We lost Hal David but we have his words

Last updated 09:15 03/09/2012

I remember, as a youngster, watching Monty Python's The Meaning of Life and in the scene where Death comes for dinner, one of the characters claims to love the music of Burt Bacharach - it's said, in much the same way that Neil from The Young Ones says that nobody listens to him, so he "might as well be a Leonard Cohen record".

In both cases - being young when I heard those one-liners, that was what turned me on to the music of Bacharach and Cohen.

In the 1980s it probably wasn't very cool to like Burt Bacharach's music - or Leonard Cohen's, obviously. But a decade on from those comedy observations, we're talking mid-90s, the music of Burt Bacharach had made a huge comeback. It was everywhere. And all the Britpop bands were talking about the influence and indie groups from all walks of life claimed an influence - and I have no reason to suggest that it was not sincere. (Cohen would get his revival another decade on from there.)

When I first heard Burt Bacharach's songs (realising that I had in fact heard so many of them via Aretha Franklin and The Carpenters and, in particular, Dionne Warwick without knowing on first listen that they were written by Bacharach) I was struck by these deceptively simple, gorgeous melodies. And how these little pop poems told stories (Twenty-Four Hours from Tulsa), reflected the times (Don't Make Me Over), spoke of simple joy (Magic Moments) and heartbreak (Anyone Who Had a Heart).

The Burt Bacharach songs of the 1960s were very different from the "Woodstock era" songs that get trotted out for Vietnam movies and TV shows, for musical montages where hippie nostalgia needs to be evoked.Burt And Hal

In the 1970s when disco and metal and punk were all about image and style (and lifestyle) as much as they were ever about the song, it's easy to see how the Bacharach compositions seemed lost. They were never about image and, as such, have largely been open to interpretation, viable to this day as worthwhile songs to continue covering.

I was always interested in the fact that people talk about Burt Bacharach but forget to mention Hal David, the lyricist - the writer of these great emotions. Sure, Burt married the words up beautifully, knowing the right way to create an arrangement, to blur some of the soppy idealism (What the World Needs Now Is Love) so as to create a gorgeous tune, a song.

But it takes two to tango, and when it takes two to write songs, as it did for Bacharach, Hal David was the one to assist in forming one of the world's great pop songwriting duos; it should be that both get equal praise. Bacharach - being a performer, an instrumentalist - has dined out on the revival, playing orchestral versions and being the subject of many tributes.

But he never wrote anything as wonderful as he did when paired with Hal David.

This weekend we lost Hal David - he was 91, he suffered a stroke. It's a great innings, 91, there's really no great sadness there in the sense that he lived a long life. And we still have his songs.

But in his passing we might reflect on the magic he offered the world. And maybe now we'll see some respect paid to David's phenomenal contribution to pop music.

My favourite Hal David/Burt Bacharach songs? Well it's hard to narrow it down - I've been collecting different versions of their hit songs for nearly 20 years now. I have the latest CD compilations and kitsch-covered LPs from op-shop bins. And the songs that David and Bacharach wrote for The Walker Brothers, Gene Pitney, Marty Robbins, Sandie Shaw, B.J. Thomas and Jackie DeShannon - to name just the immediate few that come to mind - also sent me off in the direction of those artists' catalogues. I can trace a love of Scott Walker's music back to hearing The Walker Brothers' version of Make It Easy on Yourself. At least a world away from Tilt - but that one song is what binds, that connected me to an artist I have carried on listening to, discovering so many wonderful things.The Hit Team

The same is true with Aretha Franklin - from my first Bacharach/David compilation a lifetime of collecting/listening was created.

With some of the other artists it was fleeting - one album (B.J. Thomas) but with others there was a respect found and interest paid that might not have been the case otherwise (Gene Pitney); it's about hearing the right song at the right time.

Hal David wrote so many of the right songs at the right time. For the right times. They live on now that he is gone. They have been living on since the late 1950s.

David and Bacharach first paired up to create The Story of My Life for Marty Robbins. That was in 1957. Later that year they had their first big hit - Magic Moments for Perry Como.

In the 1960s they turned into the hit-writing machine that created a career for Dionne Warwick - so many incredible/enduring songs...

David and Bacharach bickered and broke up. Burt wrote some hits with his then-wife Carole Bayer Sager and David continued to write, at least occasionally. One of his biggest successes, post-Bacharach, was To All the Girls I've Loved Before, teaming with Albert Hammond to create what would go on to be an enormous hit for Willie Nelson and Julio Iglesias.

