry be a big hit with Australians?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: Henry climbs into Aussie crisis

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

On the Box blog pointer small

On the Box: What's on TV with Chris Philpott

2 Broke Girls: the worst new show of 2012