Lock up your naughty kids - expert

BY NEIL REID
Last updated 05:00 30/05/2010
kid
Locking up kids in their rooms is OK, says psychologist Nigel Latta, below.
latta
.

Relevant offers

TV psychologist Nigel Latta is promoting a no-nonsense "time-out" for naughty kids – locking them in their bedrooms until they behave.

But his advice has been attacked by child safety campaigners including anti-smacking bill architect Sue Bradford who criticised it as "outrageous".

Latta, host of The Politically Incorrect Parenting Show, made the suggestion when hosting a live chat on a Sydney newspaper website earlier this month while on a promotional tour of Australia for his TV series' debut.

He was providing parental advice on the Daily Telegraph site.

One reader asked Latta for help on how to handle kids who "keep begging for more and more and wind you down all the time till u [sic] say yes and give in".

Latta responded: "Tell them that you're having a sit down and a wee rest and that the smart thing for them to do would be to go find something quiet to do.

"If they dont [sic] listen then pick them up, put them in their rooms, and close the door ... bolting it with the lock you've just installed.

"Then go sit down, have a cup of tea, reflect on the general serenity of the moment, soak up the vibe, and then when you're good and ready go let them out. Repeat as many times as needed."

Sunday News approached Latta earlier this week about his comments.

"It is an outline on how you could use time out," said the clinical psychologist, who also hosted hit TV series Beyond The Darklands, delving into the backgrounds of some of New Zealand's worst criminals.

"If you don't [use time out], then what happens is that you sit down and get wound up," Latta said.

"It doesn't mean that you leave them in there [their rooms] forever – but you put the bolt on the door so they can't keep running in and out and everyone calms down."

But former Green MP Bradford, whose anti-smacking bill afforded children the same legal protection from assault as adults, warned such actions could have "a lifelong impact" on the locked-up kids.

"Locking children up when you are angry, frustrated or just sad could really damage the children psychologically and cause all sorts of problems later," Bradford said.

"There have been horror stories in the past from children being locked in small spaces and left as punishment. It is a form of cruelty and mental violence." Whangarei-based barrister Michael Gardam, convener of the New Zealand Law Society's youth justice committee, said he was "taken aback" by Latta's advice.

Ad Feedback

"I think you have to be careful how you handle [it]. Obviously there are issues about the amount of force used," Gardam said. "It is difficult to see how it could be done without some form of force, potentially anyway. I would think you would have to be fairly careful. Obviously it has the potential to turn to custard, that sort of approach.

"I don't know if it is good advice, personally speaking." Barnardos' northern regional manager Glenys Knowles said: "We would encourage parents to pick up the phone, grab hold of some resources and talk to some other parents. But bolts on doors ... It is not something that Barnardos would advocate. If parents are struggling they should ask for help."

Latta, Police Commissioner Howard Broad, and Ministry of Social Development chief Peter Hughes reviewed anti-smacking legislation. Latta said it made no difference to how police and social workers did their jobs.

- © Fairfax NZ News

171 comments
Post a comment
prisala   #171   02:25 am Oct 11 2010

i was never locked in my room as a young child,but once i got to about 11 my behaviour got much worse, when my parents grounded me i just sneaked out the house,eventully they got so fed up they put a lock on my door that could only be locked or unlocked with a key. the following saturday after another week of bad behaviour, i was sent to my room and locked in at first i did"nt care, but after a couple of hours i was extremly bored and fed up, i told my parents i learnt my lesson, please would they let me out,NO was their answer, i spent the whole day shut in my room it was horrible i really hated it. my room was small and i wanted out, after this punisment i think my behaviour improved, yes there were occasions where i had to be locked in my room again once for a whole weekend,(very serious offence)but overall my behaviour got much better if ever i got grounded again i made sure i stayed in the house,i did"nt want to be punished like that again. my point is i think locking kids in their rooms is a excellent form of punisment, yes it"s not pleasent, but that"s the point of punishing them it certanly dos"nt do them any harm, although i think it"s not suitable for young kids they could find it scary, but as for teenagers that won"t stay grounded, ( LOCK THEM UP )

Paul   #170   02:34 pm Jun 07 2010

If I may be so bold as to say who the hell is Sue Bradford kidding. I thought Nigel Latta was a psychologist and Bradford was an ex politician who I might add was not a real politician anyway as mung bean eating tree huggers are exactly that so who the hell does she think she is. If locking up my kids for time out is going to work then the PC brigade can kiss my you know what.

