Paul Henry's 'retard' fallout continues

Last updated 15:32 30/11/2009
Special Olympics New Zealand has weighed into the controversy caused by Paul Henry and his comments about Susan Boyle.
Fairfax Media
WAR OF WORDS: Special Olympics New Zealand has weighed into the controversy caused by Paul Henry and his comments about Susan Boyle.

Related Links

Josh Kronfeld slams Paul Henry 'Moustache-gate' complaints upheld TV review: Paul Henry plumbs new heights TVNZ handled 'moustache-gate' right TV review: 'Art' gets a Henry rubbishing Outrage after Paul Henry comments Henry: no regrets over 'retard' remark

Relevant offers

TV

A Sheep's Show How many chances for Once Upon a Time? Entertainment Quiz 10/2 House to end after current season Rescued dog bites TV host during broadcast DeGeneres hits back at haters Curb or Seinfeld: which is better? More claims about PM's man and doco funding Excuse me, I was just wondering ... Henry has dig at new employers

Special Olympics New Zealand has weighed into the controversy caused by Paul Henry and his comments about Susan Boyle, saying the term "retarded" is as offensive as a racial slur like "nigger".

The organisation had asked the Broadcasting Standards Authority to ensure using "the R word" was unacceptable after the TV One Breakfast host called Scottish singer Susan Boyle "retarded".

On last Monday's show, Henry laughed while reading from a magazine article about how the Britain's Got Talent singer was starved of oxygen at birth and suffered an intellectual disability.

"Here's the really interesting revelation: she is in fact retarded ... And if you look at her carefully, you can make it out," he said.

Special Olympics New Zealand chairman David Rutherford said using "retard" to describe intellectually disabled people was as hurtful as racial slurs like "nigger" and "kike".

Mr Rutherford said Special Olympics New Zealand had requested a review of the application of broadcasting standards to ensure that the use of "retard" was regarded as unacceptable.

"Central to our thinking has been the consideration of people with intellectual disability. Most people with intellectual disability would find it very difficult to defend themselves in the medium of television."

Henry's comments have made it to Hollywood, with celebrity gossip blogger Perez Hilton directing his Twitter followers to an American news story on the Henry's comments.

Hilton, whose perezhilton.com website received millions of views per day, tweeted: "Susan Boyle in the middle of 'retarded' controversy", with a link to a story on Irish-American website Irish Central - sharing the story with more than 1.5 million Twitter followers.

Irish Central quoted Henry as saying his comments were made in a light-hearted fashion.

He said he had done nothing wrong and that it was okay to use the word retarded in relation to people with intellectual disabilities.

IHC New Zealand spokeswoman Philippa Sellens said last week Henry's comments were "highly offensive".

"It was in extremely bad taste to use his position as a broadcaster to 'entertain' by mocking a sector of the community that has difficulty speaking up for themselves."

Ad Feedback

IHC had had "a massive response" and was encouraging the public to complain to TVNZ and the Human Rights Commission.

The Human Rights Commission was unable to confirm how many complaints had been received.

TVNZ spokeswoman Megan Richards said she was unable to comment on the complaints as they were "going through the usual process".

Henry defended his comments over the weekend, saying criticism was "water off a duck's back".

"The only reason I'm particularly interested in this – I've never spoken this much about a complaint before – is because I've been aware before with certain things that I've said that certain interest groups have got together and sort of encouraged people to complain, but I think when it's an organisation like IHC it is actually quite different.

"There's a question of free speech here. At the end of the day if I am not breaking rules – and I don't go out to do that – I'm just saying what's on my mind, what I think. I'm trying to be entertaining, or trying to be informative, but I'm not checking myself all the time as most people do."

Asked whether he had been rapped over the knuckles by TVNZ, Henry said: "It's very early days. I'm assuming an official complaints procedure has started.

Watch footage of the incident below:

- NZPA

265 comments
KJ   #265   08:33 am Dec 01 2009

The guy is a bully with bully mentality. This is the sort of stuff we're trying to keep out of the playground.

It's regressive. People supporting need to find some new way of humour, unless you're not smart enough to.

James   #264   08:29 am Dec 01 2009

This is what TVNZ wants, though, eh? Bit of controversy. Gets people watching. That Henry, he's such a cad! What will he say next?!?

In truth he's just a jerk who happens to be on television instead of internet message boards.

James   #263   08:19 am Dec 01 2009

I love Paul Henry.

Carol   #262   08:18 am Dec 01 2009

What exactly does "retarded" look like and where did Paul get his degree making him qualified to make such assessment? Put yourself in the person who has the disability, would you want to be called names that are always said to reflect negatively; would you like to be discriminated against all your life for something you had no control over? We label jars, not people and remember having a disability is the only minority everyone can get into. For those of you who think it is ok to call people names, hope your disability arrives in time for you to be offended when the tables are turned.

Brendan   #261   09:48 pm Nov 30 2009

I cannot believe the posts I am reading in support of Paul Henry on this topic! I am a Kiwi living on the other side of the world, and felt a sense of shame and disgust at what Mr Henry said. This is not an issue of free speech, but one of journalistic integrity....something which Mr Henry clearly lacks. His antics are tabloid journalism at best, and he wouldn't get away with such offensive remarks in mainstream networks around the world. The fact that he cannot control his thought processes is not something that should be applauded.

If the posts supporting Mr Henry are indicative of the NZ reaction to this subject, then I'm afraid they do nothing but support some of the negative stereotypes of Kiwis in Europe.

Keeper   #260   09:47 pm Nov 30 2009

Paul Henry is funny and witty and he is the absolutely the only reason I watch breakfast TV. Sure sometimes he does go a little too far (in this case) but have you tried to watch Sunrise?? Sooo boring, it barely wakes me up. I'd much rather watch Paul, even if he does step over the line on occassion. Don't get me started on Good Morning....even more of a yawn, do they think that all housewives are boring? I wish Paul hosted that too.

Warren Meggitt   #259   09:46 pm Nov 30 2009

I work in the Disability field and know many people with lives not so good as Mr Pauls H but they are great people with plenty to offer the world and they do ,and make us all better for knowing them

Brigitte   #258   09:45 pm Nov 30 2009

People need to get over themselves. I love the fact that Paul isn't PC and says what a lot of the time, people are thinking. In this day and age with all the political correctness, I think he is a breath of fresh air. He is very funny and I believe that Paul makes Breakfast and without him, ratings would fall. You go Paul!! You have my support!

Kevin Campbell   #257   09:45 pm Nov 30 2009

I heard Paul criticise John Key for being gutless on reforming the economy. He is the only journo i have heard with balls enough to do that. He is a legend. Go Paul, go for it, you good thing.

Don Sinclair   #256   09:45 pm Nov 30 2009

I'ts time for Paul & Hone to get the flick. We don't need people like this giving our country a bad name overseas!


Show 206-255 of 265 comments
Special offers
Opinion poll

How do you feel about The Simpsons being renewed for a further two seasons?

Woohoo! Long may it reign

Doh! It should have ended ages ago

Meh.

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

On the Box blog pointer small

On the Box: What's on TV with Chris Philpott

How many chances for Once Upon a Time?