Anger over fake parking tickets

BY CLIO FRANCIS
Last updated 14:00 07/04/2009
SPOT THE DIFFERENCE: The fake parking ticket, left, and a real parking infringement notice. Click here to see larger image of the tickets.

Relevant offers

An Auckland bar has been accused of breaching copyright after handing out 2,000 fake parking tickets to Parnell motorists.

The tickets are almost identical to those issued by the Auckland City Council, but were plastered on car windscreens last week as part of an marketing ploy by Parnell bar Ivory Lounge.

The only difference between the real and fake fine notices is the website address and the 0800 phone number.

Motorists who rang 0800 PARKFINE on the fake tickets were told they were victims of a prank. But Auckland City Council staff were not amused.

Group manager for parking Brian Tomlinson said a parking ticket was a legal document, and as such, there were serious legal ramifications if it was subject to fraudulent reproduction.

"It's an April Fools joke and I can appreciate that but I also understand the concept has gone horribly wrong," he said.

The council and police had both fielded complaints, but Mr Tomlinson said it won't prosecute.

"We've decided we're not going to be pursuing this further, enough council and police time has already been wasted investigating this.''

However the bar's manager and co-owner Callum O'Brien was unrepentant. "I think it's all been taken a bit seriously by some people with no sense of humour. If a fake parking ticket on your car ruins your life you've really got to take a look at yourself,'' he said.

The bar was asked to stop issuing the tickets and cease all activity surrounding it. Mr Tomlinson said if this directive was not followed there was the option to pursue the matter further.

Yesterday afternoon the bar's website was displaying the parking ticket and the 0800 phone number was still active.

Mr O'Brien said he had no plans to take down the advertising.

"The people who don't see the funny side of it probably wouldn't come to our bar anyway.

"All in all I think it's been good for business."

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

49 comments
Post a comment
MK   #49   04:40 pm Apr 30 2009

At first glance they look very similar, but it doesn't, or shouldn't take too long to realise that in actual fact it is in no way a genuine ticket. So why is everyone so angry? Perhaps they are just angry at their own stupidity. If you actually believed it to be a ticket perhaps that means you regularly recieve parking infringements, and in that case, this is a good lesson.

If you recieved a ticket and are not happy about it then cry me a river and throw the "ticket" in the bin, if you didnt recieve a "ticket" and just want to complain about it for the sake of it, which by the way most Aucklanders are really good at doing, then build a bridge and get over it, you are making it to be out more than it really is, a joke - and a rewarding one at that.

It isn't out of the ordinary to use innovative marketing schemes in the hospitality industry, so good on yah Callum for thinking outside the box to advertise your bar.

Mel   #48   02:23 pm Apr 08 2009

Classic! Good stuff Ivory Lounge. People need to have their wits about them on April Fools...so for those that actually fell for this - shame on you. To everyone else complaining, get over it- it was just a prank. I hope they have heaps of new patrons this week - brilliant advertising.

Andy   #47   09:39 am Apr 08 2009

I think this is a fantastic campaign! The Ivory Lounge will be getting my business from now on. I would love to get a ticket that turns out to be a free drink.... better than any tickets i've got in the past. The fact that some people (William Bailey) are having a cry about it is exactly the point.... get people talking about the bar. The campaign would not be as big of a success without Nana's like you William making a story out of it. Maybe they should change their name to the Irony Lounge.

Jo   #46   09:08 am Apr 08 2009

Brilliant!! I wish more of my parking tickets looked like that :-)

MartiniMartook   #45   08:41 am Apr 08 2009

One of the best marketing ploys I have seen. Everyone knows people who make up local government have no sense of humour, and once again they have proven themselves to be overpaid morons.

The campaign will have given this business extensive exposure, which as stated previously is going to give them a leg up during tough times..... and keep some more people employed!

Randy Earl   #44   03:27 am Apr 08 2009

As a Kiwi i'm embarrassed that this prank has been taken so seriously by the ACC. NZ definitely needs to realise the PC world was a 90s thing and Modern times require a sense of humour and sometimes a thick skin. Good on ya Ivory. Love your bar, love your work and keep the Billy Joel tunes blasting!!!

bob   #43   02:14 am Apr 08 2009

The fake ticket actually states its "not an infringement notice". Totally legit.

Outstanding   #42   10:34 pm Apr 07 2009

Top effort - but some bad journalism here - expect better from your website. You say the only difference was the web address and the 0800 number. This is rubbish. There are heaps of differences. Nearly every paragraph at the top and at the bottom all point to the bars details and you would have to be a moron to have studied that ticket closely and thought it to be genuine

Mik   #41   08:55 pm Apr 07 2009

You'd have to be a dumbarse to get upset over a ticket like that...pretty obvious...some people should get a life...

HnomiS   #40   06:49 pm Apr 07 2009

Tony 8 - what helps the economy get moving again? Perhaps consumer spending? Where do consumers spend money? In a bar from time to time. Perhaps your time would be better spent researching before commenting. If your business doesn't have a website in this day and age you are streaks behind the start line - get on the same page as the rest of the world. It's attitudes like yours that hold NZ back from true diversity and development on the global business platform.

The campaign is excellent and has probably acheived what it set out to do - it's got people hot under the collars, it's got people talking and most likely it will have people walking through the front doors. A great viral piece that will have people showing their friends who will then talk to friends of friends. Nice job and am sure the positive spin will be outweighing the negative. In an age where generic advertising has no cut through you got to be looking outside the box. Nice job right there.


Show 1-39 of 49 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Omnivore blog pointer small

The Omnivore: Jeremy Taylor on food

Alex James - what are you playing at?

Moata

Moata's Blog Idle

A Sheep's Show

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mondayising Waitangi and Anzac Days