It's not a tragedy - it's a travesty
The Southland Times
Related Links
Relevant offers
Open letter to parents by Southern District road policing manager, Inspector Andrew Burns.
Since the start of this year there have been 11 people killed in Southland as the result of vehicle crashes.
This is in itself an absolute tragedy but when all the factors are examined, some of these vehicle crashes don't appear to be tragedies. They are travesties.
The deaths of seven of these 11 people cannot be seen as tragedies. They are devastating for family and friends, but not tragedies.
These seven deaths involved excessive speed or alcohol.
This might sound harsh, particularly with the events of the past few days in Invercargill where the lives of three young people have been needlessly wasted.
The reason I say that these particular events are not tragedies is that the behaviours of the people involved suggested a high probability that the cause of their deaths would be related to these behaviours. Simply put, if people are engaging in high-risk behaviours, such as speeding and drink-driving, the chance that they will be involved in a crash increases dramatically.
Research tells us that speed is a factor in about 30 per cent of fatal and 15 per cent of injury crashes across the population.
However, this increases to 46 per cent of fatal and 23 per cent of injury crashes among 15 to 19-year-olds. Driving with a blood alcohol level of 80mg/100ml increases by 16 times the chance of being involved in a crash. This blows out to an increase of 86 times for those aged 15 to 19.
It is clear that 15 to 19-year-olds are a high-risk group with six of the seven deaths mentioned being in this age group.
Ultimately the responsibility for keeping this group safe is ours; the community, but more importantly the families and friends of these young people.
The police have a role in this by enforcing laws that are designed to keep all road users safe.
Unfortunately police are often not supported by those in a position to influence and protect these young people. Excuses are made for behaviours, responsibilities are shifted elsewhere and there are complaints about unfair treatment.
These young people need guidance. They need good role models. They need direction.
They don't need tacit approval to continue high-risk behaviours.
I know this is not easy but as a community we see the devastation that occurs when things go wrong.
I am sure everyone would prefer to turn back the clock and make some changes after the event. We need to start doing it now.
If family and friends do not take a lead role in changing these behaviours then we will continue to see obituaries for young people that might be more accurately described as a "devastating loss" to family and friends as opposed to "tragically taken". To see the numbers of young people hurt and killed as a result of taking part in high-risk driving behaviours is a travesty; the tragedy is some of us are allowing it to happen.
TIMELINE
What happened: It appears a vehicle travelling at high speed in Leven St clips a traffic island and skids sideways for more than 100m. It flattens a parking meter and slams into a concrete wall.
When: 12.35am on Friday
Dead: Driver Jesse Langeveld, 19 Passengers Tylar Parry, 16, and Ethan Peek, 16
Seriously injured: Passenger Shawn Milne, 16
The car: A highly modified Honda Civic
The cause: Still subject to a police investigation but speed, alcohol, drag racing and road conditions are being considered as possible factors.
Sponsored links
Karl Beardsley your "Every young bloke does this" attitude is pathetic,moronic and utter rubbish. Only a small fraction of young guys are dumb enough to get drunk and pretend they are Michael Schumacher around a suburban street in a souped up "boy racer" car. See my earlier post re 'natural evolution'.
A travesty, yesiree. These kids were just idiots ... but then again, common sense is taught from their parents. Although you cannot use this example as justification for raising the age that one can obtain a drivers licence. There are always going to be morons on the road and you can't save everyone.
Compulsory insurance and ban modifications - that would deal with a lot of the issues.
Thank you Inspector for being the voice of the 1000's who agree with you. I just cant believe the Tui stickers on the coffin. Obviously some people just dont get it.
Inspector Burns, you have my vote! More of us need to be saying the things you have & following the words with action. Thank you.
Thank you to Inspector Burns who has said what so many were thinking.
'Simply put, if people are engaging in high-risk behaviours, such as speeding and drink-driving, the chance that they will be involved in a crash increases dramatically.'
...Seems to be pretty logical.
The police can only educate and reiterate so much info to boy racers. Do the parents need to step forward and take some responsibility in reminding their kids as to whats smart and whats not?
Mind you, a 16 year old still out at midnight on a Thursday, a casket covered in Tui stickers and a final lap of Invercargill before his funeral? Maybe there was no help for some.
Thank you Inspector Burns,
Perhaps if NZ follows Germany's example and makes a first-aid accreditation compulsory for all drivers. Then perhaps people (of all ages) will realise that their actions in a car can result in serious repercussions.
Here is the answer, nice and simple so even the politicians can understand:
15. Year. Old. Children. Should. Not. Drive. Cars. On. Public. Roads.
Simple, really. 17 at least - 18 preferably.
I've just turned 30 and become old and boring with this post.
Please please please can we bring in compulsory insurance. It will stop 99% of this problem, full stop.
Minister fears fake limbs putting prison staff at risk
Lawyer refuses to testify against war medal burglary accused
Police dob in drink driver to Air NZ
Teacher has baby with 17-year-old student
Martinborough pinot strikes gold
Dog left bleeding after scooter drag
Update on the undead from science's bat-cave
Concern over missing South Auckland teen and baby
El Nino puffs up for a big blow
Covenant - The healing after all the pain and heartache
Concern over missing South Auckland teen and baby
Police dob in drink driver to Air NZ
Dog left bleeding after scooter drag
All Blacks beat England in dour test
Williams confident of luring Tiger to NZ again
Teacher has baby with 17-year-old student
El Nino puffs up for a big blow
Wallabies humiliated by Scotland
Martinborough pinot strikes gold
Triple treat cashes up ailing NZRU
All Blacks beat England in dour test
Police dob in drink driver to Air NZ
Wallabies humiliated by Scotland
Teacher has baby with 17-year-old student
Bitter MP seeks reconciliation
Shyla's a purr-fect little mum
Nice Kiwi blokes - shame about the women
Griffin's moves biscuits to Fiji
$450,000 march is political manipulation
Cyclists gone but their trash lingers
Mall campaign pays for 'protesters'
Playing chicken with the markets
Newest First
Oldest First
I haven't read all the comments, perhaps this has been covered, but the parents and friends of the driver in particular want to consider that he would be facing manslaughter charges had he survived. Nothing glorious about that. The tui thing, and singing drinking songs at one of the funerals rather disgusts me.