Ad Feedback

Police 'cowboyish' in shooting out of control steer

The Press
Last updated 05:00 04/11/2009
Steer
DON SCOTT/ The Press
PHOTO SHOOT: People gather around the dead steer for photographs after the police shot it in the grounds of Riccarton High School.

Relevant offers

Police have been accused of "cowboyish and outrageous" behaviour for shooting a steer that ran out of control in Christchurch.

Police say they had to shoot the steer as it was out of control and a danger to the public, but one witness criticised the police actions.

The brown steer ran amok after escaping from a trailer on Suva St near the intersection with Hansons Lane, in Riccarton, about 5pm yesterday. It crashed through a fence and dented a police patrol car before it was herded onto the Riccarton High School sports grounds.

Police made the decision to shoot the animal about 5.40pm as they believed it could endanger people during rush hour.

One witness, who wished to remain anonymous, said police mishandled the situation.

"It was pretty outrageous. They decided that they could not contain the animal.

"The poor bugger was beside itself with fear.

"You have to shoot a cattle beast between the eyes really. After about five shots they killed the bugger. They had no idea. They were urban policemen with no idea about rural stock. They needed to let him calm down. It was cowboyish and outrageous."

It is understood the steer had just been bought and was being taken from the saleyards to a lifestyle block.

Acting sergeant Gordi Meyer said the animal was a danger to the public and could not be calmed. "There was no chance of getting it on a trailer and it was coming up to rush hour, so we did not want it back on the road. We made the decision to shoot it so it could not do any more damage or run into cars and people. It was a safety decision we made at the time," he said

Ad Feedback
33 comments
Copper   #33   11:06 am Nov 04 2009

Come one move on!!!! Other pressing matters to worry about. #27 Good one, agree.

Emma   #32   09:41 am Nov 04 2009

This happened right outside our Flat! It looked hardly uncontainable, was a big fella though

Matt   #31   09:32 am Nov 04 2009

That cattlebeast is at least 5 times bigger than a human, police guns are sized for humans - hence several shots. Also the last thing they want is to have a wounded animal running bezerk. A bullet costs a few cents and even if the steer was mortally wounded after say 3 shots, two extra ones to make sure and to have it die quickly are well worth it. All you who feel sorry for the steer - do you eat meat? How do you think things happen in that industry, I assure you there are no tranquiliser darts and gentle coaxing.

George   #30   09:31 am Nov 04 2009

Ok guys, lets just take a breath here. Yes it could have been tranqed but apart from the Zoo perhaps, who in Chch would have a dart gun?

The animal would have taken a long time to calm down, 5-6 hrs at least. Where was it supposed to be contained at the time? Didnt realise there were good sets of yards in the middle of Chch....

And as for the witness who says that you needed to shoot it between the eyes, obviously he's never shot a cattle beast. You cant shoot them between the eyes, that never drops them.

Mark   #29   09:30 am Nov 04 2009

People who think that the police should have shot a moving target between the eyes, or better still, had a vet come in and tranquilise the steer, live in a magical place where anything is possible. If they think this is sad, they should enter the supermarket meat aisle.

kyle   #28   09:28 am Nov 04 2009

you people are a bunch of whingers. i bet you would all be crying out if they hadn't shot it, and it had been hit by a car during rush hour or something equivilant. 'wah wah the cops aren't doing their job'

Good on them for making an executive decision on the day, one that at the time seemed to justify the situation and more than likely prevented further damage to the surrounding area and the people in it. It was a shame the animal had to die, but i daresay it was destined for the dinner table anyway.

Grant   #27   09:27 am Nov 04 2009

David they need guts not to pander to people like yourself. I'm not surprised they shot it 5 times, it's the instinctive reaction when you want to make sure, big deal. 5 shots over the course of about 5 seconds I would imagine. You don't have a clue where they shot it in any case.

Nate   #26   09:24 am Nov 04 2009

If the animal had run on to the road and gone through a windshield killing someone who would you blaim them.

Come on you arm chair critics stop complaining, these guys and girls (police) put themselves on the line for YOU all the time. The only people who should be ashamed are those of you who complain from the safety of your arm chairs.

Suzanne   #25   09:24 am Nov 04 2009

Thanks to the lack of detail in this news report I am left with questions such as: did the police liaise with the SPCA or other suitable organisations? As others have already said, the police are not trained in dealing with animals, so I would like to think that they made an effort to seek expertise and to achieve the best possible outcome for all, including the steer. And why was the steer shot when it was in the sports grounds, of all places? Certainly not an imminent risk to the public there, and these grounds were a safe place where it could run out of steam and calm down.

David   #24   09:20 am Nov 04 2009

Grant

Guts?

How much guts do you need to shoot a defenceless animal?? And to shoot it five times??? Surely these guys are bright enough to realise you need to hit a large animal between the eyes.....but obviously not.


Show 1-23 of 33 comments
Ad Feedback
Special offers

Featured Promotions