Papers reveal service cut plan

BY JANINE RANKIN
Last updated 12:00 09/02/2010

Relevant offers

Hospital beds at Horowhenua, Palmerston North Hospital's rehabilitation ward and sexual health and diabetes services could be chopped in MidCentral Health's attempt to claw back a forecast $8.9 million deficit this year.

Cuts to renal services and medicine budgets are also proposed in leaked documents from a district health board hospital advisory committee workshop last week.

The media was not invited to the workshop which faced the challenge of complying with Health Minister Tony Ryall's instructions to break even and to deliver a "recovery plan" for wiping out the deficit.

Savings from management reviews, the loss of 12 nursing and caregiver roles at the hospital and other cost-cutting measures have failed to achieve a target to save $800,000 a month, and MidCentral Health is looking to cut deeper.

"Small changes are not going to help us live within our means," said chief executive Murray Georgel.

There were already service reviews under way, but they were unlikely to save enough without exploring other options, he said.

"So much for front line services," said Palmerston North MP Iain Lees-Galloway, referring to Mr Ryall's assurances that services would not be cut.

"This is what ultimately had to happen.

"The board is between a rock and a hard place – it has to find these savings, and letting a few backroom people go and dropping a few staff here and there was never going to be enough."

He said cutting preventive services like diabetes management would be short-sighted.

Primary care did not have the resources to pick up the work MidCentral Health off-loaded.

New Zealand Nurses Organisation representative Donna Ryan said she was "absolutely gobsmacked" by the papers.

"Nobody has talked about exit of services with me.

"I'm not sure how far ahead their plans are, or if it's just for discussion.

"But I think the community has a right to know what they're talking about."

Ms Ryan said she had been involved in discussions about the future shape of the hospital's rehabilitation services through the rehabilitation units.

"But I'm not prepared to do any more work on that if they are exiting the service."

HAVE YOUR SAY
What do you think about this? Write to the editor at PO Box 3, Palmerston North, email editor@msl.co.nz, (include name and address), text to 027 498 1242, or post your comments below.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

2 comments
Post a comment
Appalled!   #2   10:09 am Feb 10 2010

I am infuriated to read of more cuts to beds within MidCentral DHB. My wife works at Palmerston North Hospital as a senior nurse on a busy ward. She very often comes home over an hour late as her workload is unable to be managed safely within her 8 hour day. If she attempts (which is rare) to claim overtime she is told it will not be paid because her trendcare hours do not reflect the need for her to stay late! Trendcare is a computerised system (which adds to the nurse's workload)that predicts how much nursing time each patient SHOULD (I say should as patients are human beings and are individuals and do not always "fit" a computer programme), require. If the nurse does predict hours that are out of the norm she/he is often challenged about the increased hours required.

I understand that cuts have to be made but not to the detriment of the patients. My wife often comes home stating that she gets to do the bare minimum for her patients, gone are the days when she could sit & chat & carry out the extra little touches. With the extremely reduced Care Assistant hours and the huge increase in Hospital Aide hours the impact on patient care has been again detrimental. Care assistants were a vaulable resource to help nursing staff with showering, toileting etc whereas Hospital Aides are not able to help in these areas what so ever. That change was not well thought out, these change have to ensure that effective cost cutting is made and that the changes will not effect frontline staff or the patients.

How about this idea, cut the CEO's, Director of Nursing, and their PA's (I assume they have personnal assistants), & Service managers hours in half and other management who fit in this category. Not Bed numbers which ultimately means nursing staff. Charge Nurses, nurse educators and the likes are frontline staff and therefore no cuts should be made. Cutting CEO, DON hours will not be to the detriment of the patients and grassroots staff. The running of wards & departments will go back to being run by the people who know what's going on rather than people who sit in offices away from the frontline & monitor what's happening via a computer! and conjuring up more paperwork for the nurses to a use to assess their patients which in turn leads to less hands on patient hours.

As you can tell I am appalled at the prospect of more cuts to nursing staff as a nurses workload is already stretched to the limits. if more staff cuts take place I will encourage my wife to seek work somewhere else. Why should she work extra hours for an organisation who shows zero loyalty to hardworking caring professionals.

M   #1   07:11 pm Feb 09 2010

Tony Ryall promised to make backroom (administration) of health more efficient and put the money into frontline services. I'd like to hear what the Minister has to say about these plans. What about our elected Board members - what do they have to say? What about the people of the Midcentral region - what do you want?

Give us some hard facts and figures about where the money goes, why we're in deficit, then we can decide what to cut: services, the Board and CEO, or perhaps the Minister!

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content