CD review: Kirsten Morrell's Ultraviolet

Last updated 10:22 26/05/2010

Kirsten Morrell's new album, Ultraviolet is one of the main releases for New Zealand Music Month by one of the main music labels. So we'd better have a look at it - given that it's got the NZ on Air logo proudly displayed inside the cover and I've been hearing about it - via press releases - since around December last year.

Morrell, you'll remember, was the lead singer of Goldenhorse. They had a couple of good songs which they rewrote and re-released a couple of dozen times and they had aLending a hand is good for Morrell career that played out under the law of diminishing returns with their singles being played out ad nauseam on commercials, in cafés, on episodes of Outrageous Fortune...

I always thought that Morrell had a decent-enough voice if a little overly affected. She definitely annoyed me with her affected dancing: far from natural and just a little too much like a total act as she used to wind her arm around like the second-hand on a stopwatch, then rewind with stilted jerks and a shy smile. Round and round that arm used to spin and the coy shrug of the shoulders as she bubbled away. It was not normal. But anyway, she could sing.

It was clear though, especially after seeing the band a few times and listening to the albums, that the real brains in the band was Geoff Maddock. He and Ben King were experts at weaving guitar lines together, winding them around one another - Maddock, particularly, has always played with an arranger's ear.

I did laugh at the suggestion that came - more than once - from Goldenhorse's label (different from the label that has released Morrell's album) that the band was really something unique. Maybe in New Zealand - but there was talk of how all they needed was to wow people overseas. I'm not sure how that was going to work. I doubt the international market sat there waiting to be wowed by essentially an unofficial tribute act to The Sundays.

Anyway, now - seemingly far too late - we have Morrell's bid at a solo career. And really, it's unclear why the horse was termed golden when, musically, it was more of a one trick pony. The band should have knocked it on the head after album number two.

Morrell is really doing nothing more than ditching a career as a second-rate version of The Sundays and starting up one, slowly and when no one really cares, as a second-rate Lily Allen.

Ultraviolet begins with Ghosts, a far-too-cute-for-its-own-good pop song propelled, most bizarrely, by a distracting blast of cartoonish electronic percussion that sounds like when one of the cast of The Flintstones had to be somewhere very quickly ("Step on it, Barn'!).

Then we go to Friday Boy and it is to the whimsical world of Ms Allen (for the first of many times). Ew!

In Silent Window Morrell sings about a golden horse, how cleverly self-referential - but this sounds like something that could have been on any Goldenhorse record and to mark it as different the clever gNot Florenceuitars were flagged and an annoying backing vocal threatens to overtake the song, feeling overwrought and out of place.

Let Me Go feels like diet-Florence + The Machine, even seeming like an unplugged and uninspiring version of some of the Florence rhythms (Drumming Song this is not).

Then we get a glimpse of country-pop with I Fly Away; not a bad option. Goldenhorse's second album had some urban cowgirl flavours and was all the better for it but this songwriting is pedestrian, prosaic and makes Frente! - at their worst - feel like they were robbed of at least one or two Pulitzer Prizes.

To Town of My Bones then, where the synthetic textures are grafted back on to the bare bones of the song - and Morrell reverts to the stop-start Lily Allen-isms.

The first song that I heard, and maybe it was the same for you, was Cherry Coloured Dreams. An advance single. I don't mind this. It is not worthy of owning the album for this song. But I can't really tear this song apart. It feels like Goldenhorse-lite but that seems the most obvious thing you can say when the lead singer of a band steps out solo. It's certainly not a song that is a) going to save the world or b) even make it much of a better world to live in for the less than three minutes that it exists each time you press play. (In my case, that is not going to be too often so no big issue there.)

Better is unfortunately named - or ironically named - as most of the songs on this album are actually better than it. It's a tuneless lilt; a dart aimed at the board of modern folk and missing by a, erm, country mile.

More successful is Cold Spoilt Girl but we're nine songs into a 12-track album with a sub-40-minute running time.

And when I say more successful it's worth reminding you, even though it was just a paragraph ago, that this is more successful than an ironically named song, Better; you know, the one that most of the songs on the rest of the album are better than. Cold Spoilt Girl, funnily enough, even has a crucial use of the word "better" in its lyric.

It is, once again, a lame rewrite of the vague country/torch songs that were tried on the second Goldenhorse album. I know you think I am repeating some of my points here. But if you want to really immerse yourself in the world of repetition then perhaps this album really is for you.

Wandering Hands has the same tempo as most of the songs on the album. Ah, that's the problem! Everything feels like it is the same on this album. That brings me back to the point of repetition. But I won't repeat that point. Because I said I would not. So I won't. It's not good to repeat yourself. So I am not going to...two songs to go - dig deep...

