The worst advice ever

Last updated 10:30 13/08/2010

lecturingWhat is the worst advice you have ever been given? Specifically, what diet or exercise advice have you been given that ended up doing more harm than good?

One thing that I've learnt about human nature is we find it really hard to not give someone else advice on weight loss or exercise. Which is all fine and good as long as the following applies

1. They've asked for it. Unsolicited advice can be not only annoying, but also de-motivating and confusing. If you've decided to calorie-count, and the person giving you advice starts talking about how low carb is the only way to go, or vice versa, then it can be hard to feel confident about your method.

2. It's at their level. I spend a large proportion of my time at the moment teaching adults. If I come in with information that is all completely new and spend a day on it, it's exhausting for the participants. But if I find out where they are, begin from that point and build on it, then they can relate it to their experience and they get far more out of it. Telling me that I need to run for 40 minutes a day, for example, isn't great advice for me. Telling me how to carve out 40 minutes from a busy schedule so I can walk or run is. That's the information I really need.

3. It's intended to help but it's not mandatory. I think some people say they are giving advice but really they just want to tell their own story. Which is completely fine. We all want to be heard. We just don't all need to be obeyed.

I was trying to think of the worst advice I've ever been given and it's hard to pinpoint it. For me (and I know it's different for everyone) the worst has to be the people who said that artificial sugar and low fat was the best solution for me. It isn't. All it does is makes me hungry and crave. For someone else it might be ideal, but not me.

What's the worst advice you've ever been given? Do you feel you are being lectured to sometimes? What makes people give it to us unsolicited? How does it make you feel?

Rachel Goodchild is on Twitter and Facebook.

**Christchurch Meet the Bloggers Evening: Tonight, Friday, August 13. Come along and meet Stuff's locally based bloggers, plus a couple of out-of-towners, in an informal setting. Colin Espiner, Dave Moore, Gerard Campbell, Margaret Agnew, Moata Tamaira, Nick Barnett and Rachel Goodchild all plan to be there. Venue: Le Plonk, 213 Manchester Street, from 7pm.

44 comments
Post a comment
Clint Eastwood   #1   10:51 am Aug 13 2010

Funny I only remember the good advice I never took.

Sandy   #2   10:53 am Aug 13 2010

I remember going on a diet and loosing about 3-4 kilos and then going into my Bank to deposit a cheque, only to be asked by the teller "have you gained weight lately?". Even though I said, "No, actually I have lost a bit" she went on to tell me that exercise was the key and I needed to increase my exercise! This was despite the fact that I was training for a half marathon at the time!

Luckily that Teller doesn't work there anymore (she got made redundant, I wonder why?).

I_Not_Y   #3   10:56 am Aug 13 2010

"Bullies are cowards who will run away if you stand up to them" No they won't, they're just as likely to punch you, hard.

Rachael   #4   10:57 am Aug 13 2010

Urgh. The biggest lectures come from people 'trying to help' i find. Yes im short, yes im on the smaller side. But thats no excuse for people tell me to eat a pie. I eat what i want, and exercise when i find the motivation. Its not about staying skinny for me, its about finding a happy medium.

One of the more annoying things, is turning up offers of certain foods, because i know they make my reflux act up something chronic. This in turn usually makes people ask if im on a diet/anorexic. Its not because i dont want to eat your horrible meal dripping in fat, its because i want to be able to move without having acid burn its way up my chest thanks!

The other thing, is i have had to relearn things i should and shouldnt eat, and when. My blood sugar tends to drop rapidly if i dont eat properly, and thus i end up sick. No explanation from any doctor, just 'eat more' yea, thats so the answer...

Jane   #5   11:19 am Aug 13 2010

The worst advice I have been given is you must put other people first before yourself! Might sound a good idea but in reality not so good! Also told that if you are on a benefit you must not have contact or socalise with people who are working! Slightly difficult! A friends mother told me this. Funny but this lady is dead and I am working but still feel guilty!

Wellybex   #6   11:26 am Aug 13 2010

I think the worse advice I've been given about diets is being told that I should try any form of deprivation diet. I think for me that's just a set up for failure. I have friends who have gone on extreme diets and some have had success and some have failed miserably. I think it just depends on your personality and willpower as to how well you cope with not being able to have any of a specific group of foods, or for that matter more than one group of foods. I go a little crazy when I have been deprived of such simple things as bread (which I don't eat much of to start with) or milk in my coffee and that just leads me to an all out binge which just leads to me feeling worse about the whole situation.

I quite like the everything in moderation method. However, I'm yet to figure out what moderation is, so until then I'll keep up the lunch time walks!

MissJ   #7   12:05 pm Aug 13 2010

The juice diets.... the lemon detox diets... You just end up turning into an intolerable b*tch for the week, your body shuts down leaving you incapable of dealing with anything, and two weeks later it's all back on again! We all know the truth, it's a moderation between diet and exercise, and there are no quick fixes.

Angela   #8   12:08 pm Aug 13 2010

I remember ringing my now ex boyfriend (who loved to give advice!) after getting back from a tai box class and he said "What you need is a good hot shower". As I hate getting stupid bits of advice like this, the next time I rung I tried to beat him to it, saying "just been to the gym, am heading for a nice hot shower" He said, "No! That's the worst thing you could do, you should head for a cool shower to cool your body down...." I thought this was so amusing that I played on it for the next few weeks, and lo and behold, every time I told him I'd do one he'd "advise" me to do the other. One of the reasons we broke up is because he thought that what he had to say was always so much more important than my opinion.

Marie   #9   12:16 pm Aug 13 2010

This is a good topic! I have got in to a really bad eating/non exercising rut over the last 6-8 months. I am starting to get myself out of it and make some good decisions and I have a few friends who are exercise/health nuts. They are so over bearing with their advice i avoid the whole topic when I am around them. The silly thing is I want to do stuff with them (go tot he gym etc) and learn from them but they are just so over the top they are pushing me away!

Leon   #10   12:32 pm Aug 13 2010

Worst advice ever "get involved in a land war in Asia"


Show 11-44 of 44 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content