Pretence and pop

Last updated 09:59 04/11/2009

If there's anything that bugs me it's pretence (well, pretence and unnecessarily squeaky footwear).  Maybe I'm just on a bit of an honesty kick this week but that whole "I know that you know that I don't really mean what I'm saying but for the sake of keeping the social machine ticking along smoothly let's both agree to ignore it" thing just annoys the fat out of me (I was going to say "crap" but I figure there's probably more fat than there is crap circulating in my system and fat is a lot harder to shift, ya know?).

LadyhawkeWhich is not to say that I am not without pretense myself. Hell no.  But at least I'm attuned enough to tell when I'm doing it, which is, apparently, something I have in common with Ladyhawke. 

For while I wasn't sure if it was okay to refer to Pip Brown as Ladyhawke.  You know, the whole "is that the name of the band or the lead singer?" anxiety that has long plagued not-quite fans of Marilyn Manson and Jethro Tull.  But since the Ladyhawke website bio is pretty much Pip Brown talking about herself (in the least pretentious way possible, mind you) I figure that probably the heavens will not open up and smite me down with the vengeful stratocaster of Rock n Roll correctness for doing so.

Anyway, there was a gig so naturally there was playing of songs and lights and dancing and waving of arms and excessive documenting. There was a time when people would just go to a gig with the intention of watching, listening, and perhaps if they had had a lager or two, swaying a bit.  Nowadays (which is old person speak for "I am a fossil") you can barely make out what's going on past the sea of tiny screens of mobile phones and digital cameras being held aloft.  When exactly did we stop experiencing life and start recording it for posterity (or Youtube)?  But of course I did it too...see.

And as at most gigs, a certain amount of songs were played and then the band went away...ostensibly "pretending" that the gig was over even though they still hadn't played My delirium so there was no chance that they weren't going to come back.  The encore...what exactly is it for?  I mean, call me cynical (or Ishmael, whatever) but I find it difficult to get all hyped up and make a big whoop when I know for a fact that the band is coming back out shortly.  I'd much rather that they simply tell the truth and say "look, we're just going to have a quick drink and confab off to the side for a bit, but we'll come back and play another three songs, please chat amongst yourselves until we get back".  Why does there need to be this pantomime-esque "Oh no, DON'T go away yet...please come back.  Yay! You're coming back. We, like, never expected that!"

But good on Ladyhawke, she came right back and told everyone how cheesy she felt about the whole thing which makes her okay in my book.  Because it's all right to like cheese or even be the source of it, so long as you don't buy into your own hype...Brian Tamaki.  Just saying.

Oh, and in other news my taxi driver struggled to make change from the seven dollars for my fare to the $10 note I paid with.  Seriously, is this a Reserve Bank issue or is it just taxi drivers in Christchurch that are dangerously low on cash?  I actually ended up with 60 cents' worth of copper in my change, which makes me wonder if there is some heretofore unmentioned coinage shortage in this country.

But anyway, I just wondered if anyone else feels the way I do about "the encore"?  I'm sure it had some meaning at some fuzzy, out of focus point "back in the day" but is it all a bit farcical now?  Wouldn't you just rather have your entertainer du jour be straight with you or is the illusion of aloofness all part of the appeal?  Ever get the feeling that you're missing out because you're too busy capturing it all for posterity?

Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.

Picture: Sunday News

35 comments
Post a comment
Elsie   #1   10:12 am Nov 04 2009

Ladyhawke was amazing! So was her encore. Enough said.

Marie   #2   10:26 am Nov 04 2009

Totally agree Moata - everyone is SO obsessed with having a million photos of everything and it kind of takes away from just experiencing/enjoying the moment when someone is fussing around with a camera.

LB   #3   10:41 am Nov 04 2009

For a moment there I thought you were going to dis Ladyhawke... phew... lucky you didn't. I'm sad I missed the gig cos she's awesome!

Kat   #4   10:43 am Nov 04 2009

Occasionally an encore is very spontaneous and unaffected and I really like that kind of encore. Like a couple of years back in the NZ Opera's production of Turandot Dongwon Shin gave such a powerful Nessun Dorma that the encore was completely deserved.

Though that said, I think the encore has become a recognised part of performing arts across the world, and there's not much use in complaining about it.

McP   #5   10:45 am Nov 04 2009

It's silly, but that's part of the fun. It's like watching a magic show - you know it's not real, but that's not the point.

It's still funny though when you catch people who believe that the artist was just about to exit the building before they heard the loud applause from the audience which convinced them to return to the stage to play their hit single.

Davo   #6   10:46 am Nov 04 2009

I agree. I also dislike the whole "we love you Christchurch!" (or wherever they happen to be playing) that bands feel obliged to do. Not to mention "You've been a wonderful audience!". Just once i would like someone to come out and say "thanks guys. You have been an average audience. Not bad, but a lot quieter than the one we had in Sydney last week, and not a patch on the guys in Tokyo. I don't think we will be back".

sher   #7   11:42 am Nov 04 2009

Ladyhawke would be the most unpretentious musician ever, she is great. As for your twitpic....other than pretty colours...it lacks somewhat in umm...ladyhawke?

samm   #8   11:51 am Nov 04 2009

Easy rule of thumb about encores vs the end of the gig. If the house lights come up the gig is over. The the act is off stage and the lights are still down they will be back. Simple!

Geoff   #9   11:53 am Nov 04 2009

Encore's just seem to be traditional. However, just because it's always been done like that, doesn't make it right.

I recall one U2 concert that I watched on DVD where Bono just told the audience that they weren't going to do the whole fake going off and "surprise" coming back out thing and would just play on.

I'm not fussed either way so long as there is good music on offer. :)

amc32   #10   11:59 am Nov 04 2009

i want a concert to finish like Bart Simpson's experience at Spinal Tap.


Show 11-35 of 35 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content