The odd one out

DONNELLE BELANGER-TAYLOR
Last updated 08:39 25/05/2012

I was sort of a middle child. I was the youngest of three, until our half-brother arrived when I was seven. He immediately became my big sister's darling. With my big brother growing out of sibling rivalries, I was left as the middle in a red-headed sibling sandwich. We fought. A lot.

My experience as a middle child was one factor in our decision to have only two children. When we discovered that my second pregnancy was twins, one of my many and mixed reactions was "At least we get to have three kids without having a middle child!"

Xander and VieveSadly, despite there being only a four-minute gap between Finn and Vieve, Finn seems to have assumed the role of middle child. My eldest, Xander, is very close to his sister. They're often to be found snuggled up on the couch with a book, kicking a ball around, or playing with Lego, while Finn watches from one side.

Vieve obviously idolises Xander. Every move is scrutinised and copied, particularly at the dinner table. I find myself reminding him that he is a role model and needs to set a good example... and that dinner plates are not drums.

I do understand why Xander finds Vieve easier to get along with. Finn is in a boundary-pushing phase. He loves to "investigate" Xander's Lego creations, in a way that leaves scattered pieces across the floor. I've caught him on the kitchen counter switching the kettle on. Earlier in the week I heard the (cold) oven door open. I ran to the kitchen to find him attempting to put an orange in the oven. While wearing oven mitts.

On the other hand, I feel for Finn. He and Vieve are very close, but when Xander gets involved, the dynamic changes.

Xander expressed a preference for Vieve from when the twins were very small. I'm not sure if it originated as a fear of replacement, or because Finn was a more demanding baby, but the Lego incidents have definitely solidified his opinion. I hope it eases with time.

Have you noticed an odd-one-out among your children? Has it improved as they got older?

» Follow PG on Facebook

23 comments
Post a comment
rk   #1   08:54 am May 25 2012

Speaking as the middle child here - I am the youngest of twins and we have a little brother. I too was often left out as my twin sister and lil brother formed a bond, and I would say the dynamics are still there today. If we are all together they tend to gravitate towards eachother. But then, I have exacerbated that but being the only married, pregnant one :)

Another Anne   #2   09:12 am May 25 2012

We had twins first up, and I have to admit that even if I wanted a third, I'd be put off by the same odd-one-out concern. As it is, I'm too scared of having twins again to take the risk! My husband is one of three and now, as adults, they get along brilliantly, but my mil has often told me about all the ganging up that happened in their childhood. From what I understand, in a lot of three child families the one that gets left out changes depending on stages, interests etc. So maybe it won't always be Finn - I bet once he's a bit older they'll have a their own brotherly dynamic. Thing is, they'll each grow up with their own perspectives on their childhood which may surprise you when they talk about it in later years.

Me   #3   09:16 am May 25 2012

I was the odd one out as a kid, not because I was the middle child but because there was a 5 year gap between me and my sister (also my sister was the only grandaughter and my brother was the oldest grandchild) but now as an adult I would say I am the closest to both siblings

JCC   #4   09:24 am May 25 2012

Oh Donnelle! I wouldn't worry too much about the middle child syndrome. I am the 2nd (of 4) and was always the peacemaker between my brothers (#1 and 3), and between my little brother and sister, and i think it has made me a more empathetic person who likes to work out solutions that work for everyone. Finn might be, by nature, a bit more of a loner, but if you think he's missing out, maybe try to encourage a special friendship with someone at playgroup? Brothers will always fight, just wait until they're in their late teens and they'll be the best of friends!

Elisabeth   #5   09:50 am May 25 2012

I have a fantastic book called "The Birth Order Book" by Dr Kevin Leman that explains some of what tends to characterise first, middle, and youngest children. It's awesome for explaining some of the dynamics between children, and how to work with them effectively as a parent. I thoroughly recommend it to everyone!

gbsmama   #6   10:03 am May 25 2012

As the oldest of 6, there were a number of 'middle children' in our house, but never one in particular. It was always changing - we all took a turn at feeling left out of something. What is interesting is that we all seem to be paired up, even now - each of the three older kids chose a younger one to 'buddy' up with. I never even noticed it until my mum pointed it out, but I tend to have a closer relationship with Child 4 - she can be a bit flaky, and somehow it became my responsibility to keep her in line - I was moaning about this to my mum, and she said that I had been doing that for her since I was 7, so why complain now! I think you will find that as Finn gets older, he will be more able to share Xander's interests eg lego, and they will develop their own relationship. Xander sounds like a kid who likes things that are different, and Vieve, being a girl, is different. Another option is to have another child hehe!

Me too   #7   10:05 am May 25 2012

Thanks for helping me decide whether or not to have another child.

But seriously, can you do something to strengthen/foster the relationship between Finn and Xander? Perhaps get Finn interested in something that Xander is passionate about? Sounds like they might have lego in common once Finn gets a bit bigger and out of the "I don't want to build it, I only want to destroy it" phase.

Wanderlust   #8   10:48 am May 25 2012

Fighting all the time; ah, the memories! Whenever someone says to me that they are pregnant again, so that the child can be a playmate for the first, I laugh and laugh and laugh.

Lulu   #9   10:52 am May 25 2012

I come from a family of three kids (I am the youngest) and I don't think any of us would have it any other way. It was great fun. The relationship will change around a lot as they get older. I remember there being two vs one at some points (usually in the back seat of the car) but I also clearly remember the three of us banding together when we needed to (usually to remove/hide carpet stains or holes in the wall). I definitely want three.

AngelinBA   #10   12:30 pm May 25 2012

I have 3 kids, oldest a boy and 2 girls. At the moment I can“t see any odd one out, the turns they take to fight with each other seem fairly evenly shared out. The older two are only in agreement when it comes to getting angry with the baby who, at 2 1/2 yrs has been nicknamed 'Dora la Destructora' (Dora the destroyer) because everything she touches is with the purpose of pulling apart, throwing on the ground or putting into water. I'm sure they'll be best of friends when they're older, as I am with my 2 siblings.


Show 11-23 of 23 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content