Why most exercise supplements are bunk

Last updated 10:06 02/05/2014
Protein

SIP IT UP: Protein increases muscle mass, but is it necessary to drink shakes to up your intake?

Related Links

Do you really need that supplement? Supplement could make exercise fun Calcium supplements 'raise' heart risk

Relevant offers

Well & Good

Is skipping breakfast the key to weightloss? Bootcamp end-goal in sight Veges power bodybuilders' growth Five ways to prevent work-life burnout Running drills: your new best friend? Does reheating pasta make it healthier? Spring-summer vegetables to enjoy Dieting? You're doing it all wrong 8 things I learned after giving up processed foods Aussies urged to lose grabbable guts

I am always amazed by the wide range of sports nutrition products on sale in gyms. 

No matter the time of day, it seems gym-goers are always drinking nutrient shakes. The sports nutrition market has grown rapidly in the last few years.

There are health benefit claims all over these products, including enhanced recovery, increased muscle mass, fat burning, better muscle definition and improved ''well-being".

With so many of these messages out there, people are obviously interested in separating the good products from the bad. As a sports scientist, I am often asked which ones people should consume when training. My general opinion is that supplements are unnecessary. You should be able to satisfy all your nutritional requirements with an appropriate diet.

But since this answer never seems to satisfy, here is a look at some of the most common supplements and the data on their importance to exercise. It is aimed at people who work out a few times a week.

Protein

The main reason for consuming protein is to increase muscle mass, because it stimulates the body to produce muscle protein. This is well established, but what is often debated is how much protein is sufficient, what type to ingest and the best time to do so.

The best type appears to be whey protein. It is absorbed into the gut more than 70 per cent faster than other options, such as casein and soy protein supplements. This means it gets to the muscles more quickly, which increases the rate at which the body builds muscle protein by more than 20 per cent compared to the other options.

Many gym-goers swear by something called the ''anabolic window,'' a claim that the protein needs to be consumed within minutes of stopping exercise for any gains to be realized. Put simply, this is pretty much hype. The window is likely 24 to 48 hours, rather than a few minutes.

As for how much protein to consume, a recent study found that in young men between 176 and 187 pounds (around 80 to 85kg) who weight-train regularly, it took 20 grams of whey protein to achieve the best possible result - what we in the trade call ''maximal stimulation''.

Any more than 20 grams appears unnecessary, in this population, anyway. It just leads to a lot of extra protein being excreted in the urine.

Creatine

Creatine has been a popular supplement for many years, though it also occurs naturally in red meat, eggs and fish. Quite a large body of scientific evidence supports its use to gain muscle mass and enhance recovery.

When creatine is taken up into the muscle, it helps to generate energy. This allows the muscle to contract and exercise to continue. This can help enhance gains in muscle mass and strength in response to weight training.

But creatine's effects on sport performance are less convincing. It increases body water storage, which increases body mass. In sports where body weight is important, this counteracts the muscle benefits and means there are unlikely to be benefits overall.

Ad Feedback

Vitamins

It is often assumed that vitamins are good for health. That is true, but when vitamins are taken in excess the opposite can be true for both health and exercise.

In particular vitamin C and E, which act as antioxidants, have actually been shown to hamper the body's adaptation to exercise training. Two recent studies found that people who took large amounts of the two vitamins (1000mg/day of vitamin C and 267mg/day of vitamin E) showed no improvement in aerobic fitness or exercise performance.

This level of consumption is 250 times the recommended dietary allowance for vitamin C and 80 times that for vitamin E, though well within the range of commercially available supplements.

The study produced another important finding. Two benefits of regular exercise are that human bodies become more sensitive to insulin, meaning the person is less likely to get diabetes, and they can produce more energy by creating more of the ''work horse'' units in cells known as mitochondria.

The people in the study who took the vitamins found that these benefits were attenuated to some extent. This suggests that these supplements may do more harm than good, certainly if you take them in large quantities.

Caffeine

People don't consume caffeine to help adapt their bodies to training but rather for improved performance during a single bout of exercise, such as a competition.

Taking caffeine supplements will indeed prolong your endurance during exercise. Coffee lovers will be glad to know that you can get the same benefits from coffee consumption.

Energy drinks

Carbohydrate-based drinks have been around for a long time, and have long been seen as worthwhile because of the way they increase the delivery of energy to the body and provide hydration. But in recent years the evidence supporting their ability to improve acute exercise performance has been called into question.

While I am confident these drinks are useful during prolonged, intense exercise of about two hours, they are often consumed during shorter duration exercise when they are likely to have little benefit.

There has also been a lot of concern in recent years about young children consuming these drinks without exercising much and unwittingly increasing their sugar and calorie consumption. These drinks also often contain caffeine, which is not recommended for children.

Other supplements

There are several other supplements available that claim to benefit to exercisers. These include beta-alanine, fish oil, conjugated linoleic acid, L-carnitine, L-arginine, nitrate and vitamin D. Current evidence suggests there is no apparent benefit from them.

Supplement contamination

In a recent study, 10 per cent of supplements tested contained banned products, such as steroids. Clearly this creates the possibility of failing a drug test if exercising competitively. More important, it is extremely worrisome to me that these substances could be in health products that can be picked up in a local supermarket.

In short, nutrition products can benefit people who work out, but there's so much misinformation that you may well be wasting money or even undermining your body's performance.

If the question is, ''What supplements should I take to enhance my exercise training?'' the simple answer is: Nothing. Exercise, have a balanced diet and enjoy it!

Stuart Gray is a senior lecturer at the Institute of Medical Sciences at the University of Aberdeen in Scotland. A version of this post first appeared on the website The Conversation.

- The Washington Post

Comments

Recipe search

Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you believe eating superfoods makes you healthier?

Yes, I feel so much better when I eat them.

No, it's all a con.

I don't know, I can't afford them.

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content