Can Kiwis taste the price difference between expensive and cheap wine? video

BEVAN READ/stuff

Do you think you can pick the top shelf from a cheapie, we put five office workers to the test and the results might surprise you.

Do you think you can you taste the difference between a $7.99 bottle of wine and a $25 bottle?

Most people would say yes - but what happens if you were drinking from plastic cups, and you didn't know which was which?

If you can't actually taste any difference, maybe you can save yourself a few bucks.

Are your household bills bigger than your neighbour's? Enter your household details and any of the listed expenses with their frequency to see how you stack up against households like your own.
start
overall household details
Income required
Select range of annual household income
35.7K
62.2K
93.6K
136.6K
Size required
Select number of people in your household
{{expense.name}} optional
calculate
Income
Before tax household income from all sources, except for one-off payments such as gifts of money or inheritances.
Pharmaceuticals
Examples include but are not limited to: prescription drugs, oral contraceptives, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, ointments.
results
No expenses to compare. Please enter at least one of your expenses.
{{expense.name}}
${{expenditure[expense.frequency] | number}}
Avg
${{expense.expense | number}}
You
You spend {{Math.round(Math.abs(1 - (expense.expense / expenditure[expense.frequency]))*100) | number}}% morelessthe same on this expense {{expense.frequency}} thanas the average Kiwi household of similar income and size. Data: Stats NZ

We put the theory to the test by giving several lucky volunteers unknown samples of beer and wine. We told them to try and rank them in price order from least to most expensive. 

The test used five pinot gris, including some well known brands such as Church Rd, The Ned and Morton Estate - which varied in price from $7.99 to $25 for a 750ml bottle. 

Also on the menu was five lagers, which included Heineken, Steinlager and Hellertau among others. They varied in price from $3.99 to $8.49 for a 500ml bottle. 

Jess was the best at telling how expensive each beer was.
BEVAN READ / FAIRFAX NZ

Jess was the best at telling how expensive each beer was.

So how good are Kiwis at discerning a fine wine from a cheap drop?

So, so. 

SCORES

Megan: Wine 2/5, Beer 2/5

Ad Feedback

Mark: Wine 2/5, Beer 2/5

Jess: Wine 2/5, Beer 3/5

Participants ranked wine and beer according to what they thought tasted more or less expensive
BEVAN READ / FAIRFAX NZ

Participants ranked wine and beer according to what they thought tasted more or less expensive

Tom: Wine 2/5, Beer 0/5

Elise: Wine 0/5, Beer 1/5

RESULTS

Out of the wines, most people identified the cheapest ones correctly - with comments suggesting those flavours weren't as sophisticated as some of the others. 

And out of the beers, most people correctly identified which one was the most expensive. Participants said it tasted more "crafty" which they said was often likely to be more expensive. 

Jess got the highest overall score of correct price estimates, while Elise performed the worst - only one beer right. 

Although Tom didn't correctly identify the price order of any beers, he was only one place off in each beer, suggesting his taste buds were pretty well aligned to price. 

Megan had a blunder and thought the cheapest bottle was the most expensive one. 

"Price doesn't necessarily mean anything, I would would far prefer to have this $9 bottle, over the $25 dollar bottle. So if I was going out to a BYO, [this is] obviously my choice - I'm definitely going to buy that one again."

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Ad Feedback