Marianne is the 11th song on the album.

And then we get to He Walked In. The last song. Morrell sings "why do you do what you do to yourself". I felt like she was singing directly to me. You know how that sometimes happens with an artist - and a song? It speaks right to you. And you wish you could answer it. You really wish you could reply.

GoldenhorseWell, here goes. I do this, Kirsten, because I am a reviewer. That's whyI have lasted through your album. If I wasn't a reviewer then I would never have made it. I can't say I am better off for getting to the end. But I did.

I cannot believe that this is where the big money in New Zealand music funding goes to - the major labels, the NZ on Air people. They should be ashamed.

Anyway, that's just - as you will all form a line now to tell me - my opinion. That's just how I feel. How do you feel? Will you check this album out? Maybe you have already...I had to ask several times to get a copy of the album to review. So I'm hardly the first to comment on it.

Have your turn below. If you love this album or plan on getting hold of it, then say so. If you don't like it say so too. That's how it works.

» Join Blog on the Tracks on Facebook

47 comments
Post a comment
bentel   #1   10:48 am May 26 2010

I'd go there ...

Zarndy   #2   10:54 am May 26 2010

I'm wondering if it's possible to like your review AND like the album? I'm going to attempt both, because I respect both people.

Elle   #3   10:59 am May 26 2010

No, I don't think I'll be seeking this one out. I couldn't even make it through the whole of GoldenHorse's third album, even though I did quite like their first two. Sad really. Talent gone to waste is a dreadful thing.

max   #4   11:02 am May 26 2010

I really liked Goldenhorse when they first came out. Saw them live once two and they were a great live band. But I have heard the singles she has released as a solo artist, and I have to say they aren't that flash. We have enough 'electro-pop'cutesy artists around. We don't need another. Also, completely off topic but because she reviewed it the other week, how bad is the music/movie reviewer on Breakfast (Jo Hudkin). I know it is Breakfast, but can they get someone who actually knows/likes music??

Elle   #5   11:03 am May 26 2010

Couldn't. Agree. More. Only heard some clips on the radio and that made me feel that uncomfortable, embarssed, feeling... like when you see your Dad dance. Or an old lady who is dressed like she shops at Supre... Anyway, affected sums it up nicely.

R T   #6   11:06 am May 26 2010

I just had to check out some of the songs on myspace after reading that review. Couldn't get through the first 20 seconds of any of the songs.

Tipsy   #7   11:15 am May 26 2010

so ...you had to ask several times to get a copy of the album to review...

Why didn't you just buy it? Ahhh you didn't want to buy it because you had already made up your mind that you were going to slag it off! Of course.

Very transparent ... one of these days you will actually have something of importance to say ...

Some guy   #8   11:19 am May 26 2010

Spot on as usual. You're going to get some "cum on, kiwi music!!!" hate on this one but it's all true.

Sorry Kirsten but the magic is not in you alone darling. Geoff's genius for songcraft COMBINED with Morelle's lovely voice was the 1-2 punch of Goldenhorse (who I still think are a pretty cool band, in spite of selling songs to the interislander, or whatever it was). No matter how pretty Morelle is (she's very pretty) or how pretty her voice is (it's very pretty), it's the songs that count.

The Voice   #9   11:37 am May 26 2010

Your idealism is heartening but in the real world commercial decisions will always gravitate towards the safe options and in this regard Morrell already has a profile via her Goldenhorse days and a look & sound that is Tv / radio friendly.

H   #10   11:44 am May 26 2010

The first Goldenhorse album was pretty good, but after seeing Morrell throw a hissy fit mid-gig over some minor technical issue a few years back (they played with Pluto and Goodshirt, who basically blew Goldenhorse off the stage) I lost interest. Based on your review - opinion though it may be - I have no desire to investigate further.

You make a good point about how music funding is allocated in this country i.e. in the most risk-averse, MOR way possible. A quick poke around the NZ On Air website and the music it funds reveals a dispiriting amount of money spent on bland R&B, generic garage rock and artists who shouldn't need the money at this point in their career (for example: why on earth would any member of the Finn family need any kind of government funding?).

Anyone who does anything unique or interesting seems to do it off their own steam and the goodwill of struggling independent labels, but there always seems to be money for marketing the latest collection of bland major label pablum. Oh well. At least the Naked and Famous secured album funding this year.

Here's hoping that the new C42/PPNZ/IMNZ deal creates some better opportunities for independent NZ artists. It's just a shame that this kind of initiative has to come from the private sector rather than the government body charged with investing in local content.


Show 11-47 of 47 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content