Your headlines for my deadlines

Last updated 09:05 08/02/2012

Some of you read this blog because it's always negative. Some of you choose to not read this blog because it's always negative - but then somehow end up posting comments pointing that out. Some of you have told me that you enjoy the interviews I post from time to time. I'm often told that you want to know about new bands only, new albums, new artists.

And then I post about a new artist, band or album and nobody comments. That's fine. I assume some of you at least are still reading.

This is my blog so I get to pick what I write about. And though some of you may dispute this and from a narrow sample decide that I don't cater for you or your tastes, much as I make this - often - about my opinion (and then of course ask for yours; only to so often be told that what I've said is just your opinion man! without the person offering theirs) I do try to cover a range of material.

I once posted an interview with Rokia Traore after being told I don't cover enough world music. It received one comment. I've written about most genres, covered new and old, live and recorded, Kiwi and international. There have been opinion pieces (duh! It's a blog!) and interviews, gig and album reviews. I've let my guard down and told you plenty about myself - too much for many of you but I can't apologise for that. It's my blog. I can't know all of your tastes all of the time. If you don't like the blog you don't have to read it. Or you can tell me you didn't like it - as some of you do.

But, I thought of a way we could have a go at addressing anything that has not been mentioned, blogged about, discussed.

It's essentially a call for topics - and you might decide to interpret this as me being desperate and asking for ideas but given that I blog every weekday and have been for over four years and nearly 1200 posts, I can rest confident that I will come up with a topic each day. Music is a big enough subject.

No, rather, I'm seeing this as your chance to set me up, or your chance to make me deliver the content you want.

There will be another round of guest-blogs later in the year, sure. There might even be two. And sporadically there will be some one-off guest posts. If you have an idea and want to write about it here - you could always try me, see what I say. But no, I'm not trying to get out of doing any work here.

Here's how this will work. You will make a suggestion for a topic - you can even come up with the headline, potentially. I will write it.

I will do this next week. Every day next week. So I'm looking for FIVE blog suggestions/topics.

There are one or two obvious restrictions. I can't just magic-up an interview with Tom Waits next week. So don't ask for that. But if you want me to write about the "sadcore" genre (apparently that's what Lana Del Rey calls her music) or any other genre, real or imagined, then I will do it. If you want me to tell you about the best or worst gig I've been to then I will do it. But I can't commit to listening to every single album by The Fall (for example). I'll do my best to research and write the five topics next week though. And part of the process is that you'll get a discussion-point each day - knowing ahead of time (for once) what the posts will be about. I'll name the topics I pick and the day that I will post each - so, should you wish, you can go off and do your research on the topic to come armed for a fight.

If you want me to admit to the worst album I've ever owned and loved (my worst secret, shameful guilty pleasure) then I will do it. If you want me to name the best new things I've heard this year that's fine. You want to go deeper, darker, that's cool. Anything you suggest is fair game.

Make your case for a blog-post to be written and if I pick it I will do it.

A while ago I got you all to ask me some questions, anything you wanted to know about me with regard to music. And then in a series of posts I answered every single one of them.

This time it's the same sort of idea, but far simpler. You choose the topic and I will write it. So you can decide how much of me is included in it by what you ask. You can ask me to justify my disdain for a band or why I love an artist that you can't stand. You can ask me to explore a genre you are convinced I know nothing about.

You can ask for an essay-styled piece about Jackson Browne perhaps. Or it might be that you want to know more about James Blake. Even though I don't like him. I'll do the work and do my best to offer up exactly what you decide.

How will you know that I am honouring this? Well - I'll pick five suggestions - the five that I think will be a nice challenge, or cover ground that I haven't traipsed over all too often already, or that seem interesting (to both you and me). And I'll name all five this week - and I will write and post them next week. One each day.

Maybe you want me to write about this magical album?You write the headlines for me to make my deadlines. It's worth a shot, I figure - something different. What do you say? What do you want me to say? Make your suggestion below - I'll pick one topic for each day of next week and get to work. So it's your chance to determine what this blog is about. It must be music-related - that is the only (obvious) caveat.

Keep up with Blog on the Tracks on Facebook and follow on Twitter.

And follow Off the Tracks to read 'The Vinyl Countdown' - an album-by-album review of my record collection.

You can email me with blog-topic suggestions or questions.


Post a comment
Fraser The Amazer   #1   09:37 am Feb 08 2012

How about the positive impact on New Zealand music from Midnight Youth, six60, or Gin wigmore?

Shane   #2   09:39 am Feb 08 2012

Just Because It's Older Than Me Doesn't Make It Rubbish - music that pre-dates your birth but still has an impact.

Dan   #3   09:39 am Feb 08 2012

Devo, goddamnit.

Cat   #4   09:40 am Feb 08 2012

This might not be something you could do next week, but I think it would be good for one or more of your readers to suggest five CDs and you listen to them and comment.

AJ   #5   09:55 am Feb 08 2012

I went to see The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo the other day. I enjoyed this movie more than I expected and the music struck me as very interesting given Trent Reznor was in part responsible for the score. One thing that did make me scoff was when we first see the hacker who assists Lisbeth with equipment he is wearing a Nine Inch Nails t-shirt.


Bob Roberts   #6   10:02 am Feb 08 2012

Noel Gallagher!......

Danny   #7   10:09 am Feb 08 2012

OK Go- Is there more to them than just great one-shot videos? Go on...they only have 3 albums for you to listen to and make a judgement!

Bobble   #8   10:15 am Feb 08 2012

I'd be genuinely curious to know how you balance up the demands of being an album reviewer (lots of albums to listen, short deadlines, competing demands on attention, desire to listen to albums that aren't up for review, not in the mood for that particular album, etc etc) with the reality that some of the best albums are slow growers while some of the instant favourites turn out to be a fun sugar rush with no substance. I'm always amazed reading old magazines how many 'classic' albums got average to mediocre reviews at the time, while many raved about albums at the time fade into obscurity. And let's not overlook albums that get great reviews at the time when they're unknown but then blow up and suddenly everyone hates them...

flippi   #9   10:19 am Feb 08 2012

1-Geek Rock - From Modern Lovers to Weezer & beyond 2-The blurry line between hard rock,metal & punk (MC5, Black Flag, Grunge) 3-Musical What-ifs (eg if Hendrix had lived to join ELP) 4-Best albums that never were (eg a 1971 Beatles album) 5-"Worst" albums by artists that you actually like (eg Neil Young 'trans')

si   #10   10:28 am Feb 08 2012

'Witch House' - does it exist?

Show 11-60 of 97 comments

Post comment


Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.

Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content