Superficial judgements

Last updated 09:49 18/11/2009

I don’t enjoy working night shift, but there's something to be said for being able to wander into work in three-quarter jeans and my favourite pink Chucks trailing an untied shoelace.chucks

Such an appearance at the beginning of my Tuesday shift didn’t even merit a second glance.

The shoelace wasn't an affectation. The damn things just won't stay tied unless I pull the lace so tight I strangle my ankle. The laces on my running shoes often come untied too. However, I usually enjoy that 20 seconds of rest it gives me when I stop to retie them.

Journalism isn't a particularly well-dressed profession at the best of times. If you're not a business reporter, arriving at work in a full suit and tie is just asking for  a day of comments on your attire.

But there are a number of jobs where appearance seems to be vital. Focusing on those in my area of interest, one such role has to be that of gym/personal trainer. This also seems to extend to the sports physios at my current gym.

I’m sure a policy to employ only buffed-looking trainers would be legally dodgy - although appearance as such is not specifically addressed in the Human Rights Act or the Bill of Rights Act. (Who says I didn’t learn anything during my law degree? Anything useful, however, is a different question.)

I suppose it does make some sense, certainly for the gym trainers at any rate. They are an advertisement for their services. What do you think?

I remember a flatmate’s girlfriend, who was on the plump side, telling me she was studying to be a gym trainer and thinking she’d have to lose a lot of weight first. Because, being honest, presented with a chubby trainer, I would have wonder about the quality of their advice.

That’s certainly an unfair assessment from someone with plenty of her own curves. I should be less judgmental as people are always assuming I’m overstating the level of physical activity I get up to and my fitness levels.

I’m not. Given I consider myself extremely unfit if I can do only a half-hour run, it’s fair to say my perspective is warped.

There’s probably not the same degree of pressure on coaches in general as there is on personal trainers, though I guess it depends on what you’re coaching.

I have no idea what the coach who wrote my triathlon programme looks like, since all communication has been via email and telephone.

Maybe I should have stalked him on Facebook before deciding whether to pay him plenty of money.

Ah, shallow, superficial judgement. Where would I be without it?

» Join Are We There Yet on Facebook.

10 comments
Post a comment
Geoff   #1   09:58 am Nov 18 2009

My ex was a personal trainer and you are right in that they are their own walking advertisements. They are also in a lot of cases self employed.

That said, one of the large gym chains does have quite a diverse range of shapes, sizes and ages of trainers. If you think about it, being approachable and not intimidating or scaring off the potential clients is also a useful marketing plan.

Kelvin2   #2   10:16 am Nov 18 2009

Isn't there a personal trainer in Australia who has decided to put on weight and become chubby so that he could see what it was like to try and lose weight, and get a better understanding of the issues? And to make his clients feel comfortable and not feel self conscious about their weight.

We should also remember that some of the best coaches in the world are total cr*p at the sport they are coaching. And vice-versa vis-a-vis players becoming coaches.

As long as the trainer wasn't woolfing down an upsized big mac, sitting in an lazy-boy chair whilst yelling at everyone, "pain is their friend", I'd say all sizes are a goer, if they can lead the way.

Kate   #3   10:17 am Nov 18 2009

A friend of mine is a somewhat plus sized tri coach, and is really doing well marketing herself to newer athletes. As Geoff says, a lot of us would much rather work with someone we feel comfortable with. I'm more likely to trust a trainer who doesn't seem to judge me, and who doesn't suggest I live on 1000 calories of egg white per day!

Leon   #4   10:21 am Nov 18 2009

The gym I go to has several slightly chunky instructors. Doesn't phase me in the slightest because I am sure that they're probably five times as fit as I am and could exercise me into a heart attack fairly easily.

Ashleigh   #5   12:21 pm Nov 18 2009

At the bikram yoga studio I go to, a couple of the instructors are fairly big. I think this makes the class seem much more accessible to everyone - and the postures, even though they're often really hard and crazy, seem more achievable when you see that a person who is bigger than average can do them, and even excel at them. Also, the fact that there are people of all shapes, sizes, ages, and abilities in the class makes it harder to make any excuses like "Everyone will look at me..." "I'm too fat and useless to be here..." and all the other things our heads tell us. I guess it's just difficult to break out of that "appearance is vital" way of looking at ourselves and other people - but it wastes so much energy! And it's boring.

Ben   #6   01:32 pm Nov 18 2009

As a PE teacher I can speak from experience that one does not have to excel in sport to be able to coach and teach effectively. I am sure that you would all maake superficial judgement of me that I am not capable of teaching physical education.

Muscleguy   #7   02:29 am Nov 19 2009

Shoelaces coming untied???? I learned in a school cross country in Intermediate School to do the laces in double knots as I lost time having to do mine up. It is fairly basic if you have that problem and takes two seconds during the tying process.

As for casualness at work, you should drop into a biology lab sometime, especially one in a medical school. Here without exception the lab heads at the research unit up at the hospital here wear jeans and a t-shirt and often neither look particularly reputable. That includes the women too. However down the hill at the campus proper the sartorial level rises, slightly though generally at the bohemian end of the scale, especially the women. This is because we have to make it clear that we are NOT clinicians despite the fact we also wear white coats. In places where the two are in close proximity the difference becomes most stark. Though during my PhD (Med School Dunedin) one of the lecturers who was medically qualified joined us slobs since he no longer practiced.

One of the joys of science is not having to wear a tie, ever. Not even at conferences. Mind you I am something of a dandy in science terms since I habitually wear chinos and a shirt to work. I do not even own a pair of jeans.

Geoff   #8   08:54 am Nov 19 2009

To echo Muscleguy #7. Double knots are your friend. Always do my shoes with them so save them coming adrift at inopportune moments.

Especially important for climbing or driving/motorsport shoes. Those inopportune moments could be quite dangerous.

scottw   #9   09:32 am Nov 19 2009

@Muscleguy #7

I've a pair of running shoes that even with double knots has a habit of coming untied. Happens even more if they get wet.

Jo   #10   12:47 am Nov 20 2009

Not sure if this is runners world subscriber only - but on the topic of shoelace tying, this guy has come up with supposedly the perfect way to tie your laces evenly so they don't wear out (I've never really had a problem with this - but hey): http://www.runnersworld.com/article/0,7120,s6-240-319--12997-2-1X2-3,00.html

I'm right with you on med school dressing muscleguy! It's awesome not having 'work clothes' and 'casual clothes'. I just have clothes. Fullstop. Whatever I have the urge to wear that day is what I wear (the only exception sometimes being footwear in the lab)

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content