Police treating death of a man at his Rotorua home as suspicious ... Read more

Death too cruel

Last updated 09:42 15/05/2014

Relevant offers


Stuart Smith: Kaikoura's health centre proves community collaboration is alive and well Stuart Smith: Raise a glass to another successful Marlborough vintage Opinion: Ngai Tahu leader Sir Mark Solomon's constancy has paid off for iwi Always blow on the (smaller) pie SATIRE: Marlborough mum takes ultimate stand against fluoride Fighting together, dying together so that we can live together Marlborough SATIRE: Sparky's light bulb moment Heritage at the heart of a vibrant future for Marlborough SATIRE: Marlborough's harvest workers evoke apocalyptic fear OPINION: Marlborough schools doing 'fantastic work'

There is a scene in Stephen King's The Green Mile where a prison officer pronounces a successful execution. It has, in fact, been extravagantly cruel.

A sadistic guard did not wet the head of the prisoner in the electric chair; so he had burnt and died in a horrific spectacle. How was that successful, a furious official demands. The answer was implacable: He is dead, isn't he?

A similarly successful execution has taken place in Oklahoma, where a man with a collapsed vein lived 32 minutes after being administered the first of three drugs. Witnesses described him writhing on the gurney and struggling to speak.

One reporter recorded him saying: "Man . . . I'm not . . . something's wrong" before the blinds were closed.

By any standard, the crime for which this guy, Clayton Lockett, was convicted was horrific. He presided over the rape, shooting and live burial of a young woman.

Some commentators were quick to say he would still have suffered less than his victim did.

And of course, people were quick to provide their own vengeance fantasies of how else he would have died if they had their way.

The fact remains that in Oklahoma they have been making a pig's breakfast of executions. In January, Michael Lee Wilson gave an anguished commentary on his own execution: "I feel my whole body burning".

United States President Barack Obama does not oppose the death penalty. Had he done so, it is highly questionable he would have been elected in the first place.

And the US Supreme Court has ruled not only to uphold lethal injection, but also to clarify that there is no constitutional right for it to be painless. Their rule is that there cannot be a system that tolerates "cruel and unusual punishment".

Somewhere between the courtrooms and the death chambers, however, things have been getting ugly indeed.

The state executions have not been providing the ceremonial satisfaction required, to an extent that the convulsions of the bad folk have been making some of the decent folk feel bad.

So practices are being reviewed.

Execution does not act as a deterrent. It does, obviously, prevent repeat offending, but so do jail terms of sufficient length.

Ad Feedback

- The Marlborough Express


Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content