Your Oscar verdict - was film the winner?

Last updated 11:52 09/03/2010

Chicken OscarsWell, the Oscars are over for another year.

It was another history-making occasion with Mo'Nique invoking the name of the first black woman to win an Oscar, Hattie McDaniel, and Kathryn Bigelow breaking through the glass ceiling to become the first woman to win the best director statue.

It was a fairly tense three-and-a-half hours, with Avatar and The Hurt Locker pacing each other throughout the ceremony, splitting the technical awards fairly evenly between them.

But in the end it was The Hurt Locker that came through as the little film that could, beating the big, blue, 3-D Goliath that was Avatar.

You've gotta wonder if the words: "I'm King of the world!" were still ringing in the Academy's ears when it came to posting the ballots. Surely a reluctance to see Jim Cameron crowing all over again was at least a factor in voting for his ex-wife's film rather than his. Not that she doesn't deserve it, but Hollywood prefers humility in its victors rather than cock-o-the-walk arrogance.

You can see all the winners in their gushy (yet humble) glory here. And for anyone wondering why Brangelina were absent, it's because they're too damn famous, that's why (plus no personal nominations.... not that they're sulking or anything...)

A bigger issue was why wasn't Farrah Fawcett included in the In Memoriam segment of Hollywood folk who'd passed on?

 So what did you think of the outcome of the 82nd annual Oscars?

Was film the winner at the end of the day? (No, it was Kathryn Bigelow, dummy.)

I've got to go off to the Ellerslie Flower Show's media day now - oh the glamourous social whirl never ends...

23 comments
Post a comment
Chaz   #1   12:08 pm Mar 09 2010

Yep, Avatar deserved the technical awards, Hurt Locker and other films deserved the creative excellence awards. All fair wins in my opinion, and the best speech of the night came from Sandra Bullock. Alec Baldwin and Steve Martin were hideous and the show was a total mess, what relevance a horror montage had to do with any of the ceremony is beyond me...should have let people have more time to make speeches, especially those in the smaller categories who got shunted off stage - awkward!!

paul   #2   12:08 pm Mar 09 2010

I would be more impressd if Kathryn Bigelow wasn't the first woman to win. I think there have been others who deserved it in the past - but she was the current choice du jour. Avatar deserved to win the technical awards of course - but District 9 could have also been a great Best Film choice.

Michael   #3   12:11 pm Mar 09 2010

Avatar deseved it's technological awards but did not deserve anything to do with Best Picture or Director and I'm glad The Hurt Locker took it, although I was rooting for Inglorious Basterds...I am just glad Avatar didn't win

Stephen   #4   12:23 pm Mar 09 2010

It was a boring ceremoney. Baldwin and Martin were boring. The starting sing-song was crap. It was also way over long, despite winners being told to reduce the time they take for their winning comments. The wrong film won best picture - Avator will be remembered in 10 years time, The Hurt Locker won't. The wrong director won too - it appeared to be PC to vote for Biglow rather than Cameron or any of the other Directors. The ending was rushed - I nearly missed who won best picture. The best positive were the awards the Weta guys got and again NZ continues to roll in the Oscars (since Paquin's win, NZer's have reguarly been collecting Oscars).

Sarah   #5   12:50 pm Mar 09 2010

Was mad that Streisand said Bigelow was first woman nominated for Best Director Oscar. Ummm, Jane Campion anyone?

Tee   #6   01:00 pm Mar 09 2010

I think Hurt Locker won for the wrong reasons. I think it won so that Avatar wouldn't. This is because film snobs (not dissimilar to the writer of this blog) love to shun popular movies and dismiss them to make themselves sound above the masses under the pretense of being a film connoisseur. Its really stating to annoy me actually. The Hurt Locker simply wasn't as good as everyone says it is. Good don't get me wrong, but by no means one of the greats.

The bottom line is if it wasn't running against Avatar it wouldn't have won.

yy   #7   01:05 pm Mar 09 2010

I agree, the ceremony was really really boring. But I liked the bit before the Best Animated Feature award with the characters at a junket. There were a few jokes that was good, but Steve Martin and Alec Baldwin didn't work. I haven't seen the Hurt Locker so don't know if it deserved Best Picture.

Scott   #8   01:14 pm Mar 09 2010

The Hurt what? I'd never heard of it until the awards were coming up, and I don't recall ever seeing it in the cinema screening ads.

At least I finally managed to make it to Blue Pocohontas. There is no way that film would take out best picture. Technically brilliant, yes (congratulations Weta!) but it was too long and with a very simplistic plot.

District 9 I thought had an outside chance, but historically its not the sort of film that wins. Odd enough that it even got nominated.

As for the rest (both films and awards) YAWN. Its been a pretty ho hum year really.

Dr Cameron   #9   01:14 pm Mar 09 2010

When oh when oh when are people going to get it!!!???

When James Cameron said "I'm the king of the world!" he was QUOTING FROM THE FILM THAT HE HAD DIRECTED (and Yes, I am shouting because it seems to be the only way to get through to the pundits and critcis). I am sure he was not "crowing" but was (IMHO) making a reasonable witty and relevant comment. Poor chap - he may be difficult to work with, he may have a bad rep - but please stop vilifying him and give him some appreciation for actually directing entertaining and successful movies. (p.s. I enjoy his movies and think they do deserve awards for ground-breaking effects, but he does have a tin ear for dialogue and, I don't believe the movies themselves are necessarily Oscar worthy for Best Picture. But if Oscars are awarded for ability to manage a huge logistical nightmane, having vision, and capability to organise actors and technicians and bring a vision to the screen, then he deserves nominations for Best Director).

rosie   #10   02:15 pm Mar 09 2010

Dr Cameron - everyone knows that and it was not witty, merely facile. your 'shouting' just displays your own ignorance of subtlety.


Show 11-23 of 23 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content