Bradford states that locking children in small areas is detrimental to the child wellbeing, well I have to agree to that BUT madam Bradford I am not locking my kids in a small non ventalated cupboard or below floor room etc I am putting them in their room which has all their books toys etc and I can calm down as well as the child so there. Keep your PC mouth shut and let real parents be parents unlike yours who obviously treated you badly.

I say give parents a break and let them parent their kids the way we are supposed to and you won't have little thugs and bad kids running around doing bad to the rest of society. I can guareentee that a child that is properly disciplined will be better adjusted than most and by the way the law states that assault is not on for ALL people this includes kids as well so why the hell did we need this law in the first place.

Sue   #169   03:49 pm Jun 02 2010

Rahul #166 "The bible says I can hit my children. I'll let god be my judge as to whether I am doing the right thing by my kids."

There we have it! This is the sort of person who looks up to Nigel Latta and hears lock your kids up and hit them when your angry. Rahul shouldn't God have a capital letter?

Ning   #168   02:58 pm Jun 02 2010

Liberator, that is what I call good ole common sense.... well done!!

Liberator   #167   11:38 am Jun 02 2010

Ther term "postive parenting" is more one of opinion, than on of fact. I judge parenting by the outcome, not necessarily the method.

I believe parents who feel ashamed at upholding rules and imposing discipline actually feel in constant fear of being resented by their children. They might have some resentment, at first. But, as the vast, vast majortiy of parents have experienced since the dawn of time, it DOESN'T last. All is forgiven. Why? Becasue, chidlren will basically accept discipline from anyone who they know loves them. THAT is trust. THAT is postive. And, the vast, vast majority of children have grown up NOT resenting their parents.

So, do what YOU feel is right for YOUR child to produce the outcome YOU are satisfied with. THAT is postive. You DO NOT need help. You DO NOT need advice. But, those who are afraid of disiplining their children will be amonsgt those who will ALWAYS need the "help". Is there a pattern here?

Rahul   #166   05:00 pm Jun 01 2010

The bible says I can hit my children. I'll let god be my judge as to whether I am doing the right thing by my kids.

Richard   #165   02:57 pm Jun 01 2010

Soooooo glad that almost everyone on this blog thinks Bradford is full of BS. Just go to show there is still some common sense in this country. Bradford would probably suggest that you make them a cup of tea and discuss what they have done and tell them that it's OK to do whatever they want because its a form of expression. This women has been the most damaging thing to parenting in the last decade.

lisa   #164   01:57 pm Jun 01 2010

This is the guy who completely believed the Sensing Murder psychics were genuine, right?

JanusGodofDoors   #163   01:49 pm Jun 01 2010

smack, wait, talk.

Belinda   #162   01:36 pm Jun 01 2010

If you need to place your children in a room locked with a bolt, so your anger can subside - I've got some advice for you.

You need to get some help! Whether it be a help line, plunket, Barnadoes, parenting books, meditation. There are so many ways to help you deal with these issues. Seriously if you need to lock a child in a room, something is wrong. It has nothing to do with the child.

Shame on Nigel Latta for not promoting positive parenting and encouraging people to ask for help if they are struggling.


Show 112-161 of 171 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

What's your diet downfall?

Sweets

Savouries

Alcohol

Vote Result

Related story: Jonah Hill reveals diet struggle

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Moata

Moata's Blog Idle

The once and future city

Greer wedding blog pointer small

Ready or Knot: Greer's getting married

The quake, sadness, and silver linings

Omnivore blog pointer small

The Omnivore: Jeremy Taylor on food

Real kitchen nightmares

Crazy Chic blog pointer small

Crazy Chic: Bronwyn Williams' fashion ride

Winter Preview: Manly Men

Car Club small pointer

The Car Club blog: Powered by Autocar NZ

Throttle that gas pedal for economy

Voyages blog pointer small

Blog: US/NZ - a cultural conversation

Behind the wall of political money

Drivetalk small pointer Feb2011

Drivetalk: Dave Moore's blog on cars and driving

Bikers and drivers - pull yourselves together

Horoscopes

What do the stars have in store for you today?

Sudoku

Rev up your mind with our numbers game

Crossword

Test your knowledge with our daily crossword

Send us your pet pics

Email yourpics@stuff.co.nz