Talk to the hand

Last updated 09:31 25/11/2009

I've mentioned a number of times that I tend to talk with my hands.  On certain occasions I've been conscious that these expansive motions might be distracting and have attempted to keep them to a minimum, but this only works as long as I'm not fully engaged in the conversation.  As soon as I get excited or interested and want to comment, on comes the flapping. 

This gesture means I'm considering re-roofingAt this stage in my life I think the chances of being able to break myself of this habit are on par with the likelihood of me winning a Nobel prize for Science on the basis of my visionary and highly innovative "food eaten on holiday doesn't count" theory of dietary nutrition.  So, slim (unlike my weekend-in-Wellington self).

Although a lot of my perhaps unnecessary gesturing is what you might call decorative or "conversational embellishment", it's not all meaningless flapping.  Sometimes when I'm talking with my hands I am actually trying to say something.  I was speaking to a fellow librarian on Monday and I noticed that she pantomimed typing when she was talking about using her computer.  "Well, strap my hands down," I thought, "she's bloody pinched that from me."  But of course, I don't have a patent on that hand gesture and you can be sure that if hand gestures could be patented then I would probably register one of a more "adult" nature, because you just know it would be a lot more lucrative.

I spend a lot of time at a computer keyboard so often any sentence containing the phrase "I was at work" is accompanied by a comical up and down hand motion not dissimilar to a really feeble doggy paddle.  This gesture, when modified slightly so that both hands move up and down at the same time instead of alternating, becomes the "universal" symbol for "piano".

I also find that when I'm looking for something, like a utensil or other tool, that I mime the action of using said implement, as if this will somehow magically lure the item into my grasp more quickly.  Yes, certainly a stapler, upon seeing my empty hand mimicking a pincer movement, will leap up, wave, and emit a "cooeee, I'm over here".  What would be really interesting would be to see the stapler and the kitchen tongs fight it out to get my attention as I generally use the same hand motion for both things.  It's a lucky thing they're generally never in the same room together (coincidence or conspiracy?).

I'm also concerned that this is all a bit close to the generally hated "artform" that is "mime".  Just to be on the safe side I think I'm going to remove my "the time I got stuck in a box" story from my "amusing anecdote" repertoire and all those times I really want to talk about going downstairs or peeling a banana are going to have to go on ice.

And it's not like this straight-from-my-brain-to-my-hands communication channel is particularly useful.  Generally the people I'm talking to aren't hard of hearing.  And if the amount of time I spend trying to locate my keys whilst making an "unlocking the door" motion is anything to go by it doesn't make misplaced items turn up any sooner at all.  I'm just thankful that I don't do it with everything.  Luckily a goodly portion of my thoughts stay in my brain, some of them make it out of my mouth, or find expression in my facial muscles, and still fewer make the longer journey down my arms.  It doesn't take too much imagination to figure out that if all of my thoughts or opinions were expressed with my arms and hands, I could get myself into quite a bit of trouble. 

So, having found at least one other person in the world who types on a "phantom keyboard" in conversation, I'm curious to know if this is actually commonplace.  If you're a "two-finger typist" do you mime "finger poking" instead?  Have you noticed yourself or others doing specific "hand-talking" motions?  Does excessive hand flapping count as exercise and can it therefore burn calories ingested away from home?  Please wave your hands in the general direction of a keyboard and comment below.

Follow NZStuffBlogs on Twitter and get fast updates on all Stuff's blogs.

37 comments
Post a comment
JeM   #1   09:39 am Nov 25 2009

I only tend to do small hand gestures rather than big grand ones! I leave that to my gay friends. I haven't asked any of them yet, but is it complusory to be a hand talker if you are a gay male, as ALL my gay man mates do it...

Chilli   #2   09:50 am Nov 25 2009

I think the miming what you're talking about is a female thing, I definitely do it, as do a couple of my girlfriends, but I've never met a guy who mimes about driving or anything like that!

My favourite one is a friend who mimes about eating something, eg. "I was eating a sandwich" *imagine two hands grasping an invisible sandwich and taking a bite* or "I had some soup" *invisible soup spoon lifted to mouth*

Ahh good times.

MsM   #3   09:52 am Nov 25 2009

Jimeoin does a bit that relates to this: we all seem to point to our wrist when asking what the time is, imagine if we did similar when enquiring about where the toilet is... one generally shouldn't point to their crotch in public I've found, even if you are busting to go...

S   #4   09:57 am Nov 25 2009

I talk more with my hands when I'm excited too but my main reason for talking with my hands I think is that my brain often "releases" the word I need just as I'm about to say it so the actions are often accompanied by a phrase such as "the thing, you know, the thing!" *insert action here*

Courtney   #5   10:03 am Nov 25 2009

I love the way you speak. The image of a staper and a set of tongs duking it out is going to be cherished in my mind for at least a few minutes until I forget or get distracted by something shiny.

We're very alike with the hand motions. What's worse though is when you can feel your arms building anticipation, knowing they're about to get to make a ridiculous gesture and you consciously stop them - but then you're left with this uncomfortable feeling, although you've saved yourself some embarassment.

...but your arms are still there, attempting to guilt trip you..

....and that all sounds a lot crazier than I intended.

LK   #6   10:04 am Nov 25 2009

I completely sympathise with you on the gestures! I don't talk with my hands very much, but I do show the stapler wha's expected of it when I'm looking for it. Otherwise, who knows? It might have better plans. But all I'm really after is for it to fulfil its duties, then it can go back into hiding...

paul   #7   10:15 am Nov 25 2009

Just when you think she can't get any weirder...

Thalia   #8   10:19 am Nov 25 2009

I don't think I've ever mimed typing while talking but I do have a tendency to gesture when speaking, sometimes people make fun of it.. often I think I use movement when I can't quite get my thoughts out but otherwise its more like emphasis on points, I thought it was fairly normal. The only time I mime actual actions is when people don't understand what I am on about.

Hands, arms and shoulders as well as head and eye movement.. mayhaps I am just strange but at least people seem to understand what I am talking about... and they're entertained at the same time.

Louisette   #9   10:24 am Nov 25 2009

I don't really do the hand thing, but I do fiddle with my rings if a) I'm apprehensive, b) I'm bored, c) I'm trying to figure out what to say. I also do a thing where I spread out my hands with the palms outward when I'm being sarcastic about something and saying it's really exciting/sensational/new.

Don 1   #10   10:28 am Nov 25 2009

Pah, mime. I'm with Terry Pratchett, who once suggested in a Discworld books that mimes be hung "upside down in a scorpion pit opposite a sign reading 'Learn The Words'". Frantic waggling is not mime, however, it is a vital weapon in the armoury of communication. Well it is for an old duffer like me who forgets things easily.


Show 11-37 of 37 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content