Film Review: My Name is Khan

BY MICHAEL FIELD
Last updated 15:59 18/02/2010
My Name is Khan is a peaceful if slow and disjointed movie.
CAUSING PROBLEMS: My Name is Khan is a peaceful if slow and disjointed movie.

Relevant offers

Film

Entertainment Quiz 10/2 Connolly to play Hobbit great dwarf DVD review: Jane Eyre Sharon Stone embraces her age The George and Brad Show Moustache film festival to be held in Maine Having fun around the world Garfield scared of Spider-Man DVD review: Rise Of The Planet Of The Apes Uggie's final bow wow at the Oscars

Aucklanders have been watching a high profile Bollywood movie that is seriously stressful to watch in Bollywood.

My Name Is Khan is a cross between Rain Man and Forrest Gump wrapped in rotis and served with over cooked birinyi.

An otherwise inoffensive, if mildly engaging movie to a New Zealand audience, it has buried in it so many India codewords that people are rushing to the barricades to stop it screening.

It is virtually impossible to see in Mumbai - or, as Rahul Gandhi (Rajiv Gandhi's son) termed it, Bombay.

The movie is notable because celebrated action man Shahrukh 'SRK' Khan is the main star. Just about anything he is in will turn a profit on his name alone.

His character is different in this movie. He plays Rizvan Khan who suffers from Asperger's syndrome which makes it very hard for him to emotionally connect with others.

The death of his mother in Mumbai means he has to move to San Francisco to be with his reluctant brother.

At this point the 1988 film Rain Man comes into play. Dustin Hoffman's character in that was also travelling across America. He was an autistic savant.

Khan - whose name defines his Islamic religion - finds happiness with a Hindu divorcee and her son. All is well until the events of 9/11 and American hostility toward Muslims increases.

The plot gets complicated and Khan finds himself trekking across America wanting to meet the president. It borrows heavily from Forrest Gump.

In fairness though, SRK brings to a lot of skill to playing Khan.

The plot meanders toward the second half, and some of the filming is plainly silly. A black village in Georgia is some kind of Indian parody of what they think American rural blacks live like.

The movie is in all kinds of political strife in India, especially Mumbai.

Part of it has nothing to do with the movie at all. People are angry that SRK said it was wrong to exclude Pakistani players from this year's IPL Twenty20 cricket.

Also behind the protests is Shiv Sena, an extreme Hindi group that controls Mumbai politics and is rapidly sending the great city back to the Stone Age.

Rather than see themselves as Indians, Shiv Sena wants Mumbai to be indigenous Marathi - and people like SRK and all the others leave.

It's so bad that one of Mumbai's greatest sons, cricketer Sachin Tendulkar, is having to say he is Indian first ... and was then attacked by the Sena.

Ad Feedback

It is the Sena who insist on Mumbai - much of the rest of India was content with Bombay.

It makes My Name is Khan an ironic film, because its rather unsubtle message is that Muslim and Hindu can get along together with problems.

It's a peaceful if slow and disjointed movie. It's good to watch if only because you can.

My Name is Khan
Director: Karan Johar
Starring: Shahrukh Kahn, Kajol Mukherjee
Time: 161 minutes
Rated: M
Trailer: www.mynameiskhanthefilm.com

- © Fairfax NZ News

12 comments
Post a comment
sunil   #12   06:10 pm Apr 08 2010

a unique ray in the fog

zuzu   #11   07:20 pm Feb 24 2010

BRILLIANT MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!! KARAN JOHAR REALLY OUT DID HIMSELF TO MAKE SUCH A AWESOME MOVIE!! 10/10 THATS FOR SURE

Ravi Bhadam   #10   10:24 am Feb 23 2010

This movie is showing in Mumbai, all over, so I dont why you are saying it isnt. Great that Karan Johar's movie is a big hit in NZ, and I know my Kiwi friends are loving it. Whu the big question everyone is asking is when are we going to see Kathryn Bigelow's THE HURT LOCKER???? The non release of the this multi award-winning film is ridiculous. Everyone is waiting ...please enquire why we are the last country in the world to see it on our screens, yet the Awards keep coming...btw the DVD has been released weeks ago and many people have seen it already.

A.F   #9   07:56 pm Feb 22 2010

Wonderful movie which is based on a real issue, and with a great message to convey.

vimal   #8   06:43 pm Feb 22 2010

Went to the very first day of screening in Melbourne with great anticipation but came out disappointed.Totally agree with the reviewer.

Kal   #7   03:18 pm Feb 21 2010

Michale,

You are 10000% correct with your review. I am going bill SRK for wasting my time and money, this guy shouldn't even get a chance to act in kindergarten play.

Keep up the good work.

Mike   #6   03:50 am Feb 21 2010

1st half was good; 2nd half terrible! Georgia hurricane scenes ridiculous! Trashes George Bush while exalting Barak Obama, even though GW did much more for India than Obama ever will.

rani   #5   09:04 am Feb 20 2010

no, its a great movie. get over the stereotyping.indians are always stereotyped in american films, which is completely overlooked by white audiences. so this shouldnt be such a big deal. great film all in all, for those who have experienced these things in real life, and for those who truly understand the culture and lastly, for those who are open minded.

Jit   #4   08:06 am Feb 20 2010

A very good and impartial review. I feel Riazvan's character behaves like a mentally retarded person ( walking, running, laughing) rather than mild Autism person---Failure of director to study the behavior of such real people. Last half is over extended. The matter of film is very small but it is unskillfully lengthened by the director. The film should give references of Forest Gump and Rain Man in the Titles...

Sachin dixit   #3   12:51 am Feb 19 2010

poor film , a stupid drama ...dont waste ur money over this.


Show 1-2 of 12 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Which of these franchises do you prefer?

Star Wars

Star Trek

Twilight

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content