Basin Reserve flyover idea a ' 50s relic' - expert

MATT STEWART
Last updated 14:06 14/02/2014
NZTA

The Basin Reserve flyover shows how motorists will travel around the cricket pitch in this simulation video.

Relevant offers

Elevated freeways are a relic of the 1950s that tend to create urban blight, a visiting transport expert has told the board of inquiry into the proposed Basin Reserve flyover.

US urban planning and transport expert Dr Richard Lee today gave evidence on behalf of Save the Basin spokeswoman Leonie Reynolds.

When asked by New Zealand Transport Agency lawyer Andrew Cameron whether plans for the $90 million project would ease the prospect of urban blight Lee said the flyover would likely be the ''cause of blight'' rather than a remedy to it.

He said there were mitigating factors, "but I'm not sure they would change the shadow, noise and perceived barrier effect'' of the proposed two-lane highway flyover 20m north of the Basin Reserve.

In the US many cities were tearing down elevated freeways because of the urban decay they caused in surrounding neighbourhoods.

Lee cited the example of San Francisco's waterfront Embacadero Freeway, built in 1959 and torn down in 1991 after it was damaged in the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake.

Following its demolition the surrounding area flourished as a shopping boulevard was built, house prices went up and jobs were created in the area.

Lee also said NZTA modelling was not nearly detailed enough to accurately predict the effect of the flyover because it did not focus closely enough on road, public transport and walking and cycling networks.

''It's less robust and accurate compared to a state of the art model.''

Lee also refuted the claim that traffic around the Basin would only get worse citing research showing across the US, New Zealand driving had been declining for a decade - a trend that started before the global financial crisis, peaking in the mid-2000s.

Young people were driving less because they preferred city-living while baby boomers were cutting back as they entered retirement.Petrol prices, car ownership and parking costs were all rising, which was another reason people were driving less.

Although elevated highways separated traffic flows he said they left a huge impact footprint and shadow.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should overseas tourists have to sit a practical driving test before being allowed to drive on New Zealand's roads?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related story: Grieving son, 9, may force driving tests for tourists

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Car Club small pointer

The Car Club blog: Powered by Autocar NZ

Holiday driving - less idiocy for once?

Driving tips
Gear up for that big holiday drive

Don't leave it too late

Gear up for that big holiday drive

Tips on how to do a safe river crossing

Taking the plunge

Tips on how to do a safe river crossing

Winter driving tips

Winter driving

On the road and prepared for the cold snap