Gig review: Fat Freddy's Drop in Auckland
BY CHRIS SCHULZ
Relevant offers
Gig reviews
Fat Freddy's Drop sometimes meander a bit, but their dub-inspired trip is always a journey worth taking. Reviewer Chris Schulz and photographer Jennifer Raoult were there.
Fat Freddy's Drop
Where: The Powerstation, Auckland
When: Saturday, November 7
As that old cliché goes, good things take time. If anyone understands that saying better than most, it's Fat Freddy's Drop.
The Wellington-based band began the second of two sold out shows at Auckland's Powerstation with a version of Shiverman - one of the stand-outs from this year's second album Dr Boondigga and the Big BW - that was nearly twice the length of its album version.
It took seven minutes for front man Joe Dukie to start singing, 13 minutes for the first blast from the band's trademarked triple-horn team and 18 minutes to come to an end.
Some would accuse them of mucking around. Others would be bored. But for the hyped crowd gathered at the Powerstation - a mixed group ranging from canoodling teens to amorous parents, and, possibly, grandparents - it was a perfectly executed slice of throbbing dub, synthy squelches and exquisite electronica that could easily have sustained several extra minutes.
If you've already seen Fat Freddy's live, and are among the many thousands who bought 2005's massive hit Based on a True Story, you probably already know that the seven-piece collective don't play things by the book.
Tonight's show ran for more than two-and-a-half hours, included a new song no-one had heard before, featured extended remixes and improvisational jams of almost every track, and didn't feature three of Fat Freddy's catchiest crowd pleasers: Wandering Eye, The Nod and Pull the Catch.
If you attended Friday night's show - which reportedly featured Hollie Smith guesting on True Story's Hope - you probably saw a completely different set.
You could say they're just being difficult, but mixing things up is the Fat Freddy's way. After all, their sound includes everything from electro dub to shimmering soul and fiery funk. And, like all three of their albums, a Fat Freddy's live show contains plenty of highlights.
Early on, Ray Ray's dense and moody rhythms featured DJ Fitchie's hypnotic, metronomic beats while Dukie danced around like a drunk rugby player, repeatedly asking the question, "What the world with no soul?"
He proved his point by providing a stunning acoustic version of This Room during the show's encore, showing off his honey-drenched tones that could, and probably have, melted hearts. It was just a shame it came so late, as the crowd was thinning a little by then.
Then there was attention-seeking trombonist Joe Lindsay, who emerged in a classy suit but soon undressed to start shaking his stuff in a white singlet that uncovered bits that should probably stay covered. He's a crowd pleaser, that one.
Less impressive was the faux-Jamaican vocals provided by MC Rhythm Slave during the rowdy Roady, and several mid-set moments where the band seemed to lose momentum by dawdling just a little too much.
But it was worth waiting for the night's undoubted triumph, Dr Boondigga's closing track Breakthrough, with Dukie sounding like a young Marvin Gaye as he played off against the horn team, building to several thrilling and climactic choruses.
Yes, they meander a bit. They also noodle around. Occasionally they drop the ball. And the show didn't end until it was well past many of the crowd's usual bedtime.
But when it comes to Fat Freddy's Drop, it's always a trip worth taking.
Photos: Jennifer Raoult
*What did you think of the show? Post your comments below.
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
the beauty is the improv. one night is diff. from the next. unlucky if your vibe doesn't match theirs on the night.
I saw them a few years back at a gig called Kiakoura Roots festival and they played a 10pm-12pm set BEFORE shapeshifter and pretty much put everyone to sleep. they are NOT an evening band. they are a sunny avo band for a lazy weekend. I vowed never to go see them at night. there was sooo much standing around and meandering that it just lost the the crowd and momentum. Hearing their latest album, which is very good, and their viewer review only confirms that they are too slow for a primetime evening spot
Here's my one word review. Boring.
I was sooo excited to be going to this concert because I love Fat Freddy's Drop but hadn't yet seen them live. There were brilliant moments but there was way, way too much meandering self indulgent stuff which totally lost the crowd and had many people twiddling their thumbs. At $60 it wasn't exactly cheap and I have to say that they were only engaging the crowd about 40% of the time. This is a shame because in the good moments they were mind blowing and the crowd went totally wild. Just wish they hadn't decided to do their own thing for so much of the evening. Definitely prefer listening to their CD!
Surely the fact that they do improvise is what makes their shows so awesome! I just don't get bands who go up there and play the songs off their albums note for note. That must be unbelieveably boring doing it night after night. Fat Freddy's PLEEEASE come to Belfast, or Dublin at the very least....
@Harry.... - I have never seen FFD while high, or even drunk (if I'm paying to see a band because I like their music, I generally want to be sober/straight, as I don't appreciate music as much when I'm not). I've seen them 4 times now, quality varying from Amazing to Flat. I think when they're on form, the meandering is a plus, seeing where they're going to go with the structure of the song, kinda like a variant on jazz improv (which makes sense given the backgrounds of the members). To me it's this tendency to mess about that makes them a good live act; I want bands to do that, and I get rather bored when bands effectively try to recreate the sounds of their tracks at their live show.
I think the main thing I've noticed is that they're at their best when touring with new material. I saw them play like 2 years after BOATS was released, and they were palpably bored. I wouldn't say they were terrible, but in between Kora and Shapeshifter they just sounded morose. But I saw them just before the new album was released, and they were clearly re-energised.
I'm with overit, Fat Freddy live are just too un-focused, too meandering, and just plain boring. I think their live shows are only truly apreicated by those audience members on drugs. (most of them, judging by the last FFD show I went to!)
One of the few bands where I would rather hear the CD.
Perhaps we're all too scared to say it, to blaspheme one of NZs favourite act. So we use words like "meander", "noodle", "dawdle" and "lose momentum". I'll say it, its simply boring.
Lawyer faces impropriety allegations
North-South split on where to rebuild Christchurch
Women prisoners cost much more to lock up
Anger at Holmes' Waitangi remarks
Time may be right for Sanzar to expand Super Rugby
Family still dealing with loss of son
Flags and hope on Libya's uneasy anniversary
Murdoch fights back with "Sun on Sunday"
Hotchin's Waiheke property for sale
FBI foil suicide attack on US Capitol
Newest First
Oldest First
The most over rated band in the country... apart from evermore,midnight youth and every other crap band we seem to rave and rave about