But I think about the great songs from Bacharach and David together. And I think about them equally in terms of the magic/dynamic - they needed each other to create these gems. Bacharach's wonderful ear and touch is to be celebrated, absolutely, but he never made a song anywhere near as good with his other collaborators. It all seemed so effortless between him and David, even with the (physical) fighting and power-struggle.

My favourite songs by Hal David and Burt Bacharach - to name just a few - are Walk On By, The Look of Love, Anyone Who Had a Heart, Make It Easy on Yourself, The Windows of the World, (They Long to Be) Close to You, Magic Moments, A House Is Not a Home, Do You Know the Way to San Jose, (There's) Always Something There to Remind Me and I Just Don't Know What to Do With Myself.Hal David

But if I had to pick just one - then it's This Guy's in Love With You.

I've just always loved that song. It has a lot of personal memories and meanings.

So R.I.P. Hal David. And here's to all the great work by David and Bacharach. (Here's a tribute from The New York Times.)

Were you/are you a fan of the work Hal David did with Burt Bacharach? Do you have favourite songs from this great songwriting partnership? And do you agree that it seems unfair to focus on Burt Bacharach when assessing the phenomenal run of hits this duo had? Surely Hal David was a crucial part of the partnership.

Postscript: Here's a detailed song-list of the works of Hal David and Burt Bacharach.

You can keep up with Blog on the Tracks on Facebook and follow on Twitter

17 comments
Post a comment
Russell   #1   09:22 am Sep 03 2012

For me it's 'Promises, Promises.' What a wonderfully complex song - inspired in part by Warwick's desire to have something so impossibly complex to sing that the 'blue-eyed soul' British female singers wouldn't steal it from her. It worked.

Shane   #2   09:48 am Sep 03 2012

When I was younger all I could associate Bacharach/David songs with was the insipid programming of New Zealand radio. It wasn't until many years later that I could ever appreciate the skills they had.

The two that stand out for me are Walk On By and I Say A Little Prayer both originally sung by Dionne Warwick, although some of the various cover versions of Walk On By have been quite good.

Hal David and Henry Mancini also wrote on of my most liked instrumental pieces, Baby Elephant Walk, which whenever I hear it makes me want to whistle along with it.

Pamela   #3   10:00 am Sep 03 2012

A big fan of the works of Hal David. In reading your list of favourites, I sang every title as I did so - can't help myself, so ingrained are they in the memory banks. If I had to choose one song, I'd go with Dionne singing "Walk on By".

And yes, it annoys me when any lyricist is seemingly eclipsed by the composer in the public's eyes. It happens often. In fact, just looking now at my Hal David/Burt Bacharach CDs - they are all labeled by the manufacturers as only by "Bacharach".

Darryl   #4   10:03 am Sep 03 2012

Hal David and Burt Bacharach were such a great combination, so many classic tunes. Their melodic and lyrical class shines through no matter who tackles the material. Hit with the very blunt instrument of the White Stripes "I Just Don't Know What to Do With Myself" still works. That's the mark of a great song.

R.I.P. Hal David

Danny   #5   10:07 am Sep 03 2012

I always loved the words (and music too) to "I'll Never Fall In Love Again". Magic stuff, from one of the great lyricists.

I'm only kidding   #6   10:07 am Sep 03 2012

Didn't the White Stripes write 'I Just Don't Know What to Do With Myself'?

Ken   #7   10:15 am Sep 03 2012

He's not my favourite lyricist, but I always felt for Hal David having to find words that could actually scan across those melodies. They go all over the place and never just repeat a simple pattern.

You can really hear him struggling sometimes ("... are saying so much more than mere words could ever say" etc) but you have to hand it to him on degree of difficulty. I mean, imagine getting handed the melody hook of "Promises, Promises". What the hell would YOU do? I'd tell Burt that's a fantastic instrumental and hand it back.

I think his finest hour was "San Jose".

Ironic ian   #8   10:40 am Sep 03 2012

I hate fans of Hal David....

George   #9   11:01 am Sep 03 2012

"Windows of the World" is an antiwar song written at the height of the Vietnam War. it's subtle (like "the Ballad of El Gooodo" by Big Star), which not many antiwar songs are, but I'm sure the message got across at the time.

abi   #10   11:30 am Sep 03 2012

@ironic ian _ obviously your moderator fell asleep here.


Show 11-17 of 17 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content