Who are the worst drivers?

Last updated 09:56 05/03/2010

Which group in society present the biggest danger on the road? Who are the worst drivers?Steering wheel

This exercise in stereotyping was being addressed on ZM this morning as I was getting ready for work. (Getting ready translates to rushing around madly wondering where the hell my grey skirt was while simultaneously trying – and failing - to tame my hair for the day.)

Various people offered their opinions. They named the elderly with incessant indicating, teenage boys, arrogant 30– 40-year-old men. This started me thinking. It’s a good question. Who are the worst drivers on the road?

I think the answer to this question depends on your own position. I've found the worst drivers as a pedestrian, as a cyclist and as another driver are all different. And just a warning – generalising in a big way will follow.

As a pedestrian, the only extremely close shave I have had was with a Wellington bus. Standing at the lights on Lambton Quay listening to my iPod, I waited for the little green man to appear before stepping off the kerb. Only to have a bus sail by, missing me by a matter of millimetres. The driver had not only run the red light but floored it in order to do so. To say I was shaken would have been an understatement.

Now, I’m not saying all of the bus/pedestrians accidents are the bus driver’s fault. Indeed, when I first moved to Wellington, I was shocked by the way people seemed to wander all over the road at will. But is it really necessary for the majority of bus drivers to pretend they’re auditioning for the Rally of New Zealand?

When it comes to who are the worst drivers from my point of view as a cyclist, the answer is trickier. The two minor collisions I’ve had involved older drivers. One got too close and clipped my elbow, the other turned into my path to park. But in both cases there was no injury and no damage.

Thirty-something women in SUVs strike fear into my heart for the heedless way in which they drive. However, judging by the amount of aggressiveness – this includes hand gestures, horns, revving engines and items thrown -  I’ve been on the receiving end of it’s men between 20 and 40 who are most likely to endanger my health as a cyclist.

To be fair, the only damage-causing accident I’ve suffered did not involve a car driver but a pedestrian and I shared the blame for not being alert enough to slam on my brakes at a second’s notice. Please note, like cars, cyclists do require some braking distance.

But what about as a driver? Who did I find the worst then? Actually, me. I don’t own a car because I don’t enjoy the driving experience and due to poor spatial awareness (which I don’t suffer on my bike) I think it’s safer for society if I refrain from getting behind the wheel. It might be nice if others who suffer from similar driving skill deficiencies refrained as well.

So, what do you think? Go nuts with generalising and tell me who you think are the worst drivers in your experience.

» Join Are We There Yet on Facebook.

Picture: The Age

125 comments
Post a comment
Geoff   #1   10:04 am Mar 05 2010

Ooh boy. Why'd you open this can of worms yet again?

My answer is that there is no set demographic who are definitively The Worst. It varies with time and place.

People who lack awareness and consideration for other road users rate pretty highly in the "worst driver" stakes though.

Sean   #2   10:07 am Mar 05 2010

Of the 5-10 accidents I have seen and been involved in, all have involved a person over 40 and in most cases over 50. Funny thing is in all cases they blamed the younger person with the police usually correcting them on the road rules or driving etiquette (sp?). As a cyclist (asians and old people are terrible in Christchurch, they drive in the cycle lanes and cut you off).

LB   #3   10:07 am Mar 05 2010

This could get nasty Ann!

As a pedestrian - agree with you on the bus drivers.

As a cyclist - I've only been riding a bike on the road for a month and its damn scary! So - anyone in a car! (I think this has more to do with me than them tho). I was riding last night in a quiet suburban st, and on the road shoulder and someone slammed their horn on at me! WTF?? Gave me a hell of a fright.

As another driver - I think the worst are middle-aged woman. They seem to have this great combo of ditzy and rude so you never know what they're gonna do. And then can't tell if they are being obnoxious or oblivious.

Grant   #4   10:09 am Mar 05 2010

I would have to say the scariest drivers ( and generalising here - because I have seen it happen 3 times in the last week) has been asian woman drivers in large cars with one hand on the wheel and the other on a cell phone - weaving back and forward across two lanes.

cheeseslug   #5   10:11 am Mar 05 2010

People that don't look where they are going, oblivious in their own little world. If you are driving you need to pay attention or as if often the case; the consequences can be disasterous.

EJT   #6   10:14 am Mar 05 2010

Oi Ann, I am one of those 30 something women with a SUV! And I am about the most considerate driver on the road. I let cars in on busy Auckland roads, I always slow down and give cyclists plenty of berth and I am one of the few Auckland drivers who sees an amber light as a signal to slow down and stop. I was even the bigger person the other day when a complete f*wit deliberately blocked my path when I attempted to enter a car park, thus requiring me to back out onto a busy street to let her out, rather than her backing up into the nearly empty car park she was trying to exit. To be fair I did call her a b**** under my breath as she passed - but did so with a smile on my face :-)

I think everyone group has the potential to be the worst driver on the road. People who drive fancy European cars get a bad rap, but I generally find the crappier the car, the more the hazard they pose. How's that for generalising?

Ken   #7   10:17 am Mar 05 2010

All drivers who speed, fail to observe the road code and who are discourteous are the worst drivers regardless of sex or age. It's far too easy and cheap to get a drivers licence in NZ and too cheap to run a vehicle hence the higher number of idiots on the road who are 'bad drivers'. Actually after 2 years living in China I spent a few months driving again in Christchurch and what struck me at the time was how very courteous the drivers were during the few months I was driving. These days as a fulltime uni student I take the bus. Anyone who is close to a bus route and commutes in a car instead of taking a bus to work or uni is either stupid, lazy, or has more money than sense.....as far as Christchurch goes anyway.

Greg   #8   10:24 am Mar 05 2010

Those who have learnt to drive on the Asian continent are generally not as confident and aware of hazards, and unfortunately the family and friends they teach to drive suffer in this regard too.

Thos who have learnt to drive in NZ, SA and OZ tend to be over confident and are not overlly cautious.

The NZ trained drivers do not have a good care for cyclists, and a gross majority of these culprits drive those V8 fords and holdens and all think they are race car drivers.

lolz   #9   10:29 am Mar 05 2010

Men (from no specifc age group) full of their own self-importance, who drive big, flashy Holdens or Fords.

I also fear the SUV driving 30-something woman.

Don't even get me started on school bus drivers.

Alice2   #10   10:32 am Mar 05 2010

Prado drivers. Consistently attempt to kill me, whether I'm walking, cycling or driving. Even one of the managers in my department has attempted to run me down in the carpark at work (he still doesn't realise - it was my first week & he didn't recognise me in my cycling gear). There's something about the size of a Prado, most people who drive them have no concept of how big they are (especially if they're 30-something women).

Having said that, the only actual vehicular contact I've had was with a 20-something guy in a mid-80s Honda (knocked me off my bike) & a mid-40s guy in a 70s Ford ute (wrote of my wee Starlet).

General consensus in my flat is Chch drivers are awful. Run orange/red lights, no consideration for others & indicate after turning the wheel, if at all.


Show 11-60 of 125